Can Johnson and Bolsonaro's brushes with Covid offer lessons for Trump?

Trump is the third of the world’s populist leaders to discover that bluster and wishful thinking are no match for the virus

When the White House insisted this weekend that Donald Trump was in “good spirits” had “mild symptoms” and was working hard, even as an obviously weakened president was being helicoptered to hospital, the upbeat official commentary all had a familiar ring in London.

When Boris Johnson fell ill from coronavirus in March, Downing Street was just as upbeat. The country was repeatedly told the condition was mild and the irrepressible prime minister was soldiering on with Churchillian bravado.

Even when he was hospitalised on the night of 5 April, the nation was assured he was in “good spirits” and it was merely a “precautionary” measure, just as the White House has insisted Trump’s helicopter trip to Walter Reed hospital on Friday evening was out of an “abundance of caution”.

Britain discovered later that the government’s account of Johnson’s illness had significantly downplayed its gravity. It came as a shock to the public when the prime minister was transferred to intensive care.

Trump is the third of the world’s populist leaders to discover that bluster and wishful thinking are no match for a virus that is indifferent to both. Brazil’s Jair Bolsonaro, who had dismissed the coronavirus as little more than a common cold and made a point at mingling with crowds of supporters, fell ill in July and spent three weeks in isolation before finally being declared Covid-free.

For reasons that have yet to be fully understood, each patient’s experience of coronavirus is different. It can be entirely without noticeable symptoms; it can be lethal. Bolsonaro seems to have had a mild form of the disease, which he put down to his “background as an athlete”. Johnson became seriously ill. He emerged from hospital in awe of the men and women of the NHS, saying: “I owe them my life.”

At 74, Trump is significantly older and less fit than Bolsonaro, 65, and the 55-year old Johnson. On the other hand, understanding and treatment of the virus has advanced since March. The trajectories of the other two leaders say little about what is now facing the US president.

The fortunes of Johnson and Bolsonaro, since their recovery, are also of limited use in predicting how it will affect Trump’s chances should he too be able to shake off the virus in time for the 3 November election.

Johnson did benefit from a bump in public esteem in March, though the YouGov polling group have pointed out that “the surge had already taken place by 23 March – four days before the PM announced he had Covid-19.

His chastened post-infection gratitude to the NHS did improve his popular image, but that advantage has since been frittered away through repeated Covid policy U-turns and the government’s continued dissembling and double standards, in the case of the insouciant wandering around England by Johnson’s special adviser, Dominic Cummings, while others were observing restrictions, for example.

Bolsonaro’s approval ratings remain high and have even seen a recent boost, probably driven in part by an emergency cash payment aimed at helping poorer families through the crisis, but analysts say his survival and rebound have also played a part.

“His quick recovery helped him consolidate the narrative that the virus isn’t really that bad,” said Oliver Stuenkel, an International Relations at the Getulio Vargas Foundation in São Paulo.

Unlike Johnson, the Brazilian president does not seem to have been temporarily chastened by the experience, telling a crowd in the Mato Grosso agricultural heartland recently: “This weak talk of staying at home is for sissies.”

Bolsonaro’s troubles still lie ahead of him. Brazil has been one of the countries worst-hit by the pandemic. Nearly 150,000 people have died. GDP is forecaste to contract by at least 5% and the end of the emergency cash payment will have to stop at some point.

Johnson is also confronting plummeting popularity and grim economic prospects. The UK has the worst toll from coronavirus in Europe, with 56,000 deaths and a second wave crashing over the country. But Johnson does not have to stand for election until 2024. Bolsonaro’s next election is not until 2022. The US election is a month away.

The degree to which Trump benefits from a post-Covid bounce will depend largely on the speed and manner of his hoped-for recovery.

That will affect whether he is seen as weakened – or will the myth of invincibility be reinforced? A sympathetic response to a pollster’s inquiry is different from the decision taken at the polling booth on whether to grant another four years to the same leader. In conditions that are entirely novel for the whole world, other leaders’ past is unlikely to prove prologue for Donald Trump.

Contributors

Julian Borger in Washington Sam Cowie in São Paulo and Peter Beaumont in London

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Donald Trump joins growing list of world leaders to contract Covid
US president and first lady’s diagnoses add to those of state leaders, lawmakers and royalty

Sam Levin

02, Oct, 2020 @8:59 AM

Article image
Brazilian minister tests positive for Covid after meeting maskless Johnson
Marcelo Queiroga sat close to Boris Johnson and Liz Truss at New York meeting

Tom Phillips in Rio de Janeiro

22, Sep, 2021 @10:05 AM

Article image
'Trump is tearing apart America': how the world sees the US protests
The racial tensions in the US have emboldened both President Trump’s allies and his enemies

Uki Goñi in Buenos Aires, Lily Kuo in Beijing, Jason Burke in Johannesburg,Tom Phillips in Rio de Janeiro, Sam Jones in Madrid, and Julian Borger in Washington

07, Jun, 2020 @7:28 PM

Article image
Boris Johnson calls for 'Trump deal' to fix Iran nuclear standoff
PM says president could come up with better pact, in apparent shift from European position

Peter Walker and Julian Borger in New York, and Kevin Rawlinson

23, Sep, 2019 @10:48 PM

Article image
Succession creator Jesse Armstrong criticises Trump and Johnson at Emmys
Writer lays into president and PM for their ‘crummy’ response to coronavirus

Mark Brown Arts correspondent

21, Sep, 2020 @1:02 PM

Article image
'A second Trump': Bolsonaro's offensive rhetoric adds to Brazil's discomfort
Supporters say his tendency to speak freely is sincere – but detractors call it a PR disaster

Tom Phillips Latin America correspondent

19, Aug, 2019 @4:00 AM

Article image
Trump: I have asked US pharma CEOs to offer Johnson experimental Covid-19 treatments
US president doesn’t name companies or treatments, but says they have arrived in London already

Julian Borger in Washington

07, Apr, 2020 @12:34 AM

Article image
'Same rhetoric': Bolsonaro's US visit to showcase populist alliance with Trump
Brazilian president shares some of Trump’s habits: he is active on Twitter and also dismisses negative media coverage as ‘fake news’

Dom Phillips in Rio de Janeiro

18, Mar, 2019 @6:30 AM

Article image
Boris Johnson: UK 'first in line' for free trade deal with US
UK foreign secretary emerges from meetings with Donald Trump’s aides with positive attitude towards future relationship

Julian Borger in Washington

09, Jan, 2017 @11:14 PM

Article image
Trump team thought UK officials ‘out of their minds’ aiming for herd immunity, book says
Trump officials tried to convince him to take threat seriously and British experts ‘oddly pessimistic’ on defeating virus, says book

Julian Borger in Washington

19, Aug, 2021 @5:50 PM