Trump's vote fraud claims go viral on social media despite curbs

President’s posts are top on Facebook as efforts to stop misinformation about election prove ineffective

False or misleading claims of electoral fraud are going viral on Twitter, Facebook and YouTube, even as the platforms continue to implement special measures aimed at reducing the spread of misinformation around the US presidential election.

Major social media platforms are nominally cracking down on misinformation, prominently displaying election results or appending warning labels to posts by Donald Trump that seek to undermine the validity of the vote.

According to social analytics platforms such as NewsWhip and CrowdTangle, however, claims about voting irregularities have become among the most-shared content on Facebook.

The top three posts are all from Donald Trump, according to CrowdTangle: one alleges “Fake Votes” in Nevada, where Trump trails Joe Biden by 36,000 votes; another claims Georgia, where Trump trails by 13,000 votes pending a recount, will be a “big presidential win”; and a third says “a very large number of ballots” will be affected by “threshold identification”, the meaning of which is unclear.

The top news stories on Facebook are also dominated by rightwing claims of “irregularities” and “fraud”, CrowdTangle data showed. Three of the top 10 posts are links from Trump to the far-right news site Breitbart, covering attorney general Bill Barr’s inquiry into “voting irregularities” and inquiries in Michigan and Georgia; a fourth is to rightwing site Newsmax, calling Pennsylvania’s situation a “constitutional travesty”.

Joining Trump in the top 10 are two posts from Republican media personality Dan Bongino backing the idea that election fraud is to blame for Trump’s loss, and a report from Fox News quoting Trump’s campaign team saying they are “not backing down”.

Ben Rhodes, former deputy national security adviser for the Obama White House, attacked Facebook directly for its failings. “At this moment, Facebook is spreading disinformation that is destroying confidence in American democracy so its multi-billionaire CEO can make some more money off of clicks and ads,” he wrote on Twitter. “Increasingly hard to understand how people of good conscience work there.”

The rightwing domination of Facebook’s platform is nothing new, but suggests that the company’s efforts to tamp down on misinformation following the election are starting to run out of steam.

Once the election was called for Biden, the top performing posts briefly changed: where Bongino, for instance, had been in the top 10 for the previous 37 days, the top performing posts on 7 November were led by the New York Times, CNN and NPR; the day after, CNN and NPR between them occupied seven of the top 10 slots.

That marked shift caused some, such as Mother Jones editor-in-chief Clara Jeffery, to wonder if Facebook had deliberately altered its algorithm to curry favour with the Biden administration. Others argued that it was more likely just a rare burst of activity from happy leftwing users on the site.

Ryan Broderick, author of the Internet culture newsletter Garbage Day, said the answer is probably in between the two.

“I absolutely do not think a website as large as Facebook, one led by people who seem completely out of touch with the daily goings on of their own user base, can immediately overnight throttle the majority of their content without basically turning the website off,” Broderick says.

“I think it’s much more likely that a bunch of American liberals got good news for the first time in four years and the platform’s thoughtless recommendation engine reacted accordingly.”

Major social media platforms continue to crack down on such misinformation, at least officially. Facebook has pinned the election results to the top of users’ newsfeeds, and is appending labels to Trump’s posts explaining the truth behind the election.

Twitter is no longer fully restricting Trump’s tweets, but continues to add labels warning users that: “This claim about election fraud is disputed”.

Even YouTube is taking action, demonetising videos from outlets such as the Trump-affiliated One America News Network that claim that “Trump won,” although the platform said it is not against its policies to seek to damage the electoral process unless it is done before the election occurs.

Contributor

Alex Hern Technology editor

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Opinion divided over Trump's ban from social media
Actions spark debate on free speech and whether chief executives of tech firms are fit to act as judge and jury

Alex Hern

11, Jan, 2021 @6:17 PM

Article image
Donald Trump suspended from Facebook indefinitely, says Mark Zuckerberg
Facebook CEO accuses president of intending to undermine peaceful transition of power

Alex Hern and Kari Paul

07, Jan, 2021 @6:59 PM

Article image
Biden article row shows how US election is testing Facebook and Twitter
Online giants felt forced to take unprecedented action as they struggle with role during divisive presidential battle

Alex Hern UK technology editor

15, Oct, 2020 @2:30 PM

Article image
The Guardian view of Trump's populism: weaponised and silenced by social media | Editorial
Editorial: Democracy has been threatened by commercialising the swift spread of controversy and lies for political advantage

Editorial

15, Jan, 2021 @6:24 PM

Article image
Donald Trump's move against Twitter factchecking could backfire
President’s planned weakening of social media law may not have effect he thinks it will

Alex Hern

28, May, 2020 @12:31 PM

Article image
Social media firms must face heavy fines over extremist content – MPs
An inquiry by the Commons home affairs committee condemns technology companies for failing to tackle hate speech

Owen Bowcott Legal affairs correspondent

01, May, 2017 @5:01 AM

Article image
China intensifies crackdown on social media with curbs on instant messaging

Ban on pseudonyms and republishing news without a licence among further checks on apps such as WeChat and KakaoTalk

Tania Branigan in Beijing

07, Aug, 2014 @2:32 PM

Article image
Turkish MPs to vote on bill that could block Facebook and Twitter
Law would give authorities power to regulate content on large social media sites

Bethan McKernan in Istanbul and Alex Hern

24, Jul, 2020 @12:12 PM

Article image
Israel and Hamas clash on social media
As in the field, Israel deploys superior strength and resources as both sides attack each other on Twitter, Facebook and YouTube

Harriet Sherwood

16, Jul, 2014 @5:18 PM

Article image
Von der Leyen: big tech firms need to be reined in despite Trump's exit
Internet giants that spread hate speech and conspiracy theories should face ‘democratic limits’, says European commission president

Daniel Boffey in Brussels

20, Jan, 2021 @5:36 PM