William Barr must quit over Trump-Stone scandal – former justice officials

More than 1,000 former US justice department officials, including some of the top government lawyers in the country, have called on attorney general William Barr to resign in the wake of the Roger Stone scandal.

Some 1,143 alumni of the Department of Justice posted to Medium on Sunday a group letter that tore into Barr for “doing the president’s personal bidding” in imposing on prosecutors the recommendation of a reduced sentence for Stone, a longtime friend of Donald Trump who was convicted of lying to and obstructing Congress and threatening a witness in the Russia investigation.

Barr, the officials said, had damaged the reputation of the department for “integrity and the rule of law”.

The searing letter is the latest twist in a rapidly spiraling constitutional crisis that began earlier this week when Barr imposed his new sentencing memo, slashing a seven- to nine-year proposed prison term suggested by career prosecutors. In the fallout, the four prosecutors who had handled the case resigned in disgust.

The letter carries weight because its signatories are exclusively drawn from past DoJ public servants. Among them are several former US attorneys appointed by both Republican and Democratic presidents and section chiefs of key elements of the justice department including its antiterrorism unit.

They write that it is unheard of for top leaders of the justice department to overrule line prosecutors in order to give preferential treatment to close associates of the president. They say that amounts to political interference that is “anathema to the department’s core mission and to its sacred obligation to ensure equal justice under the law”.

Barr’s action amounted to an existential threat to the republic, the former officials say: “Governments that use the enormous power of law enforcement to punish their enemies and reward their allies are not constitutional republics; they are autocracies.”

Barr tried to squash the perception he had been leaned on by Trump by calling on the president to stop tweeting about criminal prosecutions. He told ABC News such unrestrained comments were “making it impossible for me to do my job”.

But speculation continued to swirl that Barr had kowtowed to the president. Demoralisation spread rapidly through the DoJ, intensifying when it emerged that Barr has ordered outside prosecutors to re-examine criminal cases against Trump associates including former national security adviser Michael Flynn.

Despite palpable distress among both serving and former officials, and multiple warnings that Trump and Barr are threatening the very rule of law, the White House has continued to inflame the situation. Trump counsellor Kellyanne Conway on Sunday claimed the president was a victim of a “two-tier criminal justice system” that was actively undermining him and his associates.

Conway used Fox News Sunday to pour fuel on the fire. The truth, she claimed, was that far from making a dangerous intervention in criminal cases involving his friends and perceived enemies, Trump himself is the victim of the politicisation of the justice system.

“If you’re President Trump or people associated with him there’s prosecutions that have gone one way,” Conway said, alluding to the original sentence recommended for Stone which she contrasted with the decision announced by the justice department on Friday to drop charges against former FBI deputy director Andrew McCabe.

Directly contradicting her own claim that Trump, despite his “vast powers”, was not engaging in political interference in criminal cases, Conway proceeded to interfere in a criminal case. She called McCabe a “serial liar and leaker” and went on: “The president thinks that Andy McCabe should have been punished because he lied and lied several times to the investigators.”

McCabe, a deputy to fired FBI director James Comey and a key figure in the Russia investigation, was fired by Trump in March 2018, two days shy of retirement.

Trump and Barr seen in the White House in November.
Trump and Barr seen in the White House in November. Photograph: Nicholas Kamm/AFP via Getty Images

The furore over Trump ignoring protocols that have kept a distance between the White House and federal prosecutors since Watergate began when the president slammed the proposed sentence for Stone as “horrible and very unfair”. Hours later, Barr announced that he was imposing a reduced recommended sentence.

Trump then made the constitutionally dubious claim that as president he has the “legal right” to stick his finger into any criminal case.

On Saturday he duly re-entered the fray over McCabe, claiming falsely that DoJ inspector general Michael Horowitz recommended the former FBI man’s firing. Horowitz referred criticisms of McCabe to prosecutors but did not recommend dismissal.

On Sunday Marc Short, chief of staff to vice-president Mike Pence, made further contentious comments on CNN’s State of the Union. Like Conway, he claimed without evidence that criminal justice was skewed against the president.

“The scales of justice aren’t balanced any more,” he said, “when someone like Roger Stone gets a prosecution that suggests a nine-year jail sentence and candidly someone like Andy McCabe who also lied to federal investigators gets a lucrative contract here at CNN. People say, ‘How is this fair?’ and that’s the source of the president’s frustration.”

The row has also become a major talking point among Democrats vying to take on Trump in November. Former vice-president Joe Biden told NBC’s Meet the Press: “No one, no one, including Richard Nixon, has weaponised the Department of Justice” as much as Trump.

The crisis is personal for Biden, given the efforts to coerce Ukraine into investigating him and his son Hunter which led to Trump’s impeachment. Last week it was revealed that Barr has set up a channel to review information gathered in Ukraine by Trump lawyer Rudy Giuliani relating to the Bidens.

“To have a thug like Rudy Giuliani reporting to the attorney general – I mean this is, this is almost like a really bad sitcom,” Biden said.

“Any self-respecting Republican or Democratic top-flight lawyer would have just resigned by now, in my view. It’s just the things that are being done are so beyond the pale.”


Ed Pilkington in New York

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Barr agrees to testify to Congress amid growing outrage over Roger Stone case
Attorney general to go before House judiciary committee on 31 March as Democrats warn of ‘a crisis in the rule of law in America’

David Smith in Washington

13, Feb, 2020 @1:27 AM

Article image
Trump praises Barr after prosecutors quit Roger Stone case
President congratulated attorney general for ‘taking charge’ after prosecutors resigned when sentencing recommendation was overruled

Edward Helmore in New York

12, Feb, 2020 @1:07 PM

Article image
William Barr says Trump's tweets 'make it impossible to do my job'
Sense of crisis at justice department builds as Barr reportedly appoints outside prosecutor to scrutinize case against former Trump adviser Michael Flynn

Joan E Greve in Washington, Maanvi Singh and Edward Helmore

14, Feb, 2020 @7:46 PM

Article image
Trump AG Barr will escape impeachment thanks to 'corrupt' Republicans – Nadler
As attorney general fires New York attorney after bizarre standoff, House judiciary chair says he will cut $50m fro ‘personal budget’

Martin Pengelly in New York

21, Jun, 2020 @5:24 PM

Article image
In his assault on justice, Trump has out-Nixoned Nixon | Robert Reich
After Watergate, we worked for impartiality. Trump, Roger Stone and William Barr have dragged us back to the swamp

Robert Reich

16, Feb, 2020 @6:00 AM

Article image
The Roger Stone-Donald Trump controversy explained
The president is accused of acting like a monarch after the justice department called his friend’s sentence too harsh

David Smith in Washington

13, Feb, 2020 @6:32 AM

Article image
Donald Trump’s former attorney general William Barr to publish his memoirs
The book, to be published in March, will divulge details from his tenure as attorney general for George HW Bush and Trump

Martin Pengelly

18, Jan, 2022 @10:54 PM

Article image
William Barr defiant amid calls to resign over his handling of Mueller report
A letter from Robert Mueller expressed concern that the attorney general’s summary did not reflect ‘the nature of this office’s work’

Lauren Gambino in Washington

01, May, 2019 @8:21 PM

Article image
William Barr uses new book to outline case against Trump White House run
Former attorney general also describes tempestuous Oval Office meeting in which he rejected electoral fraud claims

Martin Pengelly in New York

28, Feb, 2022 @5:01 AM

Article image
Saving Justice review: how Trump's Eye of Sauron burned everything – including James Comey
With the storming of the Capitol, the fired FBI director’s earnest attempt to help America recover has been overtaken by events

Lloyd Green

10, Jan, 2021 @6:00 AM