Trump administration has executed more Americans than all states combined, report finds

The execution spree was a first in US history and stands contrary to the declining trend in death penalty practices

Donald Trump has added a morbid new distinction to his presidency – for the first time in US history, the federal government has in one year executed more American civilians than all the states combined.

In the course of 2020, in an unprecedented glut of judicial killing, the Trump administration rushed to put 10 prisoners to death. The execution spree ran roughshod over historical norms and stood entirely contrary to the decline in the practice of the death penalty that has been the trend in the US for several years.

The outlier nature of the Trump administration’s thirst for blood is set out in the year-end report of the Death Penalty Information Center (DPIC). In recent years, the annual review has highlighted the steady withering away of executions, all of which were carried out by individual states.

That pattern continued at state level in 2020, heightened by the coronavirus pandemic which suppressed an already low number of scheduled executions. Only five states – Alabama, Georgia, Missouri, Tennessee and Texas – carried out judicial killings. And only Texas performed more than one, producing the lowest number of executions by the states since 1983.

States carried out seven executions to the federal government’s 10. Despite the rash of federal killings, that still amounted to the fewest executions in the US since 1991.

Against that downward path, the actions of the Trump administration stand out as a grotesque aberration.

“The administration’s policies were not just out of step with the historical practices of previous presidents, they were also completely out of step with today’s state practices,” said Robert Dunham, DPIC executive director and lead author of its year-end report.

Part of the story was Trump’s willful refusal to take the coronavirus seriously. Unlike death penalty states, the federal government insisted on proceeding with executions. As a result, there was an eruption of Covid-19 cases at the Federal Correctional Complex in Terre Haute, Indiana which the DPIC report notes infected at least nine members of execution teams.

But the overwhelming story of the federal executions in 2020 was the disdain shown by the Trump administration towards established norms, and its determination to push the death penalty to the limits of decency even by standards set by those who support the practice.

Since Trump lost the election on 3 November, the federal government has put to death three prisoners: Orlando Hall, Brandon Bernard and Alfred Bourgeois. The last time a lame-duck president presided over an execution was in 1889, when the Grover Cleveland administration killed a Native American of the Choctaw Nation named Richard Smith.

All three Trump lame-duck executions involved black men. As the DPIC review points out, racial disparities remain prominent in the roll call of the dead, as they have for decades, with almost half of those executed being people of color.

The review exposes other systemic problems in the Trump administration’s choice of prisoners to kill. Lezmond Mitchell, executed in August, was the only Native American prisoner on federal death row. His execution ignored tribal sovereignty over the case and the objections of the Navajo Nation which is opposed to the death penalty.

The subjects of the federal rush to the death chamber included two prisoners whose offenses were committed when they were teenagers. Christopher Vialva was 19 and Bernard 18: they were the first teenage offenders sent to their deaths by the US government in almost 70 years.

The sharp contrast between the Trump administration’s aggressive stance and the dramatic reduction in executions at state level is underlined by the annual review of the Texas Coalition to Abolish the Death Penalty (TCADP), also released on Wednesday.

Texas, traditionally the death penalty capital of America, carried out three executions this year, down from nine in 2019. The most recent was on 8 July. Billy Joe Wardlow was 18 in 1993 when he committed robbery and murder.

“The fact that state legislators, juvenile justice advocates, neuroscience experts and two jurors from Wardlow’s trial had called for a reprieve based on what we know now about adolescent brain development make the circumstances of his arbitrary execution even more appalling,” said Kristin Houlé Cuellar, TCADP executive director.

There was some good news. In March, Colorado became the 22nd state to abolish the death penalty. Louisiana and Utah have not executed anybody in 10 years.

Joe Biden, the president-elect, has vowed to eliminate the death penalty. But until he enters the White House on 20 January Trump remains in charge. Three more federal inmates are set to die – including the only woman on federal death row – before he is done.

• This article was amended on 16 December 2020 to clarify that Richard Smith was a Native American of the Choctaw Nation.


Ed Pilkington in New York

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Impeachment inquiry: Nadler may add Mueller counts against Trump
Judiciary chair cites ‘real and present danger to the integrity of the next election’ as he prepares for critical hearing

Oliver Laughland

08, Dec, 2019 @3:20 PM

Article image
Trump calls for death penalties for drug dealers as focus of opioids plan
Trump’s policy rollout focuses on punishment for dealers and traffickers but doesn’t propose new legislation to combat the crisis

Amanda Holpuch, Jessica Glenza and Ben Jacobs in Washington

19, Mar, 2018 @9:03 PM

Article image
Trump blasts calls for impeachment of Brett Kavanaugh after new allegations
New York Times details known and new claims against judge, prompting
Harris, Castro and Sanders to lead calls for constitutional action

Martin Pengelly

15, Sep, 2019 @8:30 PM

Article image
Supreme court: Democrats rally in bid to stop Trump filling Ginsburg's seat
President, McConnell and Graham say nomination will proceed as Senate minority leader Schumer promises: ‘Nothing is off the table’

Lauren Gambino

20, Sep, 2020 @11:07 AM

Article image
Trump faces day of struggles over Betsy DeVos and travel ban
Democrats try to block Trump’s pick for education secretary in the morning, while the afternoon brings challenge to his immigration ban

Sabrina Siddiqui in Washington

08, Feb, 2017 @7:16 AM

Article image
White House dismisses Trump claim that flag burners should be imprisoned
President-elect says people who burn the US flag should get ‘loss of citizenship or a year in jail’, but Obama spokesman says act is protected by constitution

David Smith and Sabrina Siddiqui in Washington

29, Nov, 2016 @7:18 PM

Article image
Trump administration ignoring human rights monitors, ACLU tells UN
Watchdog delivers scathing appraisal to UN council as total of unanswered rapporteur requests rises to 22

Ed Pilkington in New York

18, Mar, 2019 @5:00 AM

Article image
Trump impeachment trial: Democrats' bids for new evidence dashed in marathon first day
Senate trial opens with arguments over proceedings as Democrats accuse Republicans of cover-up on Trump’s behalf

Lauren Gambino in Washington and Tom McCarthy in New York

22, Jan, 2020 @6:19 AM

Article image
Supreme court: Joe Biden accuses Trump and Republicans of abuse of power
Death of Ruth Bader Ginsburg rocks presidential race as Trump says he will pick a woman and McConnell promises vote

David Smith in Washington

21, Sep, 2020 @7:56 AM

Article image
Divided states of America: 62% say Trump is driving people apart, poll finds
Quinnipiac University poll finds president has negative 35%-59% overall approval rating as he tweets picture of himself replacing Obama in ‘eclipse’

David Smith in Washington

24, Aug, 2017 @3:00 PM