Columbia students threaten to withhold tuition fees amid Covid protest

  • Leader criticises ‘profit motive’ of elite New York institution
  • University defends actions on issues including anti-racism

Almost 1,800 students at Columbia University in New York are threatening to withhold tuition fees next year, in the latest signal to US academia of widespread preparedness to act on demands to reduce costs and address social justice issues relating to labor, investments and surrounding communities.

In a letter to trustees and administrators of Columbia, Barnard College and Teachers College, the students said: “The university is acutely failing its students and the local community.”

They accused the university of “inaction” since the start of the Covid-19 pandemic in March, when students began demonstrating against what they say are exorbitant tuition rates “which constitute a significant source of financial hardship during this economic depression”.

The letter referred to national protests over structural racism, accusing the university of failing to act on demands to address “its own role in upholding racist policing practices, damaging local communities and inadequately supporting Black students”.

Emmaline Bennett, chair of the Columbia-Barnard Young Democratic Socialists of America and a master’s student at Teachers College, told the Guardian the university and other colleges had made no effort to reduce tuition fees as they moved to remote learning models necessitated by pandemic conditions.

“We think it says a lot about the profit motive of higher education, even as the economy is in crisis and millions of people are facing unemployment,” Bennett said. “This is especially true of Columbia, which is one of the most expensive universities in the US.”

Demands outlined in the letter include reducing the cost of attendance by at least 10%, increasing financial aid by the same percentage and replacing fees with grants.

Such reforms, the letter said, should not come at the expense of instructor or worker pay, but rather at the expense of bloated administrative salaries, expansion projects and other expenses that do not directly benefit students and workers.

The university, the letter said, must invest in community safety solutions that prioritise the safety of Black students, and “commit to complete transparency about the University’s investments and respect the democratic votes of the student body regarding investment and divestment decisions – including divestment from companies involved in human rights violations and divesting fully from fossil fuels.

“These issues are united by a shared root cause: a flagrant disregard for initiatives democratically supported within the community. Your administration’s unilateral decision-making process has perpetuated the existence of these injustices in our community despite possessing ample resources to confront them with structural solutions.

“Should the university continue to remain silent in the face of the pressing demands detailed below, we and a thousand of fellow students are prepared to withhold tuition payments for the Spring semester and not to donate to the university at any point in the future.”

A Columbia spokesperson said: “Throughout this difficult year, Columbia has remained focused on preserving the health and safety of our community, fulfilling our commitment to anti-racism, providing the education sought by our students and continuing the scientific and other research needed to overcome society’s serious challenges.”

The university has frozen undergraduate tuition fees and allowed greater flexibility in coursework over three terms. It has also, it said, adopted Covid-related provisions including an off-campus living allowance of $4,000 per semester, to help with living and technology expenses related to remote learning.

Columbia is not alone in facing elevated student demands. In late August, for example, students at the University of Chicago staged a week-long picket of the provost’s house as part of a campaign to disband the university police department, Chicago’s largest private force.

The issue of student debt remains challenging. In a nod to progressives, President-elect Joe Biden last month affirmed his support for a US House measure which would erase up to $10,000 in private, non-federal loan debt for distressed individuals.

Biden highlighted “people … having to make choices between paying their student loan and paying the rent” and said such debt relief “should be done immediately”.

Some Democrats say relief should go further. In September, Senate minority leader Chuck Schumer and Massachusetts senator Elizabeth Warren co-authored a resolution which called for the next president to cancel up to $50,000 of outstanding federal loans per borrower.

At Columbia, students say their demands for Covid-related fee reductions are only a starting point.

“In the long-term, we need to reform the educational system entirely,” said Bennett. “We need to make all universities and colleges free, and to cancel all student debt to prevent enduring educational and economic inequalities.”


Edward Helmore in New York

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Q&A: what you need to know about America's student debt crisis
Bernie Sanders has a radical plan to wipe out undergraduate and graduate debt for all Americans. Here is what’s at stake

Miranda Bryant in New York

25, Jun, 2019 @5:00 AM

Article image
New plan makes it easier for US college students to apply for federal aid
Obama administration hopes to help ‘hundreds of thousands’ pay for college under new rules for Fafsa, which many say is needlessly complex

Lauren Gambino in Washington

14, Sep, 2015 @4:56 PM

Article image
College affordability in 2016: debt-free v tuition-free, explained
Sure, Hillary Clinton has a plan to make college affordable, but will it really be free? And how much is it going to cost government and universities – and voters?

Jana Kasperkevic in New York

11, Aug, 2015 @6:41 PM

Article image
Obama proposes new college ranking system in effort to bring down costs

President says new system would help students identify whether they were getting value for money in time of rising student debt

Dan Roberts in Washington

22, Aug, 2013 @4:15 PM

Article image
Want to lower your child's college bill? Tell him to live at home – or stop eating
Talk of the skyrocketing cost of tuition at America’s colleges and universities distracts from an equally pressing issue: rapidly rising room and board fees

Suzanne McGee

24, Sep, 2015 @11:01 AM

Article image
LIU lockout: US professors and students seen as disposable commodities
While the historic 12-day lockout of students and faculty from the Brooklyn campus has ended, the disquieting significance of that action will live on

Rose Hackman

15, Sep, 2016 @2:49 PM

Article image
Vassar College receives $1m award for support of low-income students
Jack Kent Cooke Foundation gives inaugural prize to New York institution, saying Vassar has more than doubled financial aid budget and grown in diversity

Alan Yuhas in New York

07, Apr, 2015 @3:10 PM

Article image
America's Black colleges take measured approach in bid to weather Covid crisis
HBCUs have seen relatively smooth fall semesters, which school leaders say is testament to student cooperation and a strong sense of community

Lauren Aratani in New York

17, Oct, 2020 @8:00 AM

Article image
Columbia students oppose installation of 'hideous' Henry Moore sculpture
The famous British artist’s Reclining Figure resembles a ‘poorly formed pterodactyl’ and would ruin aesthetics of library’s landscape, petitioners said

Amanda Holpuch in New York

05, Apr, 2016 @8:33 PM

Article image
The Columbia University student strike is about far more than tuition | Indigo Olivier
Rather than waiting for the adults in the room to relieve our debt burden, students are taking matters into their own hands

Indigo Olivier

18, Feb, 2021 @12:19 PM