'He pulled the wool over our eyes': workers blame Trump for moving jobs overseas

Trump pledged to stop ‘offshoring’ but manufacturing workers at GE and Carrier say Trump has broken his campaign promise

Next Friday, Eddie Martin will work his last day at the General Electric plant in Salem, Virginia, after working there for seven years.

GE announced in June last year it was shutting down the Salem plant, which opened in 1955. More than 250 employees were affected, as those jobs will be sent overseas to India. Martin is one such employee.

He says: “It’s horrible. You have over 200 people losing their jobs just so the company can build a $200m plant in India and pay those people $3.50 an hour.”

Martin plans to go back to school and work in marine mechanics. He says: “This has left a bad taste in my mouth. I will hopefully never work in manufacturing ever again.”

Promises to save US manufacturing and prevent American jobs moving abroad were a key part of Donald Trump’s 2016 campaign. But since Trump took office in January 2017, nearly 200,000 jobs have been moved overseas, based on Trade Adjustment Assistance certified petitions.

That includes firms doing business with the US government. According to research by Good Jobs Nation, 14,444 jobs were moved abroad by the top 100 federal contractors in the United States in Trump’s first two years in office. The rate of “offshoring” among the top 100 federal contractors actually exceeds rates throughout the Obama administration and the majority of the Bush administration, aside from 2008 when the economic recession hit.

Harley Shaiken, a labor professor at UC Berkeley, says: “There has been relatively little change since Trump took office. Plant closings are devastating. For the worker, it is damaging and it can create the kind of stresses that cause divorces, break up families, and disrupt the ability to care for parents or young children. This kind of disruption creates far-reaching anxiety and anger and we saw that politically expressed in 2016.”

That leaves workers like those at the Virginia GE plant with a feeling of being lied to as they watch their livelihoods disappear.

“It’s taking away a livable wage in the area,” says Darryl Castillo, who worked at the plant for six years and will be among the last wave of layoffsscheduled for early December.

Castillo was involved in union negotiations to try to prevent the plant from closing, but the union’s concession offerings to save GE money ended in failure. He says: “It really didn’t matter what the number in savings was. They were going to close it no matter what, and that was very disappointing. They gave us a general hope of ‘help us help you to keep it open’ – but it was a bold-faced lie.”

GE confirmed the Virginia jobs will be outsourced to India. “This action is difficult and does not reflect the performance, dedication, and hard work of our employees,” a spokesperson said in an email. “We remain committed to work with the union to support affected employees, nearly half of whom are eligible for retirement.”

For some of the tens of thousands of workers affected by plant closures and job offshoring across the United States, Trump’s 2016 promises to save their jobs and stop their plants from closing have left a sense of betrayal.

“I believed it. I thought he was going to save some jobs. He pulled the wool right over our eyes and he’s still doing it till this day,” says 58-year-old Susan Cropper, who worked at a Carrier plant in Huntington, Indiana, for 31 years before the plant closed and she was laid off along with over 700 employees in March last year.

After being laid off, it took her eight months to find another job, but it pays much less than what she was making at Carrier. “Not only did I lose my job, now I’m not going to work long enough to build another retirement somewhere else,” she says.

Trump had promised throughout his presidential campaign to save the nearby Carrier plant in Indianapolis, which has laid off hundreds of workers since he made a deal with the company in December 2016. The deal was supposed to prevent those jobs from being sent abroad to Carrier’s plant in Mexico.

“I gave the best years of my life to that corporation that threw me out like I was a rag doll,” Cropper adds. “Carrier was rewarded with more government contracts, tax breaks, and the executives get to keep their lifestyle and line their pockets. It’s been a really unfair process.”

Carrier did not respond to multiple requests for comment.

During a presidential campaign stop in Burlington, Iowa, Trump declared: “I will be the greatest jobs president that God ever created.” But critics claim that when it came to stepping up to prevent a Siemens turbine plant from closing in Burlington in December, Trump was nowhere to be found.

“I sent a letter to the White House and got a response that this is a state or local matter, so they brushed us off,” says 64-year-old Robert Morrison, one of 125 workers who were laid off when the Burlington plant closed. “We felt abandoned and betrayed not only by Siemens, but by our elected officials, from Trump down.”

According to Morrison, many workers either moved away or took jobs with pay cuts and long commutes. He was forced to retire early.

“This was my job of 31 years. I loved that job,” he says. “I was hoping my son or grandson and nephews could work there some day. We made a fantastic product used around the world. Now the turbines are going to be made in India and Czech Republic.”

A Siemens spokesperson said the plant closed because of market decline.


Michael Sainato

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Trump threatens to hit all $505bn of Chinese imports with tariffs
President indicates readiness to slap tariffs on the entirety of Chinese goods, saying it is ‘the right thing to do for our country’

Edward Helmore

20, Jul, 2018 @5:28 PM

Article image
Mulvaney: Trump 'now' realizes he cannot fire Fed chair Powell
Trump denies asking advisers about removing central bank chief but acting chief of staff’s words could undermine claim

Guardian staff and agencies

23, Dec, 2018 @6:36 PM

Article image
‘When is this going to end?’: US factory town devastated by jobs moving overseas
The Viatris plant in West Virginia has been making pharmaceuticals since 1965 – but it’s closing down and laying workers off

Michael Sainato

20, Jun, 2021 @7:00 AM

Article image
Elkhart, Indiana finally sees 'Obama recovery' – but many say RVs saved city
Obama visited the ailing Indiana city four times in 16 months at the peak of the economic crisis, and pledged part of a $787bn stimulus package to help – but recovery was slow until US demand for RVs revived the city’s old stalwart

Chris McGreal in Elkhart, Indiana

02, Apr, 2016 @11:00 AM

Article image
US interest rate rise almost certain after bumper jobs growth
President Trump quickly claims credit for 235,000 jobs created last month as pressure on Federal Reserve grows to order first of three predicted rises

Phillip Inman and Sam Thielman

10, Mar, 2017 @6:15 PM

Article image
Donald Trump's top economic adviser Gary Cohn quits
Adviser, who reportedly strongly opposed imposition of tariffs, becomes latest high-profile departure from Trump administration

Dominic Rushe in New York and David Smith and Lauren Gambino in Washington

07, Mar, 2018 @1:06 PM

Article image
The US is on the edge of the economic precipice – and Trump may push it over | Robert Reich
Government shutdowns hurt millions. Great depressions hurt even more. History suggests real pain is round the corner

Robert Reich

23, Dec, 2018 @6:00 AM

Article image
Trump announces tariffs on Mexico until 'immigration remedied'
US to place 5% tariff on goods as Mexico president says ‘social problems aren’t resolved with taxes’

Lauren Gambino in Washington, David Agren in Mexico City and agencies

31, May, 2019 @9:34 AM

Article image
Trump hails economy and tells workers: 'start looking' if you want a better job
President boasts of growth and suggests workers who don’t like their jobs should move elsewhere ‘in our great economy’

Erin Durkin in New York

20, Sep, 2018 @1:17 PM

Article image
Donald Trump is lashing out at Mexico but his real fight is at home | Phillip Inman
Democrats are turning a president enraged at the blocking of his border wall into an unhinged beast

Phillip Inman

02, Jun, 2019 @12:49 PM