'That's not a bag': man with dog bends New York subway rule and gets denied

MTA rules state dogs must be ‘enclosed in a container’ but one conductor seems to think a dog in a sack pushes that definition

In 2016, the Metro Transit Authority (MTA) in New York banned people from bringing their pets on the subway. The only exception was for animals “enclosed in a container and carried in a manner which would not annoy other passengers”.

But New Yorkers love a loophole, and so while the MTA probably meant dogs carried in purpose-built crates, subway riders quickly got inventive with tote bags and rucksacks – pushing the law to its high-fashion limits.

On Friday, however, a man found that he couldn’t quite squeeze his dog through the loophole. He was filmed by journalist Will Sabel Courtney on the subway platform at Carroll Street in Brooklyn, arguing with a train conductor about whether he was allowed to bring his dog onboard. The dog was in a burlap sack, which the man was able to hoist over his shoulder as if it was just another New Yorker tote, but the driver felt there wasn’t enough material to call it a bag.

Saw this guy arguing with an @MTA conductor about bringing his dog on the subway. Dude said the dog’s burlap sack was a bag; conductor said nope, wouldn’t let him on the train. @Gothamist @A_W_Gordon @2AvSagas #NYCSubway pic.twitter.com/qjgN5anKV3

— Will Sabel Courtney (@WillSCourtney) April 7, 2019

The conductor can be heard saying “That’s not a bag, that’s not a bag” before driving the train away.

It’s unusual for the MTA to refuse an animal in this way. As the wonderful Instagram account bagdogs documents, almost any kind of bag will do.

In June 2018, the MTA briefly attempted a more hardline approach, advising a commuter on Twitter to call 911 if they saw a dog outside a bag on the subway. Twelve hours later, following a small outcry, they quickly walked backed the policy, saying it was a mistake and passengers should only call 911 in an emergency.


Sam Wolfson

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Fecal bacteria ‘rampant’ on New York sidewalks, researchers find
Co-author advises taking off your shoes at the door after studying dog poop on Upper East Side

Edward Helmore

18, Feb, 2023 @5:23 PM

Article image
What are the most common dog names in New York City? Ciao, Bella!
New Yorkers love their dogs – so perhaps it’s not surprise that they name them as if they were children, with Bella and Max among the most popular monikers

Mona Chalabi

22, Jul, 2017 @10:00 AM

Article image
Animal welfare advocates hail New York law banning sale of pets at retail stores
The legislation aims to end the ‘puppy mill-to-pet store pipeline’ for abusive breeders of dogs, cats and rabbits

Victoria Bekiempis in New York

25, Dec, 2022 @9:00 AM

Article image
Dogs could join people at restaurant patios, as New York senate passes bill
While restaurants can choose whether to allow pets – who must be leashed and with their owners at all times – not everyone wants to dine with man’s best friend

Alan Yuhas in New York

15, May, 2015 @4:52 PM

Article image
AOC finds her perfect puppy – which other politicians have found theirs?
The congresswoman says her French bulldog will come with her to the office and to town halls, making them an ideal pair

Poppy Noor

07, Jan, 2020 @8:57 PM

Article image
Dog walkers at Howard University infringe on 'black Mecca', students say
In an online forum, someone said they were told to leave by students while walking their dog on campus

Dream McClinton in New York

25, Apr, 2019 @10:00 AM

Article image
Emergency calls for pets eating cannabis surge 765% over past decade
ASPCA says it received more than 1,800 calls in 2018, with the legalisation of cannabis products largely to blame

Joe Bish

05, Feb, 2019 @3:26 PM

Article image
Man who invented labradoodle says it's his 'life's regret'
Wally Conron says he created a ‘Frankenstein’s monster’ as unethical breeders now make hybrids with serious health problems

Matthew Cantor in San Francisco

26, Sep, 2019 @1:31 PM

Article image
You changed me: I rescued my dog Augusta, but really she rescued me
In this new series, noted authors will write about the person who changed them forever. This week, Elizabeth Wurtzel discovers the pet love of her life

Elizabeth Wurtzel

08, May, 2016 @12:00 PM

Article image
Dog hailed as hero cloned by California company

Trakr, a trained sniffer dog, had led rescue workers to the last survivor found after the 9/11 attacks

Ed Pilkington in New York

18, Jun, 2009 @6:11 PM