Critics fear Amazon's minimum wage hike will distract from its other issues

The world’s most powerful retailer will pay more, but its impact on the economy may mean more struggles for low-wage workers

In 1967, just a year before his assassination, Dr Martin Luther King launched the Poor People’s Campaign to “to demand that the government address itself to the problem of poverty”. Five decades on little has changed for low-wage workers.

Minimum wage increases in the US have failed to even keep pace with inflation. A full-time minimum wage worker in 1968 would have earned $20,600 a year (in 2017 dollars), according to the Economics Policy Institute (EPI). A worker paid the federal minimum wage would have only earned $15,080 working full time in 2017. Even the record-breaking run in employment growth has so far failed to raise the wages of low-paid workers.

Sign up for the US morning briefing

Last week there seemed to be a sign of change. Amazon became the latest company to promise a $15 minimum wage for its workers in the US (and an increase to £10.50 an hour in London and £9.50 across the rest of the UK).

Despite the irony that the move was being made by a company run by Jeff Bezos, the world’s richest man, the decision was hailed as a major victory by advocates of a higher minimum wage. Even senator Bernie Sanders, a probable 2020 presidential candidate, congratulated Amazon. Sanders recently introduced the aptly acronymed Stop Bad Employers by Zeroing Out Subsidies (Bezos) act that would tax companies whose workers are paid so poorly that they rely heavily on government benefits.

What Mr. Bezos has done today is not only enormously important for Amazon’s hundreds of thousands of employees, it could well be a shot heard around the world. I urge corporate leaders around the country to follow Mr. Bezos' lead.

— Bernie Sanders (@SenSanders) October 2, 2018

Amazon was the latest US company to agree to a wage hike after a series of high-profile protests over wages in the US. Disney and retailers Target and Costco have made similar moves. Now the pressure is on for other big employers, notably Walmart and McDonald’s, to follow suit. But without a federally mandated increase in the minimum wage, many workers will still struggle to make ends meet and Amazon critics worry that the move will distract from other issues associated with the world’s most powerful retailer.

“This is good for low-wage workers,” said Stacy Mitchell, co-director at the Institute for Local Self-Reliance (ILSR). “But we should not let it distract us from Amazon’s impact on the wider economy.”

In 2016, ILSR released a report that calculated Amazon needed roughly half as many employees as traditional bricks and mortar stores to sell the same amount of goods. “And that was a 2016 report using 2015 data,” she said. Every generation of Amazon warehouse is more automated than the last and in China, where the trend is ahead of the US, giant warehouses can use as few as four employees, maintaining robots, to process orders.

While it’s popular to worry about the rise of the robots – King himself warned of the “impact of automation and cybernation” back in 1967 – Mitchell believes it is probably not worth getting too hung up on automation. Similar threats have come and gone in the past without dramatically reducing the workforce.

The problem this time is different. “I am far more worried about Amazon’s impact from its increasingly monopolization of the market,” she said. “In history when we have had new technology, there has traditionally been a flood of companies and competition. But what we have seen recently is the collapse of small and mid-sized businesses. Amazon is not the only factor in that, but it’s the largest.”

The wage rise comes as Amazon is buffeted by ever stronger regulatory headwinds. Senator Elizabeth Warren, another likely Democratic presidential candidate, and European commissioner Margrethe Vestager are increasingly concerned about Amazon’s power. The company has also faced multiple reports of poor pay and work conditions at Amazon and criticism of its demands forlarge tax breaks, said EPI economist Ben Zipperer.

The old argument that Amazon is a net good because it allows people to buy stuff cheap online “is not really cutting it any more”, he said.

But while it is a clear positive that low-wage Amazon workers will get more money, the impact of lax policies on anti-trust issues and soft labor laws mean low-wage workers will still continue to struggle to get meaningful wage increases with or without Amazon’s backing, he said.

While we watch to see whether other big companies will follow Amazon’s move, Mitchell said: “It’s good that this has happened. But it is also important that we don’t take our eye off the ball.”


Dominic Rushe in New York

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Amazon raises minimum wage for US and UK employees
Company says it has ‘listened to its critics’ as it increases US rate to $15 and UK to £9.50

Richard Partington

02, Oct, 2018 @12:13 PM

Article image
Twenty years after the dotcom crash, is tech’s bubble about to burst again?
Dramatic swings in stock prices are causing serious alarm – but these huge companies are no longer fragile startups

Dominic Rushe in New York

12, Sep, 2020 @3:00 PM

Article image
$10,000 a second? Amazon’s results could be amazing
The retailer’s quarterly figures will have received a huge boost from lockdown sales

Rupert Neate

18, Apr, 2020 @11:05 PM

Article image
Amazon makes play for online grocery market - but will it deliver?

Analysts fear wheels could fall off the online giant's bandwagon when delivering groceries but some detect an ulterior motive

Rory Carroll in Los Angeles

15, Aug, 2014 @2:12 PM

Article image
Which big names in business are 2018’s ones to watch?
Can Nicky Morgan avoid a ‘no deal’ Brexit? Can Michael O’Leary keep Ryanair aloft? And will Jeff Bezos stay the world’s richest man?

Simon Goodley

28, Dec, 2017 @1:05 PM

Article image
Walmart splashes $3.3bn on in hopes of jolting online retail sales
Superstore giant has fallen well off the pace of online retail leader Amazon and hopes Jet’s chief executive will provide ‘entrepreneurial sprit’

Rupert Neate in New York

08, Aug, 2016 @4:46 PM

Article image
What will it take to make Amazon a great place to work?
Companies like Walmart have responded to reputation risks in the past, but Amazon’s initial response to allegations of employee abuse doesn’t look promising

Tom Liacas

19, Aug, 2015 @4:38 PM

Article image
Amazon could give the world a gift on its 25th birthday – by paying more tax
Turnover in Britain was nearly £2bn yet the company paid just £1.7m in corporation tax. It’s time for Jeff Bezos to cough up

07, Jul, 2019 @6:00 AM

Article image
Ten billionaires reap $400bn boost to wealth during pandemic
Covid-19 pushed many into poverty but brought huge benefits for some of the wealthiest, renewing calls for fairer taxes

Rupert Neate Wealth correspondent

19, Dec, 2020 @4:00 PM

Article image
Mighty Amazon looks all but unassailable as Covid continues
Jeff Bezos’s company is set for sales topping $100bn last quarter, and while rivals are nibbling, its position looks secure

Jasper Jolly

31, Jan, 2021 @12:05 AM