Hawaii's evacuees on why they live under a volcano: it's affordable

As the Kilauea volcano erupts, Puna district residents reflect on the threat to an area of affordable housing – and great beauty

Imago Mana had always wanted to move to Hawaii. But it was mostly a dream for the computer technology teacher from Virginia, who put it in the back of her mind.

“I always thought: I can’t do that now, Hawaii is too expensive.” Then, around the age of 50, she began getting debilitating migraines. She lost her job, her house, her car. She moved back in with her mother. As she was trying to figure out what to do next, a friend told her about a part of Hawaii where life was a little different, a little wilder. In the district of Puna, Mana found a raw vegan commune where she could work in exchange for living in an off-the-grid hut on 50 acres of jungle. She bought a one-way ticket and boarded a plane four days later.

“The minute I got off the plane I knew I was home,” Mana said.

  • A lava flow on Makamae Street in Leilani Estates.

Mana, now 59, has since moved out of the commune and was among those evacuated on Thursday because of the continuing eruptions of the looming Kilauea volcano. Dramatic videos of lava slowly pouring through streets and inching over the land have attracted international attention.

Mana has lived in the Leilani Estates subdivision, which is located in Pahoa, for three years rent-free as a caretaker. It’s one of the reasons she has been able to live on her $1,400-a-month disability checks. Now, she’s one of many trying to replace the affordable housing she lost in Pahoa – where many depend on the low cost of living. In exchange for living in the lava zone, often without infrastructure such as city water or sewer lines, she and others have been able to make a life for themselves without much money.

Ground cracking extends across Highway 130 in Puna, Hawaii.
Ground cracking extends across Highway 130 in Puna. Photograph: Handout/US Geological Survey/Getty Images

Puna district and the town of Pahoa, where homes have been destroyed by lava, are among the least expensive places to live in the islands. It’s common for three-bedroom, two-bath houses on an acre of land to sell for around $250,000, according to Cathy Fedak, a realtor from Pahoa who also lived in Leilani Estates.

“There are a lot of literally starving artists here,” said Amedeo Markoff, who opened the Puna Gallery and Gift Emporium in March to sell handcrafted wood pieces and local art. Markoff added that with news of the volcano scaring off tourists, a community where many struggle to make ends meet is in even greater peril.

Markoff said for the residents, businesses and artists, affordable housing is key.

“There are a lot of reasons why people want to live in Puna,” he said “But the No 1 reason is the beauty. The No 2 reason is that real estate is priced so that your average Joe can live here.”

That’s certainly the case for Corey Hale, who came to Pahoa from California nearly four years ago and purchased a one-acre plot of land just outside Leilani Estates for $15,000.

A fissure eruption fountains more than 200ft into the air, consuming all in its path, near Pahoa.
A fissure eruption fountains more than 200ft into the air, consuming all in its path, near Pahoa. Photograph: Bruce Omori / Paradise Helicopters/EPA
More volcanic damage.
More volcanic damage. Photograph: AP
  • Top: a fissure eruption fountains more than 200ft into the air, consuming all in its path, near Pahoa. Bottom: video of more volcanic damage.

Hale, who is 54 and a former crisis counselor, intended to build a house on her thickly forested jungle plot at some point, but needed to wait until she got the money together. In the meantime, she lived in a “gypsy wagon” given to her by a neighbor, went to work fixing leaks and building an outdoor shower out of old wood pallets, and lit oil lamps to see at night.

But having her own land and an inexpensive off-the-grid lifestyle became even more important when she became disabled and saw her monthly income reduced to $340 in food stamps and $338 in cash. Luckily, Hale said, she never went hungry because of the abundance of avocado, mango, papaya and banana trees around her property.

“I created a really good life for myself,” she said. “It was simple, but it was good – life is messy here, but it’s real and it’s beautiful.”

Hale, who was evacuated on Thursday, said she hoped she’d be able to return home soon. For now, she’s staying at a Red Cross shelter in Pahoa. She’s been reluctant to make plans because no one knows how long the eruption will continue or how long residents will be kept out of their neighborhoods. And on Tuesday, just as things had become quiet, Hale got another shock when two new volcanic fissures opened up near her property. She fears that even if she can return, the eruption will have changed the place she knew and loved.

“With lava, after it’s gone, it’s like you come back to a different planet,” she said. “I had to say goodbye to my land when I left, and my heart hurts.”

Henrietta “Kaonohiokalani” Jeremiah, a musician, retiree and native Hawaiian, also lives in Leilani Estates and is waiting to see if and when she will be able to go back home. She purchased her one-acre plot of land for about $20,000, then built a multi-sided home, similar to a yurt, on the property.

Evacuees help carry items retrieved from a home at an emergency shelter.
Evacuees help carry items retrieved from a home at an emergency shelter. Photograph: Mario Tama/Getty Images
Residents of the Leilani Estates and Lanipuna Gardens subdivisions pick up supplies at a community donation center.
Residents of the Leilani Estates and Lanipuna Gardens subdivisions pick up supplies at a community donation center. Photograph: Terray Sylvester/Reuters
h
A volunteer delivers pet supplies to an evacuation center in Pahoa. Photograph: Terray Sylvester/Reuters
  • Top: evacuees help carry items retrieved from a home at an emergency shelter. Left: residents of the Leilani Estates and Lanipuna Gardens subdivisions pick up supplies at a community donation center. Right: a volunteer delivers pet supplies to an evacuation center in Pahoa.

For her, she said, living in Pahoa offed the chance to have a deep, spiritual relationship with the land, far away from the more urbanized parts of the islands. Despite the current crisis, she said, living in the area with other artists has made life a rich and shared experience.

Markoff said he was growing a bit weary of the way the disaster has been treated in the news.

“There’s an idea that people are crazy to live here,” he said. “But many people grew up here and have been here their whole lives.” Plus, he said, the area is a melting pot that still feels like the old Hawaii, far away from the development that has dramatically changed other parts of the islands. And, he said, even the volcano has a certain magnetism.

“It’s pretty amazing to be so close to new land being made,” he said. “It’s a very powerful thing.”

Footage of the eruption.
Footage of the eruption. Photograph: CCTV+

Contributor

Breena Kerr in Pahoa

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
'The entire habitat is gone': Hawaii's natural wonders claimed by lava
The Kilauea eruption has wiped out rare sites and whole ecosystems. As the island mourns a tragedy, it also accepts the brutal cycle of nature

Breena Kerr

20, Jun, 2018 @8:00 AM

Article image
Hawaii volcano eruption prompts fears of disastrous blow to tourism
Hawaii’s $2.4bn industry is struggling in the wake of the Kilauea Volcano eruptions, with bookings for May through July down 50%

Breena Kerr in Hawaii

27, May, 2018 @6:00 AM

Article image
Hawaii's Kilauea volcano spews lava - video

Bright red ribbons of lava spewed out at the Kilauea volcano in Hawaii. Kilauea, which has been erupting since 1983, is one of the world's most active volcanoes

05, Aug, 2011 @2:24 PM

Article image
Hawaiian town rocked by up to 800 earthquakes daily as volcano erupts
Residents say constant tremors from the nearby Kilauea eruption have turned the village of Volcano into a ‘ghost town’

Breena Kerr in Hawaii

14, Aug, 2018 @10:00 AM

Article image
Welcome to Hawaii's 'plastic beach', one of the world's dirtiest places
Hawaii has long evoked images of a Pacific paradise but Kamilo Beach, located on the Big Island, presents a starkly different reality

Liz Barney on Kamilo Beach and Michelle Broder Van Dyke in Honolulu

10, Jan, 2020 @11:00 AM

Article image
Hawaii's daredevil surfers grab their boards to ride hurricane's epic waves
As Hurricane Lane pummelled the Hawaiian islands this week, surfers headed out into the swell, despite official warnings

Breena Kerr in Maui

26, Aug, 2018 @12:59 PM

Article image
'Lava haze' and 'vog': toxic volcanic gases prompt health fears in Hawaii
Potentially deadly plumes of volcanic gas and particles are polluting the Big Island in the wake of recent eruptions

Breena Kerr in Hilo, Hawaii

22, May, 2018 @7:29 PM

Article image
Record rain triggered 2018 Kīlauea volcano eruptions, says study
Research on events in Hawaii suggests climate crisis could lead increase eruptions around world

Damian Carrington Environment editor

22, Apr, 2020 @3:00 PM

Article image
Hawaii man, 75, found dead after apparently falling into volcano
Man believed to have fallen from closed area of national park, where visitors have attempted to glimpse glowing lava lake since September eruption

Dani Anguiano and agencies

04, Jan, 2022 @7:09 PM

Article image
World weatherwatch: Spring brings wildfires, storms and ash plumes
Thunderstorms have killed at least five in the mainland US, while fires plague eastern Russia and volcanic activity has been disrupting aviation in Hawaii

Judith McConnell (MetDesk)

23, May, 2018 @8:30 PM