Trump invokes Nixon and McCarthy in NYT White House counsel report rant

Donald Trump went on the offensive on Sunday, invoking the spectres of Richard Nixon and Joseph McCarthy, starkly polarising figures from American history, in a frenzied attack on the New York Times.

The president’s rage was stoked by a bombshell report that said White House counsel Don McGahn has cooperated extensively with special counsel Robert Mueller in his investigation of Russian election interference, links between Trump aides and Moscow, and potential obstruction of justice.

The president both called the Times report “fake” and confirmed its substance.

Repeating a spelling mistake made in his initial response on Saturday, when the report was published online, Trump wrote: “The failing [New York Times] wrote a Fake piece today implying that because White House Councel [sic] Don McGahn was giving hours of testimony to the Special Councel [sic], he must be a John Dean type ‘RAT.’”

Dean was White House counsel to Nixon during Watergate. He testified against the president, pled guilty to obstruction of justice and was held at an army base. He spoke on Saturday to Slate.

“Don McGahn is doing exactly the right thing,” Dean said, “not merely to protect himself, but to protect his client. And his client is not Donald Trump; his client is the office of the president.”

The Times said McGahn had spoken to Mueller’s team for a total of 30 hours, on the advice of Trump’s first lawyers in the Russia investigation. McGahn shared some information investigators would not otherwise have known, the Times said, about events including Trump’s attempts to fire Mueller.

In a separate report, Reuters said a person familiar with the matter did not believe McGahn provided incriminating information about the president and had not seen or heard anything that amounted to obstruction of justice by Trump.

Nonetheless, Trump said on Sunday that the Times “wrote a story that made it seem like the White House Councel [sic] had TURNED on the President, when in fact it is just the opposite – & the two Fake reporters knew this. This is why the Fake News Media has become the Enemy of the People. So bad for America!”

Dean tweeted a reply, saying he had “trouble using the title Mr President for someone installed by Putin”. He doubted Trump had “ANY IDEA what McGahn has told Mueller” and added: “Also, Nixon knew I was meeting with prosecutors, b/c I told him. However, he didn’t think I would tell them the truth!”

Trump has used the “enemy of the people” tag repeatedly, attacks decried by the media for potentially encouraging violence. Last month, Times publisher AG Sulzberger said he had asked the president to stop.

It didn’t work. On Sunday the president also claimed, without evidence, that “some members of the media are very Angry at the Fake Story in the New York Times” and had “actually called to complain and apologize”. He also complained about a “disgusting new Board Member” at the Times, apparently a reference to the writer Sarah Jeong.

Dean was not impressed by Trump’s behaviour.

“I see a lot of similarity in the bungling,” he told Slate. “Watergate was not a carefully planned crime and cover-up. It was one bungled event after another. I see the same thing happening with Trump.”

In his Twitter rant, Trump went 20 years back in time from Watergate, to the “red scare” of the 1950s. “Study the late Joseph McCarthy,” the president wrote of the Wisconsin senator who led efforts to criminalise “un-American” political beliefs, “because we are now in period with Mueller and his gang that make Joseph McCarthy look like a baby!”

The president has an acquaintance in common with McCarthy: the rightwing lawyer Roy Cohn, who worked for the senator before mentoring Trump as he rose to prominence in New York.

John Dean is sworn in by Senate Watergate committee in a photo from June 1973.
John Dean is sworn in by Senate Watergate committee in a photo from June 1973. Photograph: AP

Trump’s hyperventilation prompted responses from top national security figures. On CNN’s State of the Union former CIA and National Security Agency director Michael Hayden expressed amazement that the president had likened Mueller, a widely respected former FBI director, to McCarthy.

“Joe McCarthy was a demagogue,” he said. “We haven’t had a public syllable from Bob Mueller in more than a year.”

Trump aimed at other familiar targets, writing: “What about the Brennan, Comey, McCabe, Strzok lies to Congress, or Crooked [Hillary]’s Emails!”

This week, in a widely criticised move, Trump stripped former CIA director John Brennan of security clearance. FBI director James Comey (fired by Trump in an event looked at by Mueller regarding potential obstruction of justice), fired deputy FBI director Andrew McCabe and fired FBI agent Peter Strzok are among those reported under threat of similar treatment.

Former director of national intelligence James Clapper told CNN on Sunday he had heard expressions of concern from within the Trump administration. Brennan told NBC’s Meet the Press he might take Trump to court.

In classic pugnacious style, Trump’s current lawyer in the Russia investigation, Rudy Giuliani, accused Mueller of leaking the McGahn story as an act of desperation in the absence of evidence on which to hang charges. Giuliani also told NBC Trump had encouraged McGahn to talk to Mueller, “is happy that he did, and is quite secure that there is nothing in the testimony that will hurt the president”.

The Times, however, said McGahn was in part motivated by fear of becoming a scapegoat if wrongdoing was discovered.

Slate asked Dean if McGahn should resign.

“More likely he would be fired than resign,” he said. “Trump does not like people doing the right thing.”

He added: “I think there is good reason for McGahn to believe that Trump would throw him under the bus, since Trump throws almost everyone under the bus … self-preservation is a real motive. At times, I felt it. When I first tried to go in and blow up the Watergate cover-up, I was really worried about the president and the office.”


Martin Pengelly and Ed Pilkington in New York

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Mueller report: special counsel delivers findings of Trump-Russia inquiry
Submission to US attorney general signals end of criminal inquiry that has prompted furious attacks from Trump and his allies

Jon Swaine in New York and Lauren Gambino in Washington

22, Mar, 2019 @10:55 PM

Article image
Trump tweets raise fears for Mueller but White House says he's safe
Tweet claims FBI deputy never took notes when meeting president as Jeff Flake says president ‘seems to be building towards’ firing special counsel

Joanna Walters in New York

19, Mar, 2018 @12:04 PM

Article image
Mueller report did not find Trump campaign conspired with Russia, attorney general says
William Barr sends four-page letter to Congress showing special counsel did not clear Trump of obstruction of justice

Oliver Laughland and Jon Swaine in New York and David Smith in Washington

25, Mar, 2019 @7:11 AM

Article image
Former FBI head Robert Mueller to oversee Trump-Russia investigation
Trump attacks ‘single greatest witch hunt of a politician’ in US history as Mueller appointed special counsel to head federal inquiry

Tom McCarthy, Jon Swaine and Ben Jacobs

18, May, 2017 @12:50 AM

Article image
Robert Mueller: who is the Trump-Russia investigation's special counsel?
The former FBI director’s service of presidents from both parties undoubtedly contributed to his selection as special counsel during an intense political crisis

Jon Swaine in New York

17, May, 2017 @11:34 PM

Article image
Barr delivers Mueller report summary to Congress on Sunday
Trump in Florida as Washington waits on tenterhooks for news of special counsel’s findings

Oliver Laughland and Martin Pengelly in New York

24, Mar, 2019 @7:23 PM

Article image
Mueller drew up obstruction indictment against Trump, Michael Wolff book says
Spokesman for special counsel denies existence of document at heart of revelation in Fire and Fury sequel, Siege: Trump Under Fire

Edward Helmore in New York

28, May, 2019 @2:35 PM

Article image
Robert Mueller breaks silence to insist he did not exonerate Trump
Special counsel gives nine-minute statement on his published report and says he did not have confidence Trump ‘clearly did not commit a crime’

David Smith in Washington

29, May, 2019 @6:03 PM

Article image
White House as crime scene: how Robert Mueller is closing in on Trump
There is a grand jury in Washington DC. The special counsel’s team is full of experts in financial crime. On Russia, the president can feel the net closing

Julian Borger in Washington

05, Aug, 2017 @12:45 PM

Article image
Giuliani rails against Mueller report as Democrats mull Trump impeachment
Trump lawyer claims ‘nothing wrong with taking information from Russians’ and denies obstruction of justice

Victoria Bekiempis and Martin Pengelly in New York

21, Apr, 2019 @5:11 PM