New York Times editor says Trump attacks on press are out of control

  • Trump on Washington Post: ‘story after story is made up garbage’
  • Dean Baquet: Times and Post will ‘fight to the death on daily stories’

Donald Trump’s attacks on the press are “out of control” and damaging “the civic life and debate of the country”, the editor of the New York Times said on Sunday.

Dean Baquet was responding to a tweet in which the president attacked his main rival.

“The Washington Post is far more fiction than fact,” Trump wrote. “Story after story is made up garbage – more like a poorly written novel than good reporting. Always quoting sources (not names), many of which don’t exist. Story on John Kelly isn’t true, just another hit job!”

The Post story in question concerned the reportedly waning power of the White House chief of staff, John Kelly, and what the paper called “recurring and escalating clashes [with] the president [that] trace the downward arc of Kelly’s eight months in the White House”.

The Post said the story was based on “interviews with 16 administration officials, outside advisers and presidential confidants, many of whom spoke on the condition of anonymity”.

On Saturday Axios also carried a story on Kelly, reporting that he threatened to quit on 28 March. The website cited “sources familiar with events” and quoted an unnamed “senior administration official” who played the story down. It also said Kelly had threatened to quit many times before.

Trump has regularly complained about anonymously sourced press reports and books and attacked media targets including the Times, CNN and NBC. Baquet appeared on CNN’s media talkshow, Reliable Sources.

Trump’s antipathy, he said, “hurts the media. I think the president missed the part of high school civics where the first amendment was explained, and where the role of free and independent press was explained. And I think this is debilitating.”

The president regularly tweets messages that correspond to content on Fox News, his preferred cable network.

Before his tweet attacking the Post, he wrote: “The FBI closed the case on Hillary [Clinton], which was a rigged investigation. They exonerated her even before they ever interviewed her, they never even put her under oath.....” and much more. So true Jesse! @WattersWorld.”

Baquet said: “I think the press will keep doing what it does, but … if [Trump] creates a culture where Fox & Friends and Jesse Watters are regarded as serious journalism, and the New York Times and the Washington Post are not, he will have done longstanding, harmful effect on the country.

“It’s out of control. It’s out of control and his advisers should tell him to stop, because it’s actually affecting the civic life and debate of the country.

“When I first heard it, I thought, OK, a year ago, it felt like an exaggerated version of what we’ve heard from presidents forever. But it’s out of control.”

Regarding the Post’s story on Kelly, Baquet said “every one of those deeply reported inside stories about the White House from the Times or the Post have all been verified. When [former Trump strategist] Steve Bannon talked about life inside the White House, when he left the White House, he verified them. [Former chief of staff] Reince Priebus came out, he verified them.

“This stuff so far is all held up.”

Baquet also said the Times and the Post would continue to “fight to the death on daily stories … [because] it’s healthy for the countries to have institutions fighting to the death. But we believe in the same principles. And I will defend them on these principles and they will defend me on these principles.”

Baquet was behind the New York Times’s decision to stop attending the White House Correspondents’ Association Dinner, an annual Washington event at which the press and the president exchange humorous barbs. Trump did not attend last year and the White House has indicated he will skip it again this year.

“I pulled us out of the White House correspondents’ dinner when I was the Washington bureau chief because I hated the image of journalists, editors and powerful politicians seeming chummy,” Baquet said.

He added that the White House Correspondents’ Association “ought to rethink their mission” because “our image should be [that] we have a tense and questioning relationship with government, not that we sip champagne with them on Saturday.”


Martin Pengelly

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Trump blasts back after New York Times publisher decries 'enemy of the people' attacks
President and Sulzberger each say other is damaging America while Trump’s rhetoric is also criticized by Washington Post editor Baron

Martin Pengelly in New York

30, Jul, 2018 @12:25 AM

Article image
New York Times editor says Trump has put his reporters’ lives at risk
Dean Baquet decries abuse of journalists and defends not calling president racist

Jim Waterson Media editor

18, Nov, 2019 @7:00 AM

Article image
Trump attacks New York Times journalist over Michael Cohen article
Trump lashed out on Twitter after Maggie Haberman contributed to a story suggesting Cohen might cooperate with federal investigators

Lauren Gambino in Washington

21, Apr, 2018 @3:56 PM

Article image
Jared Kushner pressured Washington Post to fire editor over Russia, book says
Marty Baron says Trump’s son-in-law leaned on Post publisher to withdraw support of Russia election interference investigation

Martin Pengelly in Washington

27, Sep, 2023 @1:50 PM

Article image
Trump lashes out at New York Times over Mexico deal revelations
Criticism of report that said Mexico agreed concessions months ago comes ahead of new book by CNN’s Acosta

Oliver Milman in New York

10, Jun, 2019 @1:10 PM

Article image
Martin Baron: 'We took Donald Trump seriously from the beginning'
The Washington Post’s executive editor on breaking Trump’s Access Hollywood hot mic moment and the surprising positives of working beside software engineers

James Silver

30, Oct, 2016 @2:00 PM

Article image
The Guardian view on the press and Trump: speaking truth to power | Editorial
Editorial: On Thursday, hundreds of US news organisations are publishing editorials opposing the president’s attacks on the press. The Guardian stands with them


15, Aug, 2018 @10:59 PM

Article image
Trump dismisses Bob Woodward’s book: ‘Lies and phony sources’
President tweets that Fear, Woodward’s portrayal of a chaotic and dysfunctional White House, is a ‘con of the public’

Matthew Weaver in London and Joanna Walters in New York

05, Sep, 2018 @2:18 PM

Article image
New York Times editor: we failed to do our job after 9/11
Dean Baquet admits that US mainstream media did not ask ‘hard questions’ about Bush administration’s prosecution of so-called war on terror

Roy Greenslade

28, Jan, 2015 @8:49 AM

Article image
Ex-NYT editor rejects Trump praise and says words 'taken out of context'
Trump seizes on coverage of new book by Jill Abramson that argues paper contains ‘unmistakably anti-Trump’ news pages

Lois Beckett

05, Jan, 2019 @9:26 PM