Jury deadlocked on criminal charges for first officer tried in Freddie Gray's death

Baltimore police officer William Porter is the first of six facing trial for his role in the spine-injury death of Gray

Midway through its second day of deliberations, the jury reported it was deadlocked on criminal charges against Baltimore police officer William Porter for the death of Freddie Gray, signaling a lack of certainty in the closely watched trial.

Judge Barry Williams told the jury to go back and continue deliberating. He reread the instructions to the jurors and told them they must reach a unanimous decision on each of four counts, the most serious of which is involuntary manslaughter. Porter is the first of six officers facing trial for his role in the spine-injury death of Gray, who was dragged by officers and transported in restraints but without a seatbelt in the back of a police van.

The majority-black jury had been deliberating for nine hours when they sent a note to Williams indicating a deadlock. City officials are preparing for widespread protest should Porter be acquitted. In a motion Tuesday, defense lawyers went so far as to ask for a mistrial and a change of venue, citing a letter from the CEO of Baltimore schools, who noted that unrest might follow from a verdict. The motion was quickly dismissed.

In closing arguments Monday, prosecutors argued that Porter had several opportunities to prevent Gray’s death and failed to do so.

Janice Bledsoe, deputy state’s attorney, punctuated her argument for convicting Porter of involuntary manslaughter and other charges with the refrain “I need a medic,” returning again and again to Gray’s requests for medical assistance.

“‘I need a medic.’ How long does it take to click a seatbelt and click a radio and ask for a medic?” Bledsoe said. “Is two, three, four seconds worth a life? That’s all it would have taken.”

Defense lawyers stressed that the state had failed to produce a witness to show that Porter had not acted as a “reasonable officer”, the standard by which jurors were instructed to judge Porter’s actions.

“I understand that there is a need to find someone accountable, to hold someone responsible for the death of Freddie Gray,” defense attorney Joseph Murtha said.

“Whether you may be offended by the way the police put him in [the van], it isn’t part of your consideration.”


Baynard Woods in Baltimore

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Baltimore officer could have prevented Freddie Gray's death, prosecutors say
Attorneys said in a forceful closing argument Monday that officer William Porter could have requested medical assistance for Gray in a matter of seconds

Baynard Woods in Baltimore

14, Dec, 2015 @9:34 PM

Article image
Freddie Gray's family calls for peace after police officers charged over death
Family lawyer calls charges ‘momentous step on road to justice for Freddie’ while stepfather Richard Shipley says: ‘Whoever comes to our city, come in peace’

Raya Jalabi and Oliver Laughland in Baltimore

01, May, 2015 @11:09 PM

Article image
Freddie Gray death: remaining charges dropped against police officers
Baltimore prosecutors failed to obtain a conviction after four trials, meaning there will likely be no criminal accountability for Gray’s death from a ‘rough ride’

Baynard Woods in Baltimore

27, Jul, 2016 @5:38 PM

Article image
Baltimore riots: police delay release of report on Freddie Gray's death – as it happened
Live coverage as Baltimore begins to take slow steps towards returning to normal

Ben Jacobs in Baltimore

29, Apr, 2015 @9:01 PM

Article image
Baltimore protesters stage city hall rally after charges over death of Freddie Gray
Celebrations of charges against six officers continue after relatively quiet night as one marcher says: ‘It’s great that everyone is coming together. I hope for no more rioting’

Raya Jalabi and Oliver Laughland in Baltimore and Alan Yuhas in New York

02, May, 2015 @8:32 PM

Article image
In Freddie Gray's neighborhood, more than a third of households are in poverty
While Baltimore’s unemployment rate soars above the national percentage, Sandtown-Winchester’s economic state could cripple cities in parts of US

Jana Kasperkevic in New York

28, Apr, 2015 @8:59 PM

Article image
First officer on trial in Freddie Gray's death takes stand in his own defense
The defense directed questions to show Baltimore officer William Porter was responsible, while the prosecution aimed to prove he was unreliable

Baynard Woods in Baltimore

10, Dec, 2015 @12:14 AM

Article image
Dropped charge for highest ranking officer in Freddie Gray case
Prosecutors dropped a misconduct in office charge against Lt Brian Rice Thursday, but he still faces four other charges, including manslaughter

Baynard Woods in Baltimore

07, Jul, 2016 @7:51 PM

Article image
Freddie Gray charges: what is 'depraved heart murder'?
The most severe charge brought against the six Baltimore police officers in the death of Gray, it carries a sentence of up to 30 years. But what does it mean?

Alan Yuhas in New York

01, May, 2015 @8:05 PM

Article image
Maryland court ruling could delay Freddie Gray officer trials for months
State’s second-highest court rules it will not hear arguments in William Porter’s appeal case until March, after which court has months to reach decision

Baynard Woods in Baltimore

12, Jan, 2016 @10:31 PM