Prince Charles 'worried about changing laws of royal succession'

Prince of Wales reportedly met Whitehall officials to share his concerns about fast-tracked changes to the UK's constitution

The Prince of Wales is said to have raised his fears of "unintended consequences" of the government rushing to change the laws of succession to the throne.

In a private meeting with Richard Heaton, permanent secretary of the Cabinet Office, Charles reportedly voiced concerns over what would happen if his grandchild, due next year, were to marry a Roman Catholic.

The succession to the crown bill, which will change the ancient laws governing the royal line of succession to ensure the Duke and Duchess of Cambridge's first child would succeed to the throne regardless of gender, has been published and is expected to be fast-tracked through parliament at the earliest opportunity.

The planned reforms, presented by the deputy prime minister, Nick Clegg, would also allow the couple's first-born to marry a Catholic – though not to be one, without having to renounce the right to succeed.

Sources told the Daily Mail Charles outlined to Heaton concerns that the move, which he is said to support in principle, could damage the relationship between church and state.

Echoing concerns raised previously by constitutional experts and theologians, Charles reportedly raised the issue of what would happen if his grandchild's future spouse were Catholic and insisted any children be raised as Catholics. This would either bar their child from the throne or compromise the monarch's role as supreme governor of the Church of England.

Canon law does not stipulate that children from a marriage between a non-Catholic and Catholic must be raised in the Catholic faith. But the Catholic must make a declaration "that I will sincerely undertake that I will do all that I can within the unity of our partnership to have all the children of our marriage baptised and brought up in the Catholic church".

The Mail reports that Charles was told during the meeting that any issue could be resolved by negotiations with the Vatican as and when the matter arose. It says Charles found this answer unsatisfactory and unconvincing.

He is also reportedly concerned about the lack of detailed consultation over the bill, which was announced on the day the Duchess of Cambridge made news of her pregnancy public. The paper said it was thought the Queen had not been informed of the decision to legislate until very soon before the bill was published, and her son and grandson appeared not to have been consulted at all, "which rankled with the Prince of Wales".

Charles is also said to have raised concerns over the effects of the proposed abolition of primogeniture, where a male sibling takes precedence over an older female, on other dukedoms and on the hereditary peerage in the UK.

Neither the Cabinet Office nor Charles's official office would comment on details of any meeting. A Clarence House spokesman said it was a matter for government.


Caroline Davies and Juliette Jowit

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Prince Charles and his 36 private meetings with cabinet ministers

Full extent of lobbying by the Prince of Wales since the coalition came to power includes seven meetings with David Cameron

Ben Quinn

11, Aug, 2013 @11:46 PM

Article image
Royal couple will aim to give prince a normal childhood
The new parents must balance media interest with the desire for privacy for their child. Not an easy thing these days

Caroline Davies

22, Jul, 2013 @8:45 PM

Article image
Prince George racks up the most presents in royal gifts tally
Surfboard and toy boat among toddler’s haul while Queen received a miniature throne and Prince Harry an automatic rifle

Caroline Davies

14, Jan, 2015 @2:58 PM

Article image
Cost of Prince Charles rises to £2.2m

Extra 11% on Prince of Wales' funding from taxpayer attributed to longer flights and last year's royal wedding

Rob Evans

29, Jun, 2012 @7:26 PM

Article image
Royal tour of Australia is all about creation of soft propaganda

Catherine and William's visit to Uluru – 30 years after Charles and Diana – reminds us how durable the royals can be

David Marr

22, Apr, 2014 @2:56 PM

Article image
Prince Charles: 'black spider memos' to ministers could spark second veto
Further secret lobbying letters could set cabinet against judiciary again if judges rule in favour of publication 'in public interest'

Rob Evans

26, Dec, 2012 @3:39 PM

Article image
Politics Weekly podcast: Regional elections and the AV referendum

Julian Glover, Anne Perkins, Antony Green and Mike Smithson discuss next week's local elections. Plus: an Australian angle on the AV campaign and a political take on the royal wedding

Presented by Tom Clark and produced by Vivienne Perry

28, Apr, 2011 @2:43 PM

Article image
Prince William welcomes brother to 'sleep deprivation society'
Duke and Duchess of Sussex could announce baby son’s name on Wednesday

Caroline Davies

07, May, 2019 @4:08 PM

Article image
The coalition needs to be cautious over plans to add gender equality into the royal line of succession | Michael White
Michael White: The coalition plans to introduce gender equality in the royal line of succession. It should tread with caution

Michael White

07, Jan, 2013 @11:01 AM

Article image
Charles and Camilla pay tribute on anniversary of Queen Elizabeth’s death
Monarch recalls late queen’s ‘long life, devoted service and all she meant to so many of us’

Caroline Davies

08, Sep, 2023 @2:16 PM