David Cameron criticises Hilary Mantel over Duchess of Cambridge speech

PM brands Booker-prizewinning author as 'misguided' after media outrage over Mantel's language

David Cameron has criticised Hilary Mantel as "completely misguided and completely wrong" after the Booker prize-winning author described the Duchess of Cambridge as a "plastic" princess.

In an interview with the BBC in Delhi, the prime minister lavished praise on the duchess and said Britain should be proud of her.

Cameron said of Mantel: "I think she writes great books, but I think what she's said about Kate Middleton is completely misguided and completely wrong.

"What I've seen of Princess Kate at public events, at the Olympics and elsewhere is this is someone who's bright, who's engaging, who's a fantastic ambassador for Britain. We should be proud of that, rather than make these rather misguided remarks."

Mantel said in a speech that the duchess appeared to have been "designed by a committee and built by craftsmen, with a perfect plastic smile and the spindles of her limbs hand-turned and gloss-varnished". The speech, titled Royal Bodies, was given at a London Review of Books event at the British Museum on 4 February.

Newspaper reports interpreted the remarks as a direct attack on the duchess. The Daily Mail called it a "venomous attack on Kate", and the Sun said it was a "bizarre rant".

Mantel was not commenting on the backlash, but a spokesman for the author urged people to read or listen to the speech "because it puts everything in its full context".

A good chunk of the speech focused on how the media reported on the monarchy and their every movement. Mantel reflected that when the duchess's pregnancy became known, the duchess had been filmed running a few paces with a hockey stick.

"BBC News devoted a discussion to whether a pregnant woman could safely put on a turn of speed while wearing high heels," Mantel said. "It is sad to think that intelligent people could devote themselves to this topic with earnest furrowings of the brow, but that's what discourse about royals comes to: a compulsion to comment, a discourse empty of content, mouthed rather than spoken."

She compared the monarchy to pandas: "Our current royal family doesn't have the difficulties in breeding that pandas do, but pandas and royal persons alike are expensive to conserve and ill-adapted to any modern environment. But aren't they interesting? Aren't they nice to look at?"

On Tuesday the duchess made her first public appearance since she presented the BBC sports personality of the year award in December. She visited the Hope House addiction treatment centre in south London.

Cameron's intervention may raise eyebrows after he referred to the duchess as "Princess Kate". Since her marriage to Prince William she has preferred to be known as Catherine and is officially known as a duchess rather than a princess.

Contributors

Nicholas Watt in Delhi and Mark Brown

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Hilary Mantel hits back in Duchess of Cambridge row

Booker Prize winner says she has no regrets about comments in British Museum lecture that led to a media storm

Cass Jones

08, Mar, 2013 @12:04 AM

Hilary Mantel: bring up the royal bodies | Editorial

Editorial: Lecture was not an attack on the Duchess of Cambridge but a thoughtful and sympathetic reflection on royal woman down the ages

Editorial

19, Feb, 2013 @9:24 PM

Article image
'Plastic' Kate: Hilary Mantel exposes the image not the person
'Threadbare attributes' of 'mannequin' duchess form Hilary Mantel's critique of monarchy and its message

Zoe Williams

19, Feb, 2013 @6:40 PM

Article image
Hilary Mantel: why novelists are deliberately misunderstood
The Booker-prize winner's speech about royal wives and the Duchess of Cambridge has been spun by the press and politicians. It's the latest in a long line of literary misinterpretations, from Martin Amis to Anne Enright, writes Sam Leith

Sam Leith

19, Feb, 2013 @5:32 PM

Article image
Hilary Mantel says political debate has been replaced by abuse and bullying
Writer reveals campaign of hate she had to endure after a public lecture she gave on the commodification of royalty

Mark Brown arts correspondent

16, Apr, 2014 @6:18 PM

Article image
Hilary Mantel v Kate: a story of lazy journalism and raging hypocrisy | Hadley Freeman

Hadley Freeman: Daring to discuss the way in which the media manipulates women is the real cause of this latest tabloid outrage

Hadley Freeman

19, Feb, 2013 @3:06 PM

Article image
Hilary Mantel always looks so uber-cosy it is like finding out George Orwell did not actually like pigs
How Samantha Cameron might have looked back on last week's row over Hilary Mantel's description of the Duchess of Cambridge as a "plastic" princess

As seen by Catherine Bennett

27, Feb, 2013 @7:00 AM

Article image
Kate speech, hate speech and Hilary Mantel's dissection of Royal Bodies

Award-winning novelist's comments about 'plastic' Duchess of Cambridge spark spasm of press fury

Mark Brown, arts correspondent

19, Feb, 2013 @2:19 PM

Article image
Duchess of Cambridge visits addiction charity following 'plastic' comment - video

Duchess of Cambridge makes first public appearance with baby bump on visit to Hope House women's rehab centre in south London

19, Feb, 2013 @2:42 PM

Article image
Hilary Mantel attacks critics over BBC’s Margaret Thatcher story broadcast
Exclusive: Author makes spirited response to Mail on Sunday after corporation decides to air The Assassination of Margaret Thatcher on Radio 4’s Book at Bedtime

Caroline Davies

14, Dec, 2014 @8:47 PM