Mother of missing Moors murder victim dies without knowing son's burial place

Winnie Johnson never stopped hoping that one day she would find where Brady and Hindley buried her son. Her death yesterday ends almost 50 years of 'mental torture'

Throughout the decades that he haunted her, Winnie Johnson had only one question for Ian Brady: "Where is my son Keith?"

Of the five victims Brady is known to have killed with his lover, Myra Hindley, only Keith's body has never been found. But until her death in the early hours of Saturday morning, Mrs Johnson never stopped hoping she would find her son's remains. The 78-year-old widow had expressed the hope that one day Keith's coffin would be carried in a horse-drawn hearse to a Manchester cemetery. For years she kept a simple wooden cross on her mantelpiece that she dreamed of placing on Keith's grave.

Her son was abducted on his way to visit his grandmother on 16 June 1964. As with the four other victims whom Brady and Hindley lured to their deaths and sexually tortured, Keith was buried on Saddleworth Moor near Manchester.

"The thought of him alone there for eternity fills my every waking moment with dread," his mother once said. "I didn't retire until I was 70 because I had to stay busy to occupy my mind. Keith was 12 when I lost him, a little boy with broken spectacles and a shiny new bike who loved nature and collecting coins. That's how I remember him because, of course, he never reached manhood. A combination of that image of innocence, and the fact that I feel so guilty about him being alone the day he was snatched, meant I had to fight Brady right to the end. There was only him and me left. I was determined never, ever to relent."

In 1987 Brady was taken back to the moor as police sought the remains of Keith and another victim, Pauline Reade, but only Reade's remains were found.

Professor Malcolm MacCulloch, one of Brady's former psychiatrists, has suggested the visit was an attempt by Brady, now 74, to exercise control over his victims' families from within the confines of a high-security mental hospital.

"It's just possible that Ian Brady was on the moor and checked the site without letting on, as it were," MacCulloch told the BBC in 2004. "Final control is the possession of the body. 'I know, you don't know. You want to know and I'm not going to tell you'."

Professor Jeremy Coid, another psychiatrist who treated Brady, told a Channel 4 Cutting Edge documentary, to be screened on Monday night, that "withholding information as to where bodies might be buried is an enormously pleasurable sense of control for somebody who is obsessed with control".

The effects of battling Brady left psychological scars on Mrs Johnson. "Ian Brady has tortured me for over 40 years and enjoyed every minute of it," she said. "He is like Hannibal Lecter, getting pleasure from mind games. He did his best to drive me mad, even though behind bars. I felt at times that his mind was in search of my soul. Many times he nearly pushed me over the edge."

But time was running out and last December Mrs Johnson said she wanted to hear face-to-face from Brady where her son was buried.

In July, gravely ill with terminal cancer, she renewed her plea, saying in a letter to Brady that her dying wish was to find Keith's body. Her recent move to a hospice prompted Channel 4 to bring forward the Cutting Edge documentary Ian Brady: Endgames of a Psychopath in which it is alleged Brady had left a sealed envelope for Mrs Johnson to be opened in the event of his death.

"No one can verify the contents of the envelope, and therefore what information it does or does not contain, but given the enormity of the implications as suggested by Brady's letter we felt we had a responsibility to inform the family," explained Emma Cooper, Channel 4 documentaries commissioning editor. "Winnie's poor health was foremost in our decision-making and this is why we have decided to bring forward the broadcast of the film and make the existence of the envelope public."

Jackie Powell, who has been Brady's mental health advocate for the last 15 years, told the programme that she received a letter of instruction and a sealed envelope from Brady via his solicitors. She told the programme: "He says that he doesn't wish to take secrets to his grave and that within the sealed envelope is a letter to Winnie Johnson and that within that is the means to her possibly being able to rest."

But doubts are growing about whether the letter, said to have been written 10 years ago, still exists or ever existed. Police have searched Powell's house but to no avail. Powell has claimed she handed it back to Brady, but a search of his room at Ashworth Psychiatric Hospital has proven fruitless.

One possibility is that, in keeping with his sadistic character, the letter was a hoax, an act of malice by a psychopath immune to the damage he had done.

"A lost child is something which destroys part of you at the time and then the rest of you slowly," Mrs Johnson said. "It can and does drive you mad, properly mad. And it also makes you want to kill the perpetrator. I would like to tie Ian Brady to a stake in the street and tear bits of flesh off him, torturing him as slowly and as completely as he has tortured me. And then when he was dead I'd happily bang the nails into his coffin myself. I don't have to explain why. The grief never goes away."


Jamie Doward

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Family of Moors murders victim Keith Bennett vow search for body will go on
Tragic death of Bennett's mother Winnie Johnson, aged 78, will not halt quest to find body of 12-year-old

Jamie Doward and Mark Townsend

18, Aug, 2012 @11:06 PM

Article image
Police yet to find remains of Moors murder victim Keith Bennett in dig
Amateur sleuth claims to have come across the body of the boy murdered by Ian Brady and Myra Hindley

Robyn Vinter North of England correspondent

01, Oct, 2022 @4:37 PM

Moors murderer contacts victim's mother

Staff and agencies

21, Feb, 2006 @10:31 AM

Article image
Moors murderer 'has revealed burial site of boy killed in 1964'

Ian Brady gave details of the location of Keith Bennett's body to one of his long-term visitors, police say

Jo Adetunji

17, Aug, 2012 @12:33 AM

Article image
Hunt for Moors murders victim takes new twist with arrest
Ian Brady's advocate held after telling documentary maker of letter to be given after death to mother of Keith Bennett

Helen Carter and Dan Sabbagh

17, Aug, 2012 @7:19 PM

Article image
Moors murder: Keith Bennett’s brother voices frustration over search
Alan Bennett says he has been left ‘confused’ by author’s claims to have found body after dig yields no results

Robyn Vinter North of England correspondent

02, Oct, 2022 @4:31 PM

Brady offers to help search for victim
Moors murderer Ian Brady has offered to return to the scene of his crimes to help trace the body of his missing victim Keith Bennett, it was revealed last night.

Rebecca Allison

22, Dec, 2001 @1:45 AM

Article image
Police end search for remains of Moors murders victim Keith Bennett
Detectives say hunt for body of 12-year-old who was killed by Ian Brady and Myra Hindley in 1964 has been unsuccessful

Helen Carter

01, Jul, 2009 @9:12 AM

Article image
New search after body found in Moors murders case: archive, 23 October 1965
The Guardian, 23 October 1965: Police hunt for evidence in Moors murders case

By our own Reporter

23, Oct, 2015 @4:30 AM

Moors murders: time to stop pursuing the case | Editorial

Editorial: Nothing is solved and nothing is gained by continuing to investigate this horrible case in this way any longer


17, Aug, 2012 @7:10 PM