Zara Aleena was failed by a privatised probation service | Letters

Sue Hobbs outlines the inaccurate risk assessments of the young woman’s murderer, while Sarah Compton says nothing has changed since the murder of her brother in 2015

Your article (Probation service and ministers have ‘blood on hands’, say Zara Aleena’s family, 24 January) identifies the undeniable case work failures by the National Probation Service (NPS) that led to the appalling murder of Zara Aleena. But what it overlooks is the impact of the privatisation of the probation service. In 2014, it was split in two, with private “community rehabilitation companies” supervising low- to medium-risk cases, and the pre-existing NPS supervising high-risk cases.

As HM Inspectorate of Probation’s independent serious further offence review of Jordan McSweeney spells out, in 2021 McSweeney was the responsibility of the profit-driven London Community Rehabilitation Company. Despite McSweeney’s known risk being present in custody, such as his possession of weapons and threatening behaviour, as well as subsequent information received about the serious risk he posed to women, the company assessed him to be medium-risk.

With inaccurate risk assessment a key feature of the case, the inspectorate concluded that, had McSweeney been correctly assessed, the planning for the release, licence conditions and action taken by the NPS when he failed to turn up for appointments could have been considerably different.

The funding arrangements for the private, profit-oriented companies provided a monetary incentive for employees not to assess cases as high-risk, as this would result in them being passed on to the state-owned NPS, and a loss of income. Consequently, risk was routinely downgraded. If anyone has “blood on their hands”, it is the neoliberal ideologues in this government who, ignoring warnings issued in 2015 and 2016 by the inspectorate that resettlement arrangements were not fit for purpose, pursued this flawed and ultimately doomed experiment to its predictable tragic end.
Sue Hobbs
, Privatising Criminal Justice

• In 2015, my twin brother, Adrian Munday, was murdered in his own home in Devon. Adrian’s killer, Stuart Hodgkin, was under the probation supervision of Dorset, Devon and Cornwall Community Rehabilitation Company, one of the new probation companies set up after Chris Grayling’s catastrophic attempt to privatise the service. Adrian had mental health issues, so was also in receipt of privatised community support.

At the murder trial, it was revealed that Hodgkin had more than 80 previous convictions, over 40 of them for assault, and three current restraining orders. This information should have been easily available to probation officers.

In 2018, Devon county council published the multi-agency safeguarding adults review (SAR) about the circumstances surrounding Adrian’s death. This report found 40 agency failings – but two pivotal mistakes came from failures to assess a “high” level of risk: first at court, when Hodgkin was sentenced to probation, not custody, for a previous crime, and second by the community rehabilitation company, which relied on the first assessment. A correct assessment would have radically changed the fatal outcome.

Following the SAR, we were assured that lessons would be learned and that these would be shared at national level. Nothing has changed. It is surely time to set up a comprehensive national database by which probation officers can access an offender’s full history easily and quickly.

Like Zara’s family, I believe the government has my brother’s blood on its hands. Let no other family have to go through this unnecessary suffering.
Sarah Compton
Glangevlin, County Cavan, Ireland

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Probation service sacrificed on altar of Tory privatisation | Letters
Letters: Retired chief probation officers, among others, respond to the crisis affecting the National Probation Service


27, Jun, 2018 @4:11 PM

Article image
GPS offender tagging farce tied to privatised probation | Letters
Letter: Chris Grayling pushed both of these schemes through and both have been expensive failures, but the former justice secretary has not been called to account for either, says Mike Nellis


28, Jan, 2018 @6:03 PM

Article image
Probation has been handled disgracefully | Letter
Letter: It was obvious that operational failure, massive expense and complex bureaucratic fragmentation awaited a part-privatised system, say professors Lol Burke and Steve Collett


15, Jun, 2020 @4:57 PM

Article image
The Guardian view on privatising probation: a disaster ignored | Editorial
Editorial: Ministers have not learned the lessons of their ideological obsession with making profits out of offenders


16, May, 2019 @5:42 PM

Article image
The Guardian view on privatising probation: ideology over facts | Editorial
Editorial: Chris Grayling was a justice minister who preferred to keep faith in privatisation even when his changes were failing some of the most vulnerable in our society. He ought to be accountable


24, Jun, 2018 @5:05 PM

Article image
Probation should be a public service again | Letter
Letter: After the collapse of Interserve, former probation officers plea for a rational, positive reform


17, Mar, 2019 @6:45 PM

Article image
Probation service will take years to recover from Chris Grayling’s privatisation fiasco | Letters
Letters: For probation to provide the range and quality of services it once did will be a major undertaking, writes Mike Worthington; Grayling was told in no uncertain terms by Napo that his reforms were destined to fail, says Pat Waterman


16, May, 2019 @4:38 PM

Article image
Shining a searchlight on prisons and probation | Letters
Letters: Prisons have been in crisis for decades, including when Labour was in power and staff numbers were high, says Joe Sim. More must be done to help women in prisons, says Katharine Sacks-Jones. Philip Priestley and Maurice Vanstone propose a four-point plan. And Chris Leyland points to Chris Grayling’s failings


30, Jul, 2018 @5:28 PM

Article image
The probation service is in a desperate state | Letters
Letters: Experienced staff are leaving because of impossible workloads, writes Anne King. Plus a letter from Ellie Dwight

03, Mar, 2023 @6:03 PM

Article image
Chris Grayling’s record of catastrophic failures | Letter
Letter: The transport secretary has a history of blunder and disaster, writes Jan Clare. As minister of justice he oversaw the virtual destruction of the probation service


06, Jan, 2019 @5:46 PM