LTNs appear not to push traffic on to boundary roads, London study finds

Exclusive: number of motor vehicles in 46 low-traffic neighbourhoods studied also significantly reduced

Low-traffic neighbourhoods significantly reduce the number of motor vehicles within their boundaries without appearing to push traffic on to roads around their edges, the most comprehensive study yet of such schemes in the UK has concluded.

The research, which was based on traffic count data before and after the installation of 46 so-called LTNs in London, found a reduction in motor traffic within the zones of 32.7% when measured as the median, and a 46.9% drop when calculated as the mean.

Of the 413 roads inside the LTNs with before-and-after traffic counts, the percentage experiencing an average of fewer than 1,000 motor vehicles a day, seen as a good shorthand for a street receptive to more cycling and walking, rose from 41% to 66%.

This could mean “a qualitative change in the local environment” on at least some streets because of the LTNs, the researchers said.

LTNs use either physical filters, such as bollards and planters, or traffic cameras to prevent motor vehicles using some smaller residential streets as through-routes, while bicycle and foot traffic is unaffected.

Opponents of the schemes, which have proved controversial in some places, with a handful removed, claim they do not reduce the overall amount of motor traffic but simply move it to other roads.

Interactive

While the authors behind the research, from the University of Westminster’s Active Travel Academy (ATA), noted they only had useable data for just under half the 96 LTNs installed in London between March 2020 and May 2021, they said there was significant overall evidence of so-called traffic evaporation.

Data from the 174 count points on boundary roads showed what the authors said was a more mixed picture, but without apparent evidence that such roads were necessarily seeing more traffic once an LTN was installed.

Of those monitored, 47% showed a fall in motor traffic and 53% showed an increase. When measured as a median, the overall figure for boundary roads rose by 1.3%, but fell by 1.6% when calculated as a mean (average).

When the totals were adjusted using Transport for London data for wider traffic changes, to account for factors like the Covid-19 pandemic and differing seasons, boundary roads had an overall mean increase of 0.7% in motor traffic, or 82 vehicles a day on average.

Within this, the researchers found what they called “substantial variation in both directions” on boundary roads. They concluded this was mainly due to non-LTN factors such as other works, and said more research could be done on reducing traffic on boundary routes.

The study noted other caveats, including that the majority of counts took place within inner London rather than more distant suburbs, and that the extent and quality of traffic data, provided by councils, was varied, with some not having produced any monitoring at all.

The researchers also pointed to the need for further study on other effects of LTNs, including how to best mitigate their impact on people who particularly need to drive on local journeys, for example some people with disabilities.

The research used data from TfL, was funded by the climate charity Possible, and carried out by the ATA.

Asa Thomas, a PhD researcher at the academy and the lead author of the study, said the findings pointed to a significant drop in motor traffic within LTNs, along with “little indication of systematic displacement of this traffic to boundary roads”.

Prof Rachel Aldred, the director of the ATA and co-author of the study, said: “The research indicates there has been overall ‘traffic evaporation’ as a result of these schemes, as the mean average reduction in motor traffic on internal roads is around 10 times higher than the mean average increase on boundary roads, adjusting for background trends.

“This suggests that not only do LTNs have substantial benefits inside their boundaries, but they can also contribute to wider traffic reduction goals.”

• This article was amended on 20 January 2023 to give the median motor-traffic increase on boundary roads as 1.3% rather than 2.1%.

Contributor

Peter Walker

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Low-traffic neighbourhoods make roads safer but need a rebrand – report
Exclusive: study of London schemes says local communication should be improved but that benefits are clear

Peter Walker

09, Jun, 2022 @5:01 AM

Article image
Tower Hamlets mayor accused of ‘culture war’ against low-traffic schemes
Campaigners criticise Lutfur Rahman as he consults for second time on London borough’s LTNs

Harriet Grant

14, Feb, 2023 @12:23 PM

Article image
Ignore false claims and bad journalism – most LTNs do reduce traffic | Andrew Gilligan
Objections to active travel infrastructures are now picking and choosing data to fit the narrative

Andrew Gilligan

24, Nov, 2022 @8:00 AM

Article image
Low traffic neighbourhoods popular with London voters, analysis finds
Parties that back schemes to improve air quality and boost active travel outperformed critics in mayoral election

Peter Walker

02, Jun, 2021 @7:00 AM

£25 congestion charge will hit 30,000 of worst polluting vehicles, says mayor

· Threefold increase will hit 4x4s and sports cars
· Free zone entry for low emission vehicles

Matthew Taylor

13, Feb, 2008 @11:35 AM

Article image
Easing of parking rules will lead to traffic congestion, warn campaigners
Ministers say changes mark end of 'war on the motorist'

Matthew Weaver

03, Jan, 2011 @2:00 PM

Article image
London borough of Newham tops UK parking fines table
East London council, which issued most fines and collected most money, is described as ‘parking fine capital of UK’

Hilary Osborne

18, Jan, 2021 @1:07 PM

Article image
Low-traffic schemes benefit most-deprived Londoners, study finds
Data dispels myth that low-traffic neighbourhoods are disproportionately found in privileged areas

Antonio Voce and Peter Walker

02, Mar, 2021 @7:48 AM

Article image
London must stand together in 2017 if its golden age is not to end
The capital’s politicians and other influential groups need unanimity of purpose if the city is to keep prospering in the year of uncertainties ahead

Dave Hill

01, Jan, 2017 @3:59 PM

Article image
'I was charged £20,000 for driving my car into the London emissions zone'
A Spanish motorist has been hit with huge penalties for driving in the UK capital

Patrick Collinson and Miles Brignall

31, Aug, 2019 @6:00 AM