Ministers to unveil anti-strike laws as disputes continue to paralyse UK

Business department says bill will enforce ‘basic’ level of service from different sectors during stoppages

Ministers are to unveil controversial new legislation designed to curb the effectiveness of strike action as industrial disputes continue to paralyse services across the UK.

The Department for Business, Energy and Industrial Strategy has previously said the bill will enforce a “basic” level of service from different sectors if workers choose to strike.

Shapps said there was currently a “lottery” if workers chose to strike, alleging that nurses were willing to guarantee a national level of service during strikes but ambulance unions were not. “There was a sort of regional postcode lottery. That’s the thing we want to avoid,” he told Sky News.

The legislation is likely to face a difficult passage in the House of Lords and a legal challenge by unions once it is passed – meaning minimum service levels are unlikely to be able to be enforced for many months.

The government’s own impact assessment has suggested that the legislation could lead to “an increased frequency of strikes … and more adverse effects in the long-term”.

Shapps told BBC Radio 4’s Today programme that he did not see that as a risk and said the government hoped it would never have to use the new power, citing the disparity between nurses and ambulance workers and saying he hoped agreements could be made without the need for enforcement.

“This would, I hope, bring everybody to the table to provide those same minimum safety levels,” he said.

“I do think the minimum safety levels make a huge amount of sense. I hope that rather than actually using the legislation, we’ll be able to just get this safety and security in place for people. It can’t be right that the British people are exposed to that variance and service depending on where they happen to live.”

The Trades Union Congress general secretary, Paul Nowak, said the change in law would risk further strikes.

“This legislation would mean that, when workers democratically vote to strike, they can be forced to work and sacked if they don’t comply. That’s undemocratic, unworkable, and almost certainly illegal,” he said. “Let’s be clear: if passed, this bill will prolong disputes and poison industrial relations – leading to more frequent strikes.”

The introduction of the bill to parliament on Tuesday comes after crisis talks on Monday between ministers and unions failed to resolve ongoing disputes with nurses, teachers and rail workers.

However, ministers have laid the ground for a U-turn on pay for NHS staff by agreeing to discuss backdating pay offers from April and one-off cost-of-living payments that were previously ruled out.

Relations are likely to be soured, however, by the introduction of the legislation on the day after the talks. Defending the proposed legislation, Shapps said the government wanted to end “forever strikes”.

He told Times Radio: “Everyone knows we want to bring these strikes, which in some cases, railways for example, seem to have turned into sort of forever strikes. We want to bring this to a close and the government is bending over backwards to do that.”

He added: “Other countries like Germany and France and elsewhere do have minimum safety levels in place and we want to make sure that we’re doing the same thing to protect the British people.

“All we’d be doing here is bringing ourselves into line with what is already practised in many other countries.”

Labour has warned that bill could allow employers to sue trade unions and sack workers. The party has said it will oppose the bill and repeal it once in government.

Shapps has played down criticism that minimum service levels legislation could lead to NHS staff being sacked. He said: “This sort of talk that somebody will be sacked is no more true than it would be under any employment contract and that’s always the case when people have to stick to the law.”

Unions warned it could see key workers facing the sack if they exercise their right to strike, and that if it becomes law it could “poison industrial relations” and lead to more walkouts.

The health secretary, Steve Barclay, is reportedly considering backdating next year’s NHS staff pay increase, as well as making a one-off cost-of-living payment.

In a meeting with health unions, Barclay is said to have suggested that improvements in efficiency and productivity within the health service could “unlock additional funding” to lead to an increased offer for the 2023-24 pay settlement in the spring.

Those comments were criticised by Unite, one of the unions that attended the talks, saying that asking for staff to work harder for more money was insulting. But Shapps said that was not what was meant.

“There are many, many new things which have come in which could make the practice of healthcare, the running of railways and other things much more efficient,” he told Sky News.

“I think what the health secretary was saying is that let’s try and take advantage of those things, and that’s our route to being able to pay people for greater productivity.”

Sara Gorton, the head of health at the Unison trade union, said the discussion represented a “tone change” from the UK government after months of ministers refusing to budge beyond what had been recommended by the independent pay review bodies.

Unions said there was no “tangible offer” made, however, with Gorton calling for “cold hard cash” to be offered so members can be consulted over stopping strikes.

While there were positive noises about the talks in some quarters, other unions were incensed by the lack of perceived progress and it was clear the discussions were not enough to prevent the likelihood of further strikes in the health sector.

Physiotherapists also said they would be announcing industrial action dates later this week despite the talks, while the GMB union said ambulance strikes would go ahead as planned on Wednesday.

The Fire Brigades Union general secretary, Matt Wrack, said: “This is an attack on all workers – including key workers, who kept our public services going during the pandemic. It’s an attack on Britain’s Covid heroes and on all workers. We need a mass movement of resistance to this authoritarian attack.”


Jamie Grierson and Jessica Elgot

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Trade unions vow to oppose anti-strike laws for NHS and ‘critical infrastructure’
Cabinet minister Gillian Keegan suggested extending ban on police and military taking industrial action to other sectors

Heather Stewart, Rajeev Syal and Peter Walker

08, Dec, 2022 @6:47 PM

Article image
No 10 denies ministers seeking political fight with rail unions
Denial comes as language toughens on both sides and head of RMT again warns of de facto general strike

Peter Walker, Pippa Crerar and Tom Ambrose

18, Aug, 2022 @6:34 PM

Article image
RCN and train drivers’ union dispute ministers’ claims about their strikes
Nurses union head clashes with Steve Barclay over plans to protect patients and RMT rows with Mark Harper about striking on eve of Eurovision final

Rowena Mason Whitehall editor

30, Apr, 2023 @7:40 PM

Article image
Grant Shapps accused of ‘advocating fire and rehire’ to end rail strikes
Transport secretary said he could enact legislation to force through measures sought by rail companies

Tom Ambrose

19, Aug, 2022 @4:55 PM

Article image
Nurses to strike again as ministers prepare to introduce ‘spiteful’ bill
Industrial action also set to escalate in other sectors while government gears up anti-strike legislation

Rowena Mason Whitehall editor

15, Jan, 2023 @10:38 PM

Article image
Ambulance strike: NHS leaders urge public to avoid risky activity
Bodies representing NHS care in England also call for Rishi Sunak intervention but PM refuses to budge on pay

Denis Campbell, Steven Morris and Dan Sabbagh

21, Dec, 2022 @12:05 AM

Article image
NHS urges use of GP, chemist or 111 service during ambulance strike
People in England and Wales advised to request ambulance only if a life is at risk

Denis Campbell Health policy editor

10, Jan, 2023 @7:13 PM

Article image
Fewer people call for ambulances on service’s biggest strike so far
Safety not thought to be affected despite up to 25,000 workers joining picket lines across England and Wales

Rachel Hall

11, Jan, 2023 @5:53 PM

Article image
Ministers accused of ‘provoking’ strikes as tube action disrupts London travel
Sadiq Khan claims transport secretary ‘deliberately’ seeking industrial action to pave way for legislation curtailing union rights

Tom Ambrose and Nadeem Badshah

19, Aug, 2022 @1:08 PM

Article image
NHS ambulance workers announce fresh strike dates as pay row escalates
Unite members across England, Wales and Northern Ireland to take further action in February and March

Matthew Weaver and Anna Bawden

20, Jan, 2023 @8:35 AM