Why the ‘Barber boom’ that Kwasi Kwarteng’s mini-budget recalls was destined for disaster

A reckless dash for growth is nothing new. Ted Heath’s chancellor Anthony Barber tried one in 1971, but it didn’t turn out well

The recklessness of chancellor Kwasi Kwarteng’s “budget for growth” evokes memories of the disastrous outcome of the last great Conservative “dash for growth”: the so-called “Barber boom” of 1971-73.

I say so-called because the wildly expansionist policy of those years was essentially the work of PM Edward Heath. His preferred chancellor, Iain Macleod, had died within a month of taking office in 1970, and Heath was thenceforth the driving force in economic policy.

It was Heath who was responsible for the famous U-turn in the winter of 1971-72. The previous policy was one of “setting the people free” by reining in public expenditure, cutting taxation and not “propping up lame ducks” when companies fell into trouble. (Any resemblance to Liz Truss’s leadership campaign pledges is coincidental.)

All of this changed that winter, when unemployment reached what was then regarded as the politically and socially intolerable level of 1 million; a major employer, Upper Clyde Shipbuilders, was threatened with closure; and the chief constable of Glasgow telephoned the PM to say he could no longer be responsible for public order unless it was rescued.

There was panic in the ranks, and the policy became one of corporate rescue and expansion at almost any cost. There is nothing new about Kwarteng’s emphasis on growth. Heath and Barber introduced an official growth target of 5% between 1971 and 1973, public expenditure controls were lifted, and in his budget chancellor Anthony Barber spoke of his object: “To achieve a rate of growth twice as fast as in the past decade.”

There were obvious concerns about inflation during boom times. Heath introduced a well-intentioned but unfortunately timed incomes policy under which wage increases would be geared to the cost of living.

Alas: in Harold Macmillan’s famous phrase, the government was hit by “events, dear boy, events” – namely the oil crisis of the autumn and winter of 1973-74, provoked by the Yom Kippur war. The oil price quadrupled, then rose again. This had a dramatic impact on wage settlements and inflation, which accelerated to 25% by mid 1975. By this time Labour was in power, the Heath government having been brought down by the pay dispute with the miners in 1974.

There are many differences between then and now, but as Kwarteng frightens the markets with previously unimaginable tax cuts, we have an independent Bank of England that is set on making counter-inflationary rises in interest rates: thus we have fiscal expansion, but monetary contraction. During the Barber boom monetary policy was also, in the words of one official, “inherently inflationary”


William Keegan

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Kwasi Kwarteng’s champagne reception may have broken ministerial code
Liberal Democrats write to cabinet secretary to demand examination of meeting with financiers after chancellor’s mini-budget

Michael Savage Policy Editor

09, Oct, 2022 @7:00 AM

Article image
Great divide: pundits’ reactions to mini-budget run from alarmed to delighted
The chancellor’s plans manage to be both the best ever and economically incoherent, depending on who you listen to

Guardian staff

25, Sep, 2022 @6:00 AM

Article image
Kwasi Kwarteng’s mini-budget: key points at a glance
The chancellor has delivered his mini-budget – here are the main points, with political analysis

Richard Partington and Aubrey Allegretti

23, Sep, 2022 @8:40 AM

Article image
Kwasi Kwarteng could borrow for the right reasons. These are the wrong ones
Money spent on the green transition or skills would reap a dividend. But this cash is just going to the rich

Phillip Inman

24, Sep, 2022 @8:42 PM

Article image
OBR forecasts likely to show £60bn-£70bn hole after Kwarteng’s mini-budget
Predictions handed to chancellor expected to paint gloomy picture for UK economy amid sweeping tax cuts

Richard Partington Economics correspondent

07, Oct, 2022 @5:20 PM

Article image
Teachers and nurses face tax increase after mini-budget hands cut to bankers
Research by the Liberal Democrats shows that key workers will be worse off next year but top bank bosses will enjoy huge perks

Michael Savage and Jon Ungoed-Thomas

24, Sep, 2022 @6:27 PM

Article image
Mini-budget 2022: what it means for you
High earners are the big winners in the chancellor’s tax giveaway, while people on universal credit risk losing income

Zoe Wood

23, Sep, 2022 @10:07 PM

Article image
How Kwasi Kwarteng’s mini-budget hit UK economy – in numbers
Reckless ‘fiscal event’ may have damaged Liz Truss’s government beyond repair

Jamie Grierson

30, Sep, 2022 @12:46 PM

Article image
Does Kwasi Kwarteng’s mini-budget offer any solutions to Britain's crises? Our panel decides | Katy Balls and others
The chancellor has delivered swingeing tax cuts and an end to the cap on bankers’ bonuses

Polly Toynbee, Miatta Fahnbulleh, Katy Balls, Nick Butler and James Perry

23, Sep, 2022 @10:08 AM

Article image
The unravelling: the full story of how Liz Truss lost her way – and her authority in the Tory party
The prime minister ditched her close ally Kwasi Kwarteng to save her own job – but now Conservative MPs are openly plotting to replace her

Michael Savage Policy Editor

16, Oct, 2022 @5:00 AM