Wales v England: how will centuries-old rivalry play out on Tuesday?

A quarter of Monmouth Town FC’s players are English – so Tuesday will be quite a night in front of the clubhouse TV

Monmouth Town FC’s packed, raucous clubhouse on the banks of the muddy River Monnow fell momentarily silent as Wales’s painful loss to a reinvigorated Iran sunk in on Friday. But thoughts – and perhaps a whole nation’s hopes – soon turned to the first clash between England and Wales in a World Cup finals.

The manager of the tight-knit Welsh regional league club, Steve Davies, 50, is not a man for giving up. He believes in resilience, family and community.

“Where there’s a football match, there’s always hope. There’s always a belief that they can produce something special. We’ve done it before in the Euros – so hopefully, we can do it again on an even biggest stage,” he said, as a group of sixth formers, who had gathered with players, coaching staff and supporters to watch the match, drifted back to school.

The semi-professional club’s lush, tree-lined grounds are just two miles from the border with England, with some players crossing over from the English side to play and train. Most of the club’s 250 registered players – from junior to senior teams – are Welsh, but a quarter are English. This week teammates accustomed to giving everything for each other will find themselves on opposing sides.

The senior team’s goalkeeper, Dan Keane, 20, who grew up in the historic border town that has frequently changed hands between the English and Welsh over the centuries, knows major bragging rights are at stake: “It’s a friendly rivalry. If we get a result against England on Tuesday night, I will be very, very loud at training. It probably won’t happen again for a long time – so you have got to enjoy it if it does.”

His teammate, Mitchell Palmer, 25, also grew up in Monmouth but has English parents. His mother made sure he was born in Hereford, not Wales. He suspects there might be a few no-shows to training on Wednesday.

Mitchell Palmer, 20, at Monmouth Town FC.
Mitchell Palmer, 20, at Monmouth Town FC. Photograph: Francesca Jones/The Observer

“If England win I wouldn’t be surprised if a few Welsh lads drop out so they don’t have to see me,” he said with a grin.

Few, however, fear that this rivalry will affect the young team’s spirit, which has carried them to fifth in the Ardal Southern league, the third tier of the Welsh football pyramid. “We will unite as a family, as Monmouth Town. And we will play for each other and work hard for each other. We will become one again,” said Davis.

One of the dedicated volunteers running the community club has just got back from Qatar. The president, Terry Cleaves, 63, a former player whose family has been involved in Monmouth Town FC for more than a century, watched Wales’s opening game with the USA, which ended in a draw. “I wanted to be in Qatar for the first kickoff of a Welsh team in the World Cup since 1958,” he said. “I was so proud to be there. I was proud to be part of the Welsh clan abroad.”

Most fans, however, have not made the journey. Instead, both England and Wales supporters will fill the clubhouse on Tuesday.

“There will be 80 to 100 people. It will be the place to be. We will take the mickey out of each other. There will be banter. But it will be a friendly rivalry,” says Cleaves.

Palmer is already nervous, despite England being one of the tournament’s favourites: “It’s a derby and anything could happen. If we go 0-1 down I might have to sneak off.”

Even some of the club’s families will also be divided on the night. Rich Thorp, 52, who is the club’s treasurer, is supporting England while his wife is backing Wales. “My eldest will be supporting Wales. My middle son will not support Wales. My daughter flips and flops,” he said.

Thorp says Welsh fans seem to lack the arrogance of some England supporters. “There’s a reason why Welsh fans are loved around the world: they’re humble. They celebrate and cheer for their team. What lets England down is that they cheer to have a go.”

Wales will have to win handsomely on Tuesday to stand a chance of going through to the knockout stages – and even then they will need other results in the group to go their way.

But for many of the team’s passionate supporters it’s enough to be playing on football’s most illustrious stage.

“We’ve waited for so long for Wales to actually qualify for the World Cup, so we’ve got no real expectations,” says Davies. “We’ve already won just by just getting to Qatar. Regardless of the result on Tuesday, to play in a World Cup, to represent Wales, with a Welsh dragon on your chest, is a fantastic achievement.”


Tom Wall

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Senegal or England to win? Parents v children in London’s west African community
In Deptford, south-east London, support for Senegal is high among the older generation, while their offspring opt for the country of their birth in the World Cup showdown

Mark Townsend

04, Dec, 2022 @6:00 AM

Article image
I saw Ukraine’s football party 10 years ago – I’ll support them against Wales | Ed Vulliamy
Even with my Welsh heritage, I know which team I want to secure a place at this year’s World Cup in Qatar

Ed Vulliamy

05, Jun, 2022 @11:00 AM

Article image
‘That was a great performance’: fans praise England despite defeat
Regulars watching World Cup quarter-final in a London pub find positives for future in team’s strong performance

Tim Lewis

11, Dec, 2022 @7:00 AM

Article image
Forget Fifa’s power play – Qatar’s World Cup has displayed international football at its finest
Argentina v France will be a fitting end to a tournament where the game proved bigger than problems that dogged it off pitch

Paul MacInnes

17, Dec, 2022 @1:30 PM

Article image
Gareth Southgate hopes England can ‘bring happiness’ amid gloom at home
England coach urges team towards a ‘third incredible journey’ ahead of World Cup match against Senegal

Sean Ingle

03, Dec, 2022 @10:30 PM

Article image
England head home from World Cup rueing another penalty miss
Sting of latest knockout defeat will linger after Gareth Southgate’s team went toe-to-toe with the world champions

Sean Ingle at Al Bayt Stadium

10, Dec, 2022 @11:58 PM

Article image
TV’s female pundits are out in force – but not for the big England matches
While big ticket clashes continue to elude them, the Qatar World Cup has still seen historic progress for women in football

Alexandra Topping

04, Dec, 2022 @10:00 AM

Article image
Qatar World Cup accused of imposing ‘chilling’ restrictions on media
Conditions restrict where international broadcasters, including BBC and ITV, are permitted to film

Shanti Das

15, Oct, 2022 @2:06 PM

Article image
Qatar lavished British MPs with gifts ahead of World Cup
MPs who received gifts later appeared to speak favourably about Qatar in parliamentary debates

Shanti Das

29, Oct, 2022 @6:05 PM

Article image
Home Office bans 1,300 ‘violent and abusive’ fans from travelling to the World Cup in Qatar
Crackdown follows a rise in disorder and pitch invasions at football matches

Mark Townsend

09, Oct, 2022 @9:00 AM