Second homes and Brexit pushing Welsh language to ‘tipping point’

Chair of commission looking at future of Welsh language fears anglicisation could put it out of community use

The “anglicisation” of Welsh speaking villages and towns caused by newcomers snapping up homes after Covid, together with the economic stress of Brexit and the cost of living crisis, is pushing the Welsh language to a “tipping point”, the head of a new commission established to address the situation has warned.

Simon Brooks, chair of the Commission for Welsh-speaking Communities, said that unless action were taken there was a danger that Welsh as a community language could soon be lost in some of its traditional heartlands.

“What we face is an important moment in history,” he said. “Lots of things have been going on in a short period of time. You’ve had Brexit, which is a huge economic jolt, then the pandemic, which led to a race for space. To my mind, anglicisation has gathered pace. There can be a tipping point in terms of language use. The fear is that a lot of these communities are at that tipping point.”

Brooks said the “snowball effect” helped community languages – which he defined as a language spoken by many or most people in the local community and used in everyday interaction – thrive. “When everybody speaks the language, you use it. When another language is introduced you can get to a point where the majority language becomes much more dominant and that can happen very quickly.”

He said he had noticed a change in his own coastal village in Gwynedd, north Wales. “The language in the street has become more English. That has been accelerated by the Covid crisis.”

Brooks said Welsh would still be spoken by a lot of people across Wales, but without intervention it could be at risk as a community language. He added: “The decline of Welsh as a community language is important to all of Britain. It’s the last Celtic language spoken at the community level. It’s important in terms of broader cultural diversity.”

The commission is launching a call for evidence from citizens and organisations on issues that affect Welsh-speaking communities, from housing and education to community development and regeneration.

Brooks said the survival of the language in second-home hotspots, such as coastal villages in Ceredigion and Pembrokeshire, was already critical. “You can have 40 or 50% of housing stock tied up in second homes. At that point a community is not viable. It can’t survive.”

He said Welsh language heartlands were often economically deprived. “They are on the periphery of the UK, a long way from the marketplaces of Britain and Europe. Historically, many areas face the same post-industrial problems as places like the north of England.” Brooks said the stresses of Brexit and the cost of living crisis were pushing Welsh speakers out.

The Labour-led Welsh government has been bringing in a raft of measures designed to stop the Welsh language heartlands being hollowed out by the rise in second homeownership, including allowing local authorities to raise discretionary council tax premiums for second homes to 300% and forcing homeowners to get planning permission to change a property’s classification from a primary residence to a second home.

Brooks, associate professor at the school of management at Swansea University, said that as well as examining the second-homes issue, the commission would look at subjects ranging from tackling long-term structural disadvantage, to how tourism should be managed and how the language could be kept alive in the farming community.

Strengthening Welsh-speaking communities is central to the Welsh government’s strategy of doubling daily use of Welsh by 2050. For the year ending 30 June 2022, the annual population survey reported that 29.7% of people aged three or older were able to speak Welsh – about 899,500 people. Just under 15% reported that they spoke Welsh daily.

Jeremy Miles, the minister for education and Welsh language, said: “It’s crucial that our communities are strong and protected so Cymraeg can thrive. Challenges facing Welsh-speaking communities have increased in recent years and I’m sure lots of people will have views and suggestions to change this.”

The call for evidence opens on 9 November 2022 and responses should be submitted by 13 January 2023.


Steven Morris

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
‘People are living in vans’: Porthmadog considers vexed issue of second homes
As final vote on raising council tax to tackle homelessness looms, some worry tourism will be affected if people sell up

Steven Morris

25, Nov, 2022 @12:00 PM

Article image
‘It’s about keeping places alive’: Wales’s radical second-homes policy
Measures aim to preserve communities and keep more homes available for locals but critics say they are ‘anti-tourist’

Steven Morris

01, Oct, 2022 @7:00 AM

Article image
Tougher second homes regulations come into force in Wales
Council tax and planning changes aim to make housing more affordable for those on local incomes

Steven Morris

01, Apr, 2023 @5:00 AM

Article image
Gwynedd raises council tax premium on second homes to 150%
Councillors to use extra £3m expected to be raised by the move to tackle area’s ‘immoral’ homelessness crisis

Steven Morris

01, Dec, 2022 @6:09 PM

Article image
Welsh government issues new rules to bring down cost of school uniforms
School badges, logos and branded items must not be compulsory amid cost of living crisis, says Labour-led government

Steven Morris

02, May, 2023 @5:00 AM

Article image
Second-home owners in Gwynedd face 150% council tax premium
‘Immoral’ that one in 10 properties in area is a second home while homelessness has increased by 47%, say councillors

Steven Morris

22, Nov, 2022 @4:37 PM

Article image
Welsh communities are enriched by incomers | Letter
Letters: Please don’t use the emotive language of ‘cultural genocide’ to describe a village that buzzes with life, Sian Harris


24, Nov, 2021 @4:58 PM

Article image
UK energy bills crisis could set back health equality by decades, say experts
Chancellor told failure to act would hit services as poverty, cold and missed meals increase sickness rates

Peter Walker Political correspondent

19, Aug, 2022 @3:47 PM

Article image
Snow warning for south-east England as icy snap likely to trigger cold weather payments
Fuel poverty charity urges government to provide more support for ‘those at greatest peril’

Jamie Grierson

09, Dec, 2022 @3:11 PM

Article image
‘Desperate’ need for Homes for Ukraine hosts as war reaches six-month point
Call for new hosts comes as refugees minister says monthly payments should double amid rising costs

David Batty

24, Aug, 2022 @6:01 AM