MPs approve controversial plans to let agency workers cover for striking staff

Critics accuse ministers of introducing a ‘scab charter’ that risks public safety and workers’ rights

Ministers have approved controversial plans to allow agency workers to replace striking workers, voting through the regulations on Monday night by 289 votes to 202.

While the business minister, Jane Hunt, said the change, which was accelerated as a result of the ongoing rail strikes, was needed to remove the “outdated blanket ban” on using agency workers to cover official industrial action, critics say the measure is akin to a “scab charter”.

Hunt told the Commons: “Some trade unions appear to us to be looking to create maximum disruption in a bid to stay relevant rather than constructively seeking agreement with employers and avoid conflict.”

The TUC had urged MPs to vote against the “pernicious anti-union measures”, which were deplored as “anti-business and anti-worker” by Labour’s deputy leader, Angela Rayner.

“They will risk public safety, rip up workers’ rights, and encourage the very worst practices. And above all they will not prevent strikes, they will provoke them,” said Rayner.

Hunt denied safety concerns, and said these changes will not affect the right to strike.

The Conservative MP Alec Shelbrooke voted against the plans, arguing that they diminish the intended impact of industrial action.

“If people are going to lose their ability to have an effect when they withdraw their labour, then I am afraid they have effectively lost the ability to withdraw their labour,” the Elmet and Rothwell MP said.

This was the first time Shelbrooke had voted against the government since being elected in 2010.

The Labour MP Ian Byrne said the government should be voting to protect workers’ rights, rather than introducing a “scab charter for bad employers”.

This change comes hours after further strike action was confirmed, this time involving drivers at eight train companies who are preparing to walk out over pay.

Though agency workers can now replace strikers, questions remain over the numbers of spare teachers, nurses and train drivers who can step in as replacements.

With both the National Education Union and NASUWT threatening strike action in the autumn term, the Conservative MP Jonathan Gullis offered to return to the classroom should those threats materialise.

Separately, a Labour motion to annul regulations to increase the level of damages a court can award in the case of unlawful strike action was defeated by 290 votes to 201.


Cash Boyle

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Ministers press on with ‘cynical’ plan to let agency staff replace striking workers
Unions and recruiters say move would harm relations and point out UK government condemned P&O for doing same thing

Gwyn Topham Transport correspondent

23, Jun, 2022 @12:25 PM

Article image
London school uses law change to replace striking staff with agency workers
Drapers’ Pyrgo primary in Romford, where top managers were paid total of £1.49m in benefits, cut salaries or hours of 10 support staff

Daniel Boffey and Warwick Mansell

11, Oct, 2022 @6:00 AM

Article image
Military in thankless task as soldiers drafted in to replace striking workers
Army’s role risks being politicised as personnel called on to cover for Border Force and ambulance workers

Dan Sabbagh

11, Dec, 2022 @10:30 PM

Article image
‘Foolish’ anti-strike bill would stop some workers from ever striking, says Labour
Angela Rayner claims people in certain job categories could lose the right to withdraw their labour under Tory plans

Jessica Elgot Deputy political editor

16, Jan, 2023 @10:35 PM

Article image
UCL academics criticise use of agency workers to replace striking security staff
University and College Union expresses concern at what it says appear to be intimidatory tactics

Kevin Rawlinson

15, Nov, 2022 @6:45 PM

Article image
Number of striking workers now lower than ever
Official figures show that just 81,000 workers were involved in strikes in 2015, down from 733,300 in 2014

Graham Ruddick

02, Aug, 2016 @5:05 PM

Article image
Why has Britain stopped striking? Workers no longer feel empowered to act | Gregor Gall
With workers’ wages falling fast, it’s clear our country’s unions are not doing their job. Pernicious employers can be hit in the pocket with the right sort of action

Gregor Gall

04, Aug, 2016 @2:02 PM

Article image
Cobra meeting to discuss plans for military staff to cover striking workers
Labour and former army head warn repeated use of armed forces may lead to burnout and soldiers quitting

Peter Walker and Dan Sabbagh

11, Dec, 2022 @10:30 PM

TUC will meet Prescott to cool fire strike anger

TUC leaders expect to meet John Prescott today or tomorrow, after the government's threat to crush striking firefighters prompted calls for the resignation of the deputy prime minister and Tony Blair.

Kevin Maguire and Kirsty Scott

30, Jan, 2003 @9:34 AM

Article image
Union leader urges Keir Starmer to make clear he is on side of workers
Unite’s Sharon Graham says Labour leader must not ‘stand on the sidelines’ as workers go on strike

Rowena Mason and Heather Stewart

19, Oct, 2022 @12:38 PM