UN refugee body criticises ‘errors’ in asylum report backed by Braverman

Organisation questions use of ‘illegal’ to describe asylum seekers in report calling for radical crackdown

A report partially endorsed by the UK home secretary, Suella Braverman, calling for a radical crackdown on those seeking asylum has been criticised by a UN body for “factual and legal errors”.

Braverman wrote the foreword to the report by the right-leaning Centre for Policy Studies that says “if necessary” Britain should change human rights laws and withdraw from the European convention on human rights in order to tackle Channel crossings by small boat.

The report, co-authored by Theresa May’s former adviser Nick Timothy, recommended the indefinite detention of all asylum seekers who enter the UK “illegally” and that ministers should legislate to make it impossible to claim asylum in the UK after travelling from a safe country.

But the United Nations high commissioner for refugees (UNHCR) questioned the report’s description of “illegal” for people seeking asylum – a term also used by Braverman and the Home Office in official documents.

“There is no such thing as an ‘illegal asylum seeker’. The indefinite detention of those seeking asylum, based solely on their mode of arrival, would punish people in need of help and protection and constitute a clear breach of the United Kingdom’s obligations under the 1951 refugee convention,” a statement from the UNHCR said.

“A blanket ban on claiming asylum in the UK for those arriving on small boats would also breach the refugee convention, if this results in refugees having no means to establish their status and places them at risk of enforced return to their own countries.

“Access to asylum should never be contingent on mode of arrival or nationality. The only way to establish whether people are refugees is through a fair and efficient determination of their claims.”

Braverman has welcomed the report, and in a foreword pledged to do “whatever it takes” to deal with the migrant crisis in the Channel. She said the numbers of people making the perilous crossing were “wholly unacceptable and unsustainable” and that ministers would “comprehensively tackle the small boats problem”.

“We’ve had enough of the persistent abuse of human rights laws to thwart the removal of those with no right to be in the UK. This must end. Saying so is not xenophobic or anti-immigration. It is the reality acknowledged and felt by the vast majority of the British public. To pretend otherwise is to insult them,” she wrote.

Timothy said tackling the issue would require a “completely different approach” from the government, addressing a series of interconnected public problems. “If we are to stop the crossings, we will need to take immediate and bold action,” he said. “It is not something that can be fixed through gradual, incremental change.”

In a new intervention, a former Home Office minister said the government’s tough “rhetoric” on tackling illegal migrant crossings was not working.

The Conservative MP Kit Malthouse told BBC Radio 4’s The Westminster Hour on Sunday night: “I worry slightly that the kind of rhetoric of ‘let’s be tough, let’s just get tougher and tougher’ is just not getting us anywhere and that actually I’d much rather hear smart solutions than tough ones.”

The immigration minister, Robert Jenrick, indicated at the weekend that barring people from countries regarded as safe such as Albania from claiming asylum was among the measures being considered.

He said the government was also looking to tighten the rules on student visas, particularly in relation to bringing family members while studying in the UK.

Braverman has repeatedly blamed asylum seekers who enter the UK “illegally” for the UK’s backlog of cases. In November, she said: “The asylum system has been broken by an unprecedented wave of illegal migration.”

The Home Office did not reply when asked if Braverman stood by her description of asylum seekers as “illegal”. Instead, a spokesperson said: “The global migration crisis is causing an unprecedented strain on our asylum system. We must disrupt the business model of people smugglers and it is right that all options are considered. We welcome policy debate on this complex issue.”


Rajeev Syal Home affairs editor

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Braverman asylum plan may breach refugee convention, says UNHCR
Home secretary reportedly planning to ban anyone who enters UK via irregular routes claiming refuge

Rajeev Syal Home affairs editor

05, Oct, 2022 @2:09 PM

Article image
UN rebukes Suella Braverman over her attack on refugee convention
UNHCR defends 1951 convention after UK home secretary’s speech on ‘uncontrolled and illegal migration’

Rajeev Syal and Ben Quinn

26, Sep, 2023 @6:51 PM

Article image
Braverman bill could lead to 3,000 asylum seekers being deported a month
Exclusive: leaked documents on illegal migration bill also say legal aid fees will need to rise in order to ensure legal cover

Rajeev Syal Home affairs editor

25, May, 2023 @7:10 PM

Article image
Suella Braverman revives Tory pledge to cut net migration to ‘tens of thousands’
Home secretary says her ‘ultimate aspiration’ is to reduce migration figure from current level of 239,000

Rajeev Syal Home affairs editor

04, Oct, 2022 @5:13 PM

Article image
Braverman says she wants to deliver Rwanda deportations at scale as soon as possible – as it happened
Home secretary welcomes high court judgment that policy is lawful

Andrew Sparrow

19, Dec, 2022 @6:29 PM

Article image
Suella Braverman won’t say Rwanda deportation flights will start by summer
Home secretary refuses to give a deadline for when her controversial policy for asylum seekers will begin

Pippa Crerar Political editor

02, Apr, 2023 @4:14 PM

Article image
Tory rebels offered concessions on asylum legislation
Ministers axe plan obliging Braverman to send thousands of asylum seekers who arrive this summer to Rwanda

Rajeev Syal and Diane Taylor

10, Jul, 2023 @9:23 PM

Article image
Braverman’s comments on boat arrivals’ values rejected by fellow Tories
Sayeeda Warsi among those objecting to home secretary’s view people crossing Channel have values that ‘are at odds with our country’

Rajeev Syal Home affairs editor

27, Apr, 2023 @4:40 PM

Article image
Defeats for small boats bill in the Lords as Channel crossings set new record
Peers voted against government-proposed measures on detention and deportation of asylum seekers

Rajeev Syal Home affairs editor

03, Jul, 2023 @9:03 PM

Article image
Suella Braverman: home secretary set to take even harder line on migration
Braverman has pitched herself to the right of her predecessor – and is expected to move quickly to sideline ECHR

Rajeev Syal Home affairs editor

06, Sep, 2022 @6:32 PM