False leads, multiple suspects: the long search for Madeleine McCann

Analysis: There have been many twists in investigation into disappearance of girl from Portuguese resort in 2007

Kate and Gerry McCann are likely to take limited solace from Portuguese authorities designating a convicted German sex offender a formal suspect in the disappearance of their daughter, more than 14 years after police pointed a finger of suspicion at them.

In their case, it took 11 months for the Portuguese police to lift their categorisation of the couple as arguidos – translated from Portuguese as “named suspects” or “formal suspects”.

The initial police investigation in the disappearance of Madeleine McCann in May 2007 from a holiday apartment in Praia da Luz was also shelved at that point. But by then, investigators had already made a string of potentially crucial, basic errors that included not only falsely suspecting the McCanns but also failing to seal off the scene at the family’s Praia da Luz holiday apartment.

Almost a decade and a half later, and following multiple suspects and desperate public appeals, it was a police search of an allotment in the German city of Hanover in the summer of 2020 that gave something of a different sense that there had finally been a breakthrough in the trans-national investigation.

The excavation had come to an end by July of that year, but a name had already emerged in form of a convicted sex offender, Christian Brückner, who had occupied the ground in the months following Madeline’s disappearance.

Now, the formal identification by Portuguese authorities of Brückner as an arguido heightens levels of expectations again, even if an abundance of false leads over the years still gives cause for caution.

The original Portuguese police investigation had also resulted in an Anglo-Portuguese man, Robert Murat, being taken for questioning and also being made an arguido. .

Murat was formally cleared of suspicion in 2008 and won more than £500,000 in libel damages over defamatory articles connecting him with the child’s disappearance.

Gerry and Kate McCann.
Gerry and Kate McCann in 2014. Photograph: Tiago Petinga/PA

It would be January 2009 before the McCanns returned to Portugal, launching a fresh public appeal for information. One suspect emerged in the shape of a dying convicted paedophile, Raymond Hewlett, who said he was in the Algarve around the time of the child’s disappearance but insisted he had an alibi.

Another was an unnamed woman who private detectives hired by the McCanns said they wanted to speak to and who had reportedly been seen in Barcelona days after the girl’s disappearance.

In March 2010, a released file from the Portuguese police on potential sightings was described as “gold dust” by a spokesperson for the family. But it, too, would lead to nothing before efforts were stepped up again the following year when the then prime minister, David Cameron, asked Scotland Yard to help the Portuguese authorities with their investigation.

Madeleine McCann
Madeleine McCann disappeared in Praia da Luz, Portugal on 3 May 2007. Photograph: Met police/AFP/Getty Images

The Metropolitan police’s involvement, known as Operation Grange, has continued to this day. It brought with it new “persons of interest” and the identification of new cases where a lone intruder had broken into holiday apartments.

Until the shift in focus to Germany in the summer of 2020, what appeared to be the most significant development was the search by British and Portuguese police of a patch of scrubland outside Praia da Luz in June 2014. It ultimately yielded nothing.

The 10th anniversary of Madeleine’s disappearance came and went in 2017, and four official suspects investigated by Scotland Yard were ruled out of the investigation – though a senior police chief said they were pursuing a “significant line of inquiry”.

Sign up to First Edition, our free daily newsletter – every weekday morning at 7am

On 4 June, against the backdrop of the Covid-19 pandemic, the public identification of a German man serving time in prison as a new prime suspect came out of the blue.

He was said to have been in the vicinity of the Algarve resort of Praia da Luz on the evening of 3 May 2007, and had a telephone conversation that ended just over an hour before the child went missing from the holiday apartment where she had been sleeping alone with her younger twin siblings as her parents dined at a nearby restaurant.

Brückner’s name soon emerged. And while the development brought hope that the case of the child’s disappearance may one day be solved, the German state prosecutor’s office has said it has “concrete evidence” that Madeleine is dead. Amid the latest developments, prosecutors in the Portuguese city of Faro did not publicly name the man but said in a statement he was identified as a suspect by German authorities at their request.

A lawyer for Brückner – who lived in the Algarve between 1995 and 2007 and burgled hotels and holiday flats, according to court documents seen by Reuters in 2020 – has said that his client has not been charged over the case.

However, the potential timing is not lost on those familiar with the case given Portugal’s 15-year statute of limitations for crimes with a maximum prison sentence of 10 years or more.

Jim Gamble, the former head of the Child Exploitation and Online Protection Centre who worked on the investigation into the child’s disappearance, told BBC Breakfast on Friday morning: “Well, this breakthrough could mean everything or it could mean nothing.

“My own gut feeling on it – from the moment the Germans began to release information two years ago – was that this was the best fit. You have proximity, you have opportunity, and you have a profile with regards to an offender that absolutely fits in a way that no others have.

“This is all positive. And from my own position, and I wouldn’t be surprised if charges did follow.”


Ben Quinn

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Portuguese police to search reservoir for Madeleine McCann
Search to take place at behest of German authorities about 25 miles from where Madeleine went missing

Jamie Grierson, and Kate Connolly in Berlin

22, May, 2023 @4:47 PM

Article image
Madeleine McCann suspect investigated over two other missing children – reports
Christian Brückner may be linked to disappearance of a five-year-old girl in Germany and six-year-old boy in Portugal

Philip Oltermann in Berlin and Jon Henley

05, Jun, 2020 @10:24 PM

Article image
Madeleine McCann case: tabloids and trolls fill vacuum as wait goes on
Two weeks after Germans identified a suspect, there is no further clarity but much slander and speculation

Archie Bland

20, Jun, 2020 @6:00 AM

Article image
Madeleine McCann search fund 'running out'

Parents Gerry and Kate McCann express dismay at lack of help from authorities three years after their daughter vanished

Haroon Siddique and agencies

03, Nov, 2010 @1:41 PM

Article image
Madeleine McCann: Portugal search to extend into third day, say sources
Operation on banks of reservoir 30 miles from where Madeleine went missing in 2007 had been due to end on Wednesday

Daniel Boffey in Silves and Kate Connolly in Berlin

24, May, 2023 @3:46 PM

Article image
Madeleine McCann search moves to scrubland

Detectives may use excavators, dogs and ground-penetrating radar in area about 2km from where child went missing

Brendan de Beer in Praia da Luz and Ben Quinn

03, Jun, 2014 @10:05 AM

Article image
Madeleine McCann case: Portuguese police question four suspects
Questioning is being conducted by Portuguese detectives with their British counterparts sitting in

Brendan de Beer in Faro

01, Jul, 2014 @6:42 PM

Article image
Sun sets on week-long search for Madeleine McCann by British police
Locals come to terms with invasion of journalists and further disruption as detectives' investigation moves to new area

Josh Halliday and Brendan de Beer in Praia da Luz, Portugal

08, Jun, 2014 @7:07 PM

Article image
Madeleine McCann case: Scotland Yard identifies new leads

Madeleine was nearly four when she went missing from her family's holiday apartment in Praia de Luz, Portugal, in 2007

Caroline Davies

17, May, 2013 @1:57 PM

Article image
Madeleine McCann: UK prosecutors visit Portugal to discuss new leads
Review of case by Met police has uncovered a number of potential suspects who have not been interviewed

Sandra Laville, crime correspondent

21, Jun, 2013 @5:14 PM