UK criticised for ‘dropping Paris climate goals in trade deal with Australia’

UK-Australia deal also criticised for allowing import of beef produced to lower standards

Green campaigners have criticised the UK government for apparently removing references to the temperature goals of the Paris climate agreement from a prospective trade deal with Australia.

According to Sky News in the UK, the trade deal – which was agreed in principle in June – was set to contain references to the Paris goals of limiting global heating to 2C above pre-industrial levels, with an aspiration to a lower limit of 1.5C.

Instead, the references to the temperature limits were left out, but the commitment to fulfilling the terms of the agreement was kept.

Sky News said it had obtained an email, which has not been published, from a senior UK government official that showed the more explicit reference to temperature goals was cut in order to seal the deal with the Australian government.

Australia is nominally committed to the 2015 Paris agreement but Scott Morrison, the prime minister, has been heavily criticised for showing little enthusiasm for climate action, on which the country is widely considered a global laggard.

The UK-Australian trade deal has also been attacked by farmers and green campaigners for allowing the import of large quantities of cheap beef and other agricultural goods produced to lower standards than are permitted in the UK.

The Australian government did not deny the report. Dan Tehan, Australia’s minister for trade, tourism and investment, told the Guardian: “The Australia-UK free trade agreement will deliver more jobs and greater access for businesses and workers in both countries, all of which will drive economic growth. Australia has remained consistent that all our FTAs should focus on international cooperation and meeting existing multilateral environment commitments.”

He added: “Australia and the UK have agreed to work cooperatively on environmental issues, including emissions reduction … Our technology-not-taxes approach to addressing climate change is delivering results, with updated forecasts showing Australia is on track to meet and beat our 2030 Paris target.”

He also noted that last month, Australia and the UK signed a letter of intent to establish a partnership on low emissions solutions that will focus on research and development across six key technologies including clean hydrogen; carbon capture; small nuclear reactors; and low emissions materials including green steel.

John Sauven, executive director of Greenpeace UK, said the removal of the explicit reference to temperature goals undermined the government’s hosting of the Cop26 UN climate talks this November in Glasgow.

“Signing an Australian trade deal with action on climate temperature commitments secretly removed is the polar opposite of everything Boris Johnson publicly pledged and rips the heart out of what the agreement stands for. It will be a race to the bottom, impacting on clean tech sectors and farmers’ livelihoods,” he said.

“There should be a moratorium on trade deals with countries like Australia until they improve on their weak climate targets and end deforestation.”

Caroline Lucas, the Green party MP, also criticised the removal of explicit language on temperature goals. “This revelation paints a bleak picture of both the government’s priorities and their abysmal negotiating power post-Brexit … their readiness to compromise on the existential challenge of our time raises serious concerns on what else might be on the table in ongoing trade negotiations.”

Ed Miliband, Labour’s business secretary, said the government should be doing more to put pressure on Australia to come forward with stronger commitments on greenhouse gas emissions before Cop26, rather than watering down a trade agreement.

He said: “Australia is one of the world’s biggest polluters and key to the goal of limiting global warming to 1.5C. But rather than piling pressure on them, the government has simply rolled over.

“This government is pursuing trade deals at the expense of our farmers and now our climate targets. This is simply a massive betrayal of our country and our planet.”


Fiona Harvey in London and Daniel Hurst in Canberra

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Global trade deal threatens Paris climate goals, leaked documents show
Controversial Trade in Services Agreement (Tisa) could make it harder for governments to favour clean energy over fossil fuels as part of efforts to keep temperature rises to 1.5C

Arthur Neslen

20, Sep, 2016 @8:00 AM

Article image
UK criticised for ignoring Paris climate goals in infrastructure decisions
Exclusive: scientists write to ministers and supreme court over recent ruling in Heathrow case

Fiona Harvey Environment correspondent

30, Mar, 2021 @8:36 AM

Article image
World leaders hail Paris climate deal as ‘major leap for mankind’
Almost 200 countries sign historic pledge to hold global temperatures to a maximum rise of 1.5C above pre-industrial levels

John Vidal, Adam Vaughan, Suzanne Goldenberg, Lenore Taylor and Daniel Boffey

13, Dec, 2015 @12:00 AM

Article image
EU coal subsidy phase-out 'completely inconsistent with Paris deal'
Stay of execution for coal subsidies has been heavily criticised by climate analysts

Arthur Neslen

19, Dec, 2018 @11:36 AM

Article image
Meat and fish multinationals 'jeopardising Paris climate goals'
New index finds many of the world’s largest protein producers failing to measure or report emissions, despite accounting for 14.5% of greenhouse gases

Bibi van der Zee and Andrew Wasley

30, May, 2018 @6:00 AM

Article image
Tackling degraded oceans could mitigate climate crisis - report
Sanctuaries and treaties to restore seas’ ecosystems would boost their capacity to absorb heat and store carbon

Fiona Harvey in Madrid

04, Dec, 2019 @12:01 AM

Article image
Joe Biden could bring Paris climate goals 'within striking distance'
Biden’s presidency could help reduce global heating by about 0.1C if plans fulfilled, say experts

Fiona Harvey Environment correspondent

08, Nov, 2020 @11:32 AM

Article image
Only Sweden, Germany and France among EU are pursuing Paris climate goals, says study
UK ranks fifth in table assessing EU actions to cut carbon emissions by 40%, with most countries gaining wiggle room via loopholes

Arthur Neslen

28, Mar, 2017 @11:58 AM

Article image
Proposed EU-wide 'climate law' would set net-zero carbon target by 2050
Plan is part of ‘green new deal’ but campaigners say it is not enough to tackle climate crisis

Fiona Harvey and Jennifer Rankin

29, Nov, 2019 @1:42 PM

Article image
Labour urges Theresa May to speed up Paris climate deal ratification
Barry Gardiner has warned the prime minister that any delay risks the UK being sidelined in influencing future action on climate change

Adam Vaughan

31, Aug, 2016 @3:21 PM