Northern Ireland Office may directly instruct trusts to offer abortion services

Exclusive: Brandon Lewis warns he will soon have ‘no alternative but to take further steps’ to ensure services are provided

Brandon Lewis could override the Northern Ireland executive and directly instruct the nation’s health trusts to provide abortion services, warning leaders in a leaked letter that the continued delay is unacceptable conduct in public office.

The Northern Ireland secretary wrote to the first minister, Paul Givan, and his deputy, Michelle O’Neill, warning he would soon “have no alternative but to take further steps to ensure that women and girls have access to abortion services as decided by parliament, and to which they have a right”.

The Guardian understands the Northern Ireland Office could explore working directly with health trusts to implement the abortion provision if Stormont does not take steps to ensure they do so. Lewis warned in his letter that continued failure could leave Stormont in breach of the European convention on human rights.

In a separate letter to the health minister, Robin Swann, Lewis demanded to see a detailed assessment of progress to date and a roadmap to meeting the March 2022 deadline. He said NIO officials had been blocked from attending meetings with the department – which he called “unacceptable.”

Abortion was decriminalised in Northern Ireland in October 2019 after a Westminster vote led by the Labour MP Stella Creasy. But since Northern Ireland’s Department of Health has not commissioned or funded any services, leaving some trusts to try to provide a service without funding or a framework.

Previously in Northern Ireland abortions were allowed only if a woman’s life was at risk or if she was at risk of permanent damage to her mental or physical health. It meant in most cases that women seeking the service were forced to make sometimes traumatic journeys to England, risking prosecution.

Earlier this year, Lewis said he would take unprecedented action and use parliament to give himself new powers to commission the services. Stormont has been formally directed to commission the services before the end of March 2022, but there has been little material improvement.

A high court judge ruled this month that Lewis had failed to uphold his duties to provide full abortion services in Northern Ireland after a judicial review was brought by a woman told to travel to England for an abortion during the pandemic.

Lewis said earlier he was disappointed in the ruling, adding that he had been the only party to take steps to try to force the executive to provide the services.

In the letter leaked to the Guardian, Lewis warned Givan and O’Neill he was prepared to take further unprecedented intervention in Northern Ireland’s health service, saying it was “entirely unacceptable” to attempt to block a legal duty.

“I firmly believe that there is also a moral duty to women and girls to ensure they are afforded their fundamental human rights – the same rights afforded to women and girls in the rest of the UK,” he wrote.

“The executive cannot continue to delay in this matter and the court could well conclude that a decision not to agree to proposals for the commissioning of services breaches article 8 of the ECHR.”

Lewis said he agreed with the judge who called the delay “dispiriting”.

“In fact, I would go further. Those in public office must comply with their legal obligations whether or not they agree with the law in question,” he wrote in the letter.

Lewis said if it became “clear to me” that the Department of Health or executive were “not making sufficient progress, or are intent on blocking this issue, I will have no alternative but to take further steps to ensure that women and girls have access to abortion services as decided by parliament, and to which they have a right”.


Jessica Elgot Chief political correspondent

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Northern Ireland to legalise abortion and same-sex marriage
Equality campaigners were celebrating before the midnight deadline for law to take effect

Rory Carroll Ireland correspondent

21, Oct, 2019 @11:06 PM

Article image
Mordaunt targets ‘appalling’ Northern Ireland abortion laws
Equalities minister calls for government to act after Tory rivals rule out reform

Matthew Weaver and Henry McDonald

03, Jul, 2019 @12:31 PM

Article image
Pro-choice groups raise concerns over possible delays to Northern Ireland abortion law
No 10’s document suggests it may take up to 18 months to implement legislation

Peter Walker Political correspondent

17, Jul, 2019 @3:01 PM

Article image
Northern Irish doctors’ group to fight abortion pill prosecutions
Pro-choice organisation opposes medics being forced to report women to the police

Henry McDonald

11, Aug, 2019 @5:17 PM

Article image
Two Northern Ireland women to get abortion costs compensation
European court orders UK government to reimburse mother and daughter forced to travel to England for abortion

Henry McDonald

19, Dec, 2019 @3:56 PM

Article image
May resists Tory calls to act on Northern Ireland abortion
PM understood to have told MPs in private meeting that political climate makes reforms impossible

Jessica Elgot Political correspondent

04, Jun, 2018 @7:00 PM

Article image
Abortion law 'harsher in Northern Ireland than in Alabama'
Campaigners say women can face jail sentences up to life in UK owing to Victorian legislation

Henry McDonald

15, May, 2019 @1:03 PM

Article image
Catholic bishops back anti-abortion candidates in Northern Ireland vote
Church leaders issue statement urging voters to reject Stormont candidates in favour of reforming abortion law

Henry McDonald Ireland correspondent

28, Apr, 2016 @1:30 PM

Article image
Most of Northern Ireland strongly backs abortion law reform, survey finds
Three in four people back legal abortions for women pregnant through rape or incest and in cases of fatal foetal abnormalities

Henry McDonald Ireland correspondent

16, Jun, 2017 @1:27 PM

Article image
The Guardian view on abortion in Northern Ireland: standing up for women’s rights | Editorial
Editorial: With devolution still on hold, the decision by a huge majority of MPs to vote in favour of equal marriage and abortion should be welcomed


11, Jul, 2019 @5:35 PM