Fingers pointed across the Channel as deaths renew UK-France blame game

Analysis: Deaths of 27 refugees prompt both sides to revert to centuries-old sniping – but neither dares go too far

Writing in Le Monde this week Julian Barnes, the novelist and chronicler of British-French relations, said both sides found it “easy to slip into the role of accuser or affronted victim”, often trading on decades- or even centuries-old stereotypes of one another.

After 27 people died in the Channel, those stereotypes are in full view, and however much each side says it will rise above the blame game, or in Emmanuel Macron’s phrase “instrumentalise” the crisis, it has been almost impossible to resist sniping. The possibility that the simmering, adjacent dispute about post-Brexit fishing licences will finally explode with a blockade of Calais this weekend only adds to the sense that this is a relationship on the edge of nervous breakdown.

The politics are raw. Emmanuel Macron, fighting to ensure a place in the presidential runoff in April, simply cannot afford to let the refugee crisis run away from him. Boris Johnson also has much at stake. Nigel Farage, his mysterious donors readying their cheques, is once again stirring and threatening the Conservative party’s right flank. Johnson’s backbenchers are struggling to square how Brexit regained control of the UK’s border when 25,700 people reached the UK in a slow but steady stream of inflatable boats.

The British prime minister is positively neuralgic about the Channel, according to French sources, repeatedly returning to the subject of migrants and refugees in his private conversations with Macron. Johnson is 80% driven by short-term domestic politics, French diplomats say.

The home secretary, Priti Patel, is in deep trouble, accused of chasing headlines rather than a real-world solution. She promised in 2020 to solve the crisis by the end of that year but has self-evidently failed.

Politically, the easiest route for both sides is to point an accusatory finger across the Channel or adopt the role of victim.

Many officials – military and diplomatic – are in reality eager to keep the relationship functioning and are trying desperately behind the scenes to do so. They are, for instance, still looking for openings to cooperate on defence, including areas such as Mali, knowing defence has been the solid glue in the Franco-British relationship. But alongside the rhetoric of David Frost, the Brexit minister, or Clément Beaune, Macron’s election attack dog, the glue is not sticking.

The French, faced with accusations that they have been dilatory about the Channel crossings, point out it takes only a moment to look at the death toll in the Mediterranean over the past six years to know that if solutions the size of a tabloid headline could quell the urge to cross the Channel, then it would have been found.

More than 20,000 people are estimated to have died in the Mediterranean, and more than 1,300 this year alone.

But Britain is hitting back, saying France is not supposed to be a failed state like Libya, and should do more to close down the people smugglers. London has in the past threatened to cut financial support for France’s border policing if Paris fails to stem the flow of people. The French, in turn, complain that the UK, bereft of identity cards, oversees a labour market into which people can readily blend invisibly.

Faced by this labour market, French opposition politicians, but not yet the government itself, are questioning the Le Touquet agreement, the bilateral treaty that allows British Border Force officers to carry out passport checks in France, and vice versa. The French National Consultative Commission on Human Rights recently said its terms “make France the police arm of British migration policy”.

Before Brexit, it is claimed, this was justifiable, since the UK was subject to the EU Dublin convention, which obliges asylum seekers to apply to the first country in Europe where they have stayed. With Brexit, that obligation dies.

France also grates at moral lectures from Britain; 83,000 asylum applications were lodged in France over the past year, compared with only 31,000 in the UK. In 2020, the UK registered 5.78 asylum seekers and refugees per 10,000 inhabitants, compared with 16.93 for France, 19.52 for Germany and 60.57 for Greece.

But to unilaterally tear up the Le Touquet agreement – in effect waving migrants and refugees through to the UK – would be to drop a bomb into the relationship.

Macron is also aware he needs the rest of Europe on his side. Jean-Yves Le Drian, the French foreign secretary, recently complained that the remarkable aspect of the map of global Britain was that it erased Europe. But there are limits to the European preparedness to fall behind the French tendency to equate the European national interest with the national interest of France.

Germany, for instance, is busy preparing a bilateral agreement with the UK. Liz Truss, the foreign secretary, will soon visit Spain, an astute choice for her first visit to an EU state.

As each side manoeuvres, neither dare go beyond the brink.


Patrick Wintour Diplomatic editor

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Priti Patel says Macron ‘absolutely wrong’ over Channel crossings
Home secretary rebuffs French claim UK immigration policy encourages people to risk dangerous journey

Rajeev Syal and Amelia Gentleman

02, Feb, 2022 @7:39 PM

Article image
UK ministers urged to ‘stop playing politics’ over Channel crossings
Aid groups say more deaths are likely and Britain must allow safe routes for asylum seekers

Jamie Grierson, Jon Henley in Calais and Dan Sabbagh in Dunkirk

25, Nov, 2021 @8:59 PM

Article image
UK’s ‘double talk’ on Channel crisis must stop, says French interior minister
Exclusive: Gérald Darmanin says UK ministers must stop saying one thing in private while insulting his country in public

Kim Willsher in Paris

28, Nov, 2021 @8:48 PM

Article image
Macron says UK failing to live up to its ‘grand statements’ on Ukraine refugees
French president accuses Britain of failing to live up to its claim to be leading the world in helping war victims

Daniel Boffey in Versailles

11, Mar, 2022 @5:39 PM

Article image
France accuses Patel of blackmail in row over Channel migrants
Interior minister says UK plans to return boats of vulnerable people would not be accepted

Rajeev Syal, Jamie Grierson and Angelique Chrisafis in Paris

09, Sep, 2021 @6:45 PM

Article image
Priti Patel says it is up to France to stop refugees crossing Channel
Home secretary reiterates offer to send more police to France after 27 people drown trying to reach UK

Peter Walker Political correspondent

25, Nov, 2021 @8:00 PM

Article image
Boris Johnson accused of scapegoating migrants over Channel comments
PM accused of using ‘inaccurate’ language after describing crossings as ‘dangerous and criminal’

Jamie Grierson and Dan Sabbagh

10, Aug, 2020 @4:46 PM

Article image
EU border agency plane to monitor French coast following Channel deaths
Ministers meeting in Calais also discuss using drones and Frontex border guards

Jennifer Rankin in Brussels

28, Nov, 2021 @11:34 AM

Article image
The Guardian view on deaths in the Channel: the tide of xenophobia | Editorial
Editorial: The government must stop pandering to anti-migrant sentiment and come up with a policy that meets its international responsibilities


25, Nov, 2021 @7:07 PM

Article image
On Channel crossings, France is sick of UK ‘outsourcing’ problems
Analysis: there’s fury at Johnson tweeting out a letter to Macron – and some of the PM’s suggested five steps are inflammatory

Jon Henley

26, Nov, 2021 @12:57 PM