Two Manchester Arena bombing victims could have been saved, inquiry hears

Evidence given that Saffie-Rose Roussos and John Atkinson could have survived with ‘different’ emergency service response

Firefighters did not arrive at Manchester Arena until two hours after the suicide bombing, only one paramedic entered the blast scene in the first 40 minutes, and Greater Manchester police (GMP) did not declare a major incident until the following day, the inquiry into the terror attack has heard.

The Manchester Arena inquiry, which resumed on Monday, moved to examine the response of the emergency services to the tragedy.

The inquiry heard evidence about the deaths of two of the victims, John Atkinson, 28, and Saffie-Rose Roussos – at age eight, the youngest to die in the attack.

“Most of those who died suffered injuries in the bombing that were, on the expert evidence, unsurvivable even with current advanced medical treatment,” said the counsel to the inquiry, Paul Greaney QC. But where Atkinson and Saffie-Rose were concerned, Greaney said: “A different response may have led to a different outcome.”

Atkinson, 28, who later died, was evacuated from the arena’s foyer on a cardboard advertising hoarding 45 minutes after the explosion. He was then moved to an area near a station entrance where he remained for a further 24 minutes before chest compressions commenced at 23.47pm and he was taken away in an ambulance.

A report commissioned by the family of Saffie-Rose claims she might have survived the bombing if she had received better first aid. Saffie-Rose died after excessive blood loss, but the report states her injuries “did not reach a threshold where they would be considered incompatible with life”.

The inquiry, which began last September, was due to resume on 12 January but was delayed due to the coronavirus pandemic. On resuming Monday, Greaney said: “We will explore whether the emergency response really worked that night and, if it did not, whether that failure made any contribution to the extent of the dreadful loss of life that occurred.” He noted that “some of what we have to say will be distressing”.

Suicide bomber Salman Abedi, 22, exploded his homemade rucksack bomb in the foyer of the arena shortly after an Ariana Grande concert at 10.31pm on 22 May 2017. Twenty-two people were killed in the blast which also injured hundreds.

Greaney said “it did not take long” for concerns to emerge about the emergency services’ response. Audio recordings taken from the body cameras of police officers in attendance were played before the inquiry, with one heard to say: “We need paramedics like fucking yesterday”.

Greaney said it was important to acknowledge the immense pressure facing members of the emergency services that night. “Our investigations must not be used to vilify those who did their best on the night,” he said. “That failure was, in the opinion of the experts, of command, not individual responders.”

The inquiry heard that while six North West ambulance service (NWAS) paramedics were at Manchester Victoria station, adjacent to the Arena, within 30 minutes of the blast, and within 40 minutes “at least” eight ambulances had arrived, only one NWAS paramedic had actually entered the foyer of the arena within the first 40 minutes.

Firefighters had assembled at a fire station three miles from the arena but did not attend the scene until two hours and six minutes after the attack. “Why that is so is plainly something that will need to be closely examined during the evidence,” said Greaney.

The hearing continues.


Sasha Mistlin

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Who were the Manchester Arena victims who might have lived?
Inquiry has found outcome for some victims might have been different but for ‘inadequacies’ in emergency response

Helen Pidd North of England editor

03, Nov, 2022 @6:26 PM

Article image
Manchester Arena inquiry: Ways to improve response of emergency services
Inquiry advice includes reviews of police funding and ambulance trusts’ responses to mass casualties, and medical staff based at venues

Helen Pidd North of England editor

03, Nov, 2022 @6:08 PM

Article image
Manchester Arena firefighters don't need to apologise, says Andy Burnham
Risk-averse culture to blame for fire chiefs barring deployment until two hours after bomb blast

Helen Pidd North of England editor

30, Mar, 2018 @10:16 AM

Article image
Manchester Arena attack: the hours of mayhem
Timeline of response of UK emergency services after bombing on 22 May 2017

Helen Pidd

03, Nov, 2022 @2:35 PM

Article image
Kerslake findings: emergency responses to Manchester Arena attack
Firefighters told to keep their distance as it was too dangerous, police took ‘brave, common-sense decisions’, and media ‘hounded’ families

Helen Pidd North of England editor

27, Mar, 2018 @4:09 PM

Article image
Manchester Arena inquiry: victims’ families respond to final report
People who lost loved ones and their representatives speak out as MI5 is accused of a ‘devastating’ failure

Josh Halliday North of England correspondent and Helen Pidd North of England editor

02, Mar, 2023 @7:53 PM

Article image
Cost of police inquiry into Manchester Arena bombing rises to £4m
Around 100 officers still working full time on investigation nearly one year on

Helen Pidd North of England editor

15, May, 2018 @11:01 PM

Article image
Manchester Arena bombing: fire service arrived two hours late, says report
Review highlights ‘risk-averse’ officers in charge and ‘catastrophic failure’ of emergency phone system

Helen Pidd North of England editor

27, Mar, 2018 @11:00 AM

Article image
Manchester police warned in 2016 over terrorism strategy, arena inquiry hears
Inspectorate found majority of force duty officers ‘felt ill-equipped’ to deal with terror incident

Sasha Mistlin

08, Feb, 2021 @8:14 PM

Article image
Manchester Arena attack: firefighters 'ashamed' they could not help victims
Fire brigades union chief says crews were waiting to go in, but the ‘order never came’

Josh Halliday and Matthew Weaver

28, Mar, 2018 @7:46 AM