Chef sentenced after one killed and 31 left ill by undercooked shepherd’s pie

John Croucher admits contravening food regulations after incident in which woman died in Northamptonshire

A church harvest supper at a village pub ended in tragedy when one of the congregation was killed and 31 others suffered food poisoning after eating a shepherd’s pie filled with mince that had been incorrectly prepared by a rushing chef.

Elizabeth Neuman, 92, repeatedly vomited after eating the pie and died while other parishioners became “unpleasantly ill” and three of those attending only escaped because they were vegetarians, Reading crown court heard.

The cook, John Croucher, who at the time was head chef at the Crewe Arms in the Northamptonshire village of Hinton-in-the-Hedges, was given a four-month jail sentence, suspended for 12 months, after admitting a charge of contravening food regulations.

Defending himself in court, Croucher, 40, said: “I hate to say it, I really hate to say it, but I think I was rushed. I was rushing.” He said he had worked in kitchens for 20 years and was now “a better chef” because of the “horrible, horrible circumstance”.

He added: “Remorse is an understatement. This is something I will never forget. Because of it, I am a better chef and it is just a shame the cost of it had to be what it was.”

The judge, Sarah Campbell, said: “On 8 October 2018, 35 villagers went to the Crewe Arms for a harvest meal. Thirty-two people ate the shepherd’s pie. A healthy and well person died of a gastrointestinal haemorrhage induced from vomiting. No sentence I pass can reflect the loss caused to the family.

“Croucher was the chef that night. The mince was not cooked properly and was placed into a pan with iced water. Croucher needed to leave, so put the mince in cling film and put it in the fridge overnight. Having left it, he cooked it again and added warm mashed potato. He did not take the temperature when it was served.”

The court was told that members of the Holy Trinity church congregation did not want retribution against the pub, its landlord, Neil Billingham, or Croucher, who no longer works there.

But the judge raised concerns about the pub’s record, saying: “The Crewe Arms is an important pub to the local community. I have read many references from members of the community. They have all said that this was a one-off mistake but looking at the evidence this was not a one-off mistake.

“The pub should have been taking steps to be improving. Inspections in 2015 gave it three stars and in 2017 gave it only a one star.”

Defending Billingham and his company, the Bobcat Pub Co, Christopher Hopkins told the judge: “You will see that Billingham went to local residents who were affected shortly after, apologising for the incident. He also asks me to express his condolences to the Neuman family on his behalf.”

Billingham, of Northampton, who admitted three charges of contravening food regulations was fined £9,000 and ordered to pay £1,000 court costs. His company was fined almost £3,000.


Steven Morris and agency

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Food poisoning rise linked to undercooked offal
Campylobacter contamination has risen significantly in the last four years after reductions in the early part of the decade

James Meikle

03, Dec, 2010 @6:39 PM

Article image
Asda fined £300,000 after dead mice and flies found at delivery depot
Dead vermin and mouse droppings found during inspection at retailer’s distribution centre in Enfield, north London

Damien Gayle

06, Mar, 2017 @3:23 PM

Article image
Tesco recalls Heinz baby food jars after metal fragments found
Single jar in 7+ months Heinz By Nature baby food range found to be ‘tampered with’

Rebecca Smithers Consumer affairs correspondent

18, Dec, 2019 @7:09 PM

Article image
Jamie Oliver and Wetherspoons caught up in meat recall
Supplier to restaurant chains and schools fails hygiene inspection and is ordered to recall meat

Sophie Dishman

25, Jan, 2018 @2:33 PM

Article image
Call for failing takeaways to display food hygiene scores
Guardian investigation finds one in seven food businesses failed their most recent inspection

Kate Lyons

26, Sep, 2016 @3:34 PM

Article image
One in 10 chickens may still carry highest levels of campylobacter
Potentially deadly bacterium found in half of samples, but Food Standards Agency says testing criteria are no longer reliable

James Meikle

26, May, 2016 @2:31 PM

Article image
Hummus firm in salmonella scare was fined for egg contamination
Zorba fined £93,000 in Wales for supplying egg-free branded tzatziki dip containing egg

Matthew Weaver

05, Nov, 2019 @6:45 PM

Article image
Diner is left shellshocked over crab dish
Restaurant chain Frankie & Benny's admits crab bruschetta was only 45% real crab, with the rest being reconstituted fish paste

Felicity Lawrence

02, May, 2014 @5:09 PM

Article image
Dangerous levels of arsenic found in rice cakes for babies
Study by Queen’s University Belfast finds 50% of baby rice products contain illegal level of inorganic arsenic

Denis Campbell Health policy editor

04, May, 2017 @6:02 PM

Article image
Broken leaves in salad bags raise salmonella risk 2,400-fold – study
Researchers say bacteria naturally present on leaves grows much faster once bag is opened, even when kept in fridge

Haroon Siddique

18, Nov, 2016 @12:37 PM