Incel ideology: a new blurry form of extremism incubated online

Analysis: The Plymouth shootings heralded a new type of terrorist threat, but what hasn’t changed is the socially isolated individuals behind it

For several years, those whose job description includes making the nation safe from terrorism have been documenting something novel and quite chaotic. Thursday’s murderous rampage on the streets of Plymouth merely confirmed the new terror threat has arrived.

The traditional silos of far right and Islamist extremism are disappearing. Instead, the security services are monitoring individuals who have gone for a mixed approach to extremist ideologies, able to accommodate the views of Tommy Robinson alongside Osama bin Laden, often adding a layer of conspiracy theory and fantastical tropes for good measure. Individuals who jump casually between fascist dogma, Islamism or misogyny are increasingly cropping up on the radar of intelligence agencies.

The incel ideology followed by Jake Davison belongs to this new blurry extremism – incubated, propagated and weaponised online.

What hasn’t changed are those seduced. Socially isolated individuals with little stake in society, like Davison, are those most vulnerable. The pandemic has amplified a sense of marginalisation for many. Yet even before the first lockdown, the incel ideology was increasingly popular. Inceldom is classified within a government category known as “mixed, unstable and unclear” ideologies. This category accounted for more than half of all referrals to the counter-terrorism Prevent programme in 2019/20– up from just 11% three years earlier.

Thursday’s killings will mean that the online “manosphere” comes under new scrutiny, its sprawling decentralised network of chat rooms and gaming platforms helping to normalise misogyny. Any attempt to crack down on such hate may, though, only push its members to migrate to newer ungoverned internet platforms.

The police’s decision not to categorise last Thursday’s attack as a terror incident will likely be judged by history as an oversight. Terrorism, by definition, is the threat or use of action to intimidate the public in advancement of a political, religious, racial or ideological cause.

More immediately, it appears to reflect that Devon and Cornwall police are not up to speed with the emerging threat of “mixed, unstable or unclear” ideology.

It is a decision unlikely to be repeated. The next Davison will most likely be known as a terrorist.


Mark Townsend

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
‘‘Shooting has broken our hearts,’ says shattered Plymouth as city mourns its children’s innocence
Keyham’s tight-knit community says the government has ‘big questions’ to answer about gun control

Steven Morris

14, Aug, 2021 @6:17 PM

Article image
Plymouth gunman ranted online that ‘women are arrogant’ days before rampage
Exclusive: Jake Davison, adherent of misogynistic ‘incel’ culture, may have been trying to quit toxic community, final messages reveal

Mark Townsend Home affairs editor

14, Aug, 2021 @2:00 PM

Article image
‘Broken’ gun licensing scheme risks another Plymouth, warn campaigners
Pro- and anti-shooting groups warn Priti Patel over lack of resources for firearms control system

Jon Ungoed-Thomas

22, Jan, 2022 @5:00 PM

Article image
Dead robber 'used fake gun' in Plymouth betting shop raid
Police say masked man apparently carrying imitation pistol when he was disarmed and pinned down by Ladbrokes customers

Cass Jones

27, Jan, 2013 @1:32 AM

Article image
Social networks struggle to crack down on ‘incel’ movement
Analysis: despite action from large platforms and volunteer moderators, communities remain influential online

Alex Hern Technology editor

16, Aug, 2021 @5:45 PM

Article image
Police and faith alliance attacks counter-extremism bill
A diverse coalition has told David Cameron that his strategy to prevent radicalisation could actually promote terrorism

Mark Townsend

21, May, 2016 @6:55 PM

Article image
Police urged to ‘follow the gun’ to cut smuggling amid rise in firearm crime
New UK research centre will chase links between weapons across the world in a bid to identify who is behind supply of guns

Mark Townsend

11, Feb, 2018 @12:05 AM

Article image
Home Office forced to defend anti-fracking groups from extremism claims
Government steps in after council and school identify campaigners as key risks under controversial Prevent programme

Mark Townsend and Ian Cobain

10, Dec, 2016 @8:37 PM

Article image
From a Czech warehouse to a street near you: the journey of a gun
Blank-firing Zoraki handguns, imported from Europe, have been converted to deadly weapons in a shed in Bedford

Mark Townsend Home Affairs Editor

18, Nov, 2018 @8:00 AM

Article image
Police raids find huge arms cache linked to Islamic terror group
Four men arrested in Coventry by counter-terrorism officers after rifle, silencer and ammunition found at two addresses

Mark Townsend

08, Sep, 2019 @8:00 AM