Police and crime bill will create toxic legacy, warns Blunkett

Former UK home secretary says law would drive wedge between officers and the public

The former home secretary David Blunkett has said the police, crime, sentencing and courts bill risks making the UK “more like Putin’s Russia”, and that it would be a “lasting and toxic” legacy for the prime minister.

Writing in the Guardian, Blunkett, who served as home secretary under Tony Blair, has said the government’s plans to use the bill to prevent peaceful protests would “leave a bad taste in the mouths of British people who value tolerance, democracy and open debate”.

“By giving police forces sweeping discretion about how they deal with protesters, this law would drive a wedge between them and the public,” he said.

“Tolerating dissent and protest is a British value, and it’s central to our democracy. It’s ironic that this bill would mean far harsher treatment for protesters in Parliament Square, where statues commemorate Mandela and Gandhi, leaders of historic disruptive, noisy and annoying protest movements now taught in British schools.”

In reference to the criticism the Metropolitan police faced in their handling of the Sarah Everard vigil, Blunkett said the pressure the Met’s commissioner, Cressida Dick, faced “gives us an inkling of the controversies that could blaze across the country if these sweeping powers are pushed on to the police”.

Blunkett’s comments came after a series of “kill the bill” protests against the proposed legislation. In Bristol, police were criticised for falsely claiming officers suffered broken bones during the protests, as well as allegedly assaulting a journalist who was present.

More “kill the bill” protests are planned at the weekend, with police warning protesters that they may be in breach of Covid-19 restrictions if they attend.

Blunkett said that the effects of the legislation passing would be felt across the political spectrum. He said although it was “easy to stereotype the protesters as leftwing”, the bill would mean “alienating others across the centre and right wing of the electorate whom the government won’t want – or can’t afford – to lose”.

He warned that if the bill was to pass into law unamended there would be “more ugly conflicts between the public and the police – and a police force that’s weaker for it”.

“Banning protest would make us more like Putin’s Russia than the UK. It would be a lasting and toxic legacy for Boris Johnson.”

As home secretary, Blunkett faced criticism for the Police Reform Act of 2002, which critics argued would compromise police autonomy and “created the risk that the police could be manipulated for political purposes”.


Tobi Thomas

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Labour urged to vote down ‘draconian’ changes to crime bill
Call for opposition to counter ministers’ ‘cynical attempt to bypass parliamentary scrutiny’

Damien Gayle

19, Dec, 2021 @12:35 PM

Article image
Labour peers to oppose amendments to police and crime bill
Move means late changes focusing on powers to control protests could be voted down in House of Lords

Damien Gayle

14, Jan, 2022 @6:22 PM

Article image
Why is anti-protest bill generating so much controversy?
Critics say handing police and home secretary more discretionary powers will undermine civil liberties

Haroon Siddique and Matthew Weaver

22, Mar, 2021 @10:55 AM

Article image
Blunkett leads attack against police 'overkill' after Green's arrest

Details emerge of nine-hour operation against shadow minister whose wife witnessed a search of their home

Nicholas Watt, Sandra Laville and Alan Travis

29, Nov, 2008 @12:01 AM

Article image
Extinction Rebellion calls move to class it as organised crime group 'ridiculous'
Climate group criticises move by UK government as Labour condemns newspaper protest

Henry McDonald

06, Sep, 2020 @3:02 PM

Blunkett on the police: the Observer interview in full
David Blunkett on his plans to make the police more effective and involve the communities most affected by crime - and why he's been misunderstood on civil liberties (2 December 2001).

Interview with Kamal Ahmed

02, Dec, 2001 @12:15 PM

Article image
Police bill risks criminalising homeless people, warn UK charities
Exclusive: letter to Robert Jenrick says urgent changes needed to bill to avoid threat of jail for rough sleeping

Peter Walker Political correspondent

08, Jul, 2021 @7:00 AM

Article image
Wildlife groups urge MPs to back protest amendments to crime bill
Bee and butterfly groups are among those asking MPs to ‘defend freedoms’ essential to protecting environment

Damien Gayle

23, Feb, 2022 @5:31 PM

Article image
Police spying: activist's personal life monitored and recorded in detail
Tribunal hears how Met spied on environmental activist deceived by Mark Kennedy

Rob Evans

03, Oct, 2018 @4:46 PM

Article image
Bristol police admit protest ban under Covid powers was unlawful
Force apologise and will pay damages for arresting four protesters at Colston statue-toppling hearing

Damien Gayle

22, Apr, 2021 @4:54 PM