Sunak throws budget lifeline to small firms battling coronavirus

Such good intentions will only be truly tested if the economic fallout becomes severe

The chancellor’s emergency measures for the coronavirus economy were targeted almost exclusively at small and medium-sized businesses, or SMEs, the sector where a short-term cashflow crisis can quickly become terminal. For big business, Rishi Sunak offered fewer handouts. The Bank of England, it seems, has been handed the job of protecting them from the global storm.

As an exercise in minimising economic damage, the thinking makes sense. The government cannot restore a supply chain that requires goods to arrive from China or northern Italy, but it can help pubs, clubs, restaurants and retailers on deserted UK high streets.

A survey last week from the Institute of Directors, whose membership is 70% SMEs, underlined the worry. One in five firms ranked the threat to their organisation from the coronavirus as “high” or ‘“severe”. A further 43% said there was a “moderate” threat.

Thus, Sunak seems to be trying to give struggling SMEs a cash buffer by removing, in effect, a chunk of their fixed overheads. Business rates for companies in the retail, leisure and hospitality sectors with a rateable value of £51,000 will be abolished for a year. This measure was “over and above what we expected”, said the IoD’s chief economist, Tej Parikh.

Very small companies that don’t pay business rates – because the rateable value of their properties is below the threshold – will get their own handout in the form of £3,000 cash grant, a £2bn giveaway that will benefit 700,000 business, said the Treasury. The accountants EY called that move “unprecedented”. Meanwhile, pubs will get their own boost with their business rate discount raised from £1,000 to £5,000.

The main virus-related assistance for SMEs was less of a surprise – the government will refund the cost of statutory sick pay for up to 14 days, including for those who self-isolate, at a cost of £2bn.

Will it be enough? That depends primarily on the size and duration of the downturn. The chancellor can breezily pledge to give the NHS “whatever it needs, whatever it costs”, but it would be impossible to make the same promise to SMEs or business in general. Sunak seems to be thinking in terms of quarters – a sharp downturn immediately, followed by a recovery.

Another critical factor will be how quickly the bureaucracy moves. A looser approach by HMRC on granting “time to pay” pleas will only be effective if companies receive a prompt answer.

“My experience of working on government support for small business and bank lending during the 2008 financial crash is that, while today’s announcements may look good, the key question will now be how quickly these can be implemented and feed through to the economy,” said Adam Johnson of Grant Thornton.

The good news, at least compared with 2008, is that the banking system looks solid. The Bank of England’s exercise in shock and awe – an interest rate cut, a funding scheme for SMEs and a relaxation of banks’ capital buffers to allow more lending – was accompanied by an impressive boast. The banks, said the governor, Mark Carney, are capable of lending in aggregate a sum equivalent to 13 times their net loans last year. The financial capacity to dampen the economic blow exists.

The trickier part will be getting credit to the right places when the squeeze is on. We are currently at the stage where banks proclaim their willingness to perform their patriotic duty of helping borrowers in distress.

Those good intentions will only be truly tested when, or if, the economic bite becomes severe. We’re not there yet, and the main economic moral from Sunak’s budget was this: the government thinks the disruption could become nasty very soon.


Nils Pratley

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Sunak faces pressure to support business over coronavirus crisis
Institute of Directors says chancellor must take urgent steps to shore up confidence

Richard Partington, Economics correspondent

09, Mar, 2020 @10:30 PM

Article image
Businesses warn Boris Johnson over U-turn on office working
Lobby groups say latest advice is ‘extraordinarily reactive’ as TUC tells PM to ‘get a grip’

Rupert Neate

22, Sep, 2020 @3:29 PM

Article image
Budget 2020 checklist: what to expect from the chancellor
How the chancellor can offset the worst affects of the coronavirus fallout, from motoring to welfare, pensions to Brexit

Larry Elliott and Ben Quinn

11, Mar, 2020 @6:00 AM

Article image
Hopes rise for Bank of England coronavirus intervention
City expects coordinated response from outgoing governor and new chancellor including rate cut and easier borrowing

Richard Partington Economics correspondent

10, Mar, 2020 @7:59 PM

Article image
Business rates rise is biggest issue for small firms in London
Small firms are angry at the uncertainty and cost of the first business rates rise in seven years, with small firms and London companies big losers

Graham Ruddick

17, Feb, 2017 @12:01 AM

Article image
Economic recovery possible by autumn if west contains coronavirus, says fund manager CEO
Standard Life Aberdeen boss hoping for ‘short sharp downturn’ but urges big stimulus in UK budget

Julia Kollewe

10, Mar, 2020 @11:07 AM

Article image
Javid’s resignation leaves new chancellor just three weeks to prepare budget
Rishi Sunak must add finishing touches to ambitious package billed as new dawn of spending

Phillip Inman

13, Feb, 2020 @5:12 PM

Article image
Events and outbreaks means Rishi Sunak's flagship budget must wait | Richard Partington
The coronavirus will reduce budget 2020 from a big bucks curtain raiser for Boris Johnson’s Toryism to a disaster relief statement

Richard Partington

08, Mar, 2020 @12:09 PM

Article image
Bank of England drafts action plan to head off coronavirus recession
Economists warn UK on cusp of recession as Bank governor talks with Treasury over ‘powerful and timely’ response

Jasper Jolly and Julia Kollewe

05, Mar, 2020 @7:42 PM

Article image
Budget live: Rishi Sunak spends on coronavirus, roads and rail in 'biggest giveaway since 1992'
Chancellor triples investment in transport and infrastructure spending, freezes fuel and alcohol duties, and removes VAT on digital publications

Andrew Sparrow and Graeme Wearden

11, Mar, 2020 @6:24 PM