Home Office reverses attempt to deport Jamaican man 'to Iraq'

O’Neil Wallfall was refused leave to remain for failing to show his life would be at risk in country he has never visited

The Home Office has made a U-turn in the case of a man caring for his terminally ill partner who was told he was going to be deported to Jamaica because officials had concluded that he “failed to demonstrate that his life would be at risk in Iraq”.

The Guardian reported last month that O’Neil Wallfall, 49 – who has never been to Iraq – received a refusal letter that appeared to indicate his case had been confused with that of someone else.

The government also said in the same document that it would not be “unreasonable” or “unduly harsh” to expect his British partner, Karen McQueen, 56, to relocate to his homeland of Jamaica with him. McQueen has a diagnosis of terminal cancer and is awaiting a transplant after kidney failure.

In the letter rejecting Wallfall’s application – which his lawyer said provided clear evidence that the government “copies and pastes” letters and disregards individual submissions when reaching its conclusions – the Home Office wrote: “You have claimed that you will be unlawfully killed on return to Iraq … you have not demonstrated … that death is virtually certain.”

After being contacted by the Guardian, the Home Office said it was reconsidering its decision “in light of further information”.

Last Friday, Wallfall’s solicitor Naga Kandiah, of MTC Solicitors, received a letter from the Home Office that said: “After a review of the case it has been decided to grant 30 months’ leave on the basis of Mr Wallfall’s family life.”

Wallfall has been in the UK since 2002 and has been waiting for 17 years to regularise his status. He has been in a relationship with McQueen for three years. The couple said they were very much in love. She was dependent on him for support with her serious health conditions.

The couple said they were overjoyed about the Home Office U-turn. Wallfall said he broke down in tears when he got the news. “I’ve been waiting 17 years for this,” he said. “Now Karen and I can get on with our lives together. At last I can sleep and don’t have to look over my shoulder for immigration all the time. The first thing I want to do is get a job. I’d love to work as a postman or for the NHS.”

McQueen said: “I don’t think we would have got this change of heart from the Home Office without the Guardian highlighting our case.”

“This is brilliant and unbelievable,” she added. “My life feels complete for the first time. It’s as if our lives have been given back to us by the Home Office and now we’re free.”

Kandiah condemned the original refusal letter citing Iraq and welcomed the government’s change of heart.Before the decision to grant 30 months’ leave he had been planning to challenge the refusal in court.

“This client, like so many others in similar situations, was at the height of vulnerability when this refusal came through,” said Kandiah. “The Home Office has done this U-turn to avoid professional embarrassment in front of a judge had the case had gone to court.”

He said he believed that the Home Office’s copying and pasting of refusal decisions, as in Wallfall’s case, was not a one-off phenomenon.

In another Home Office refusal letter seen by the Guardian, officials said they would deport a man to his home country Sri Lanka because “you are of an economically active age and will be able to return to Nigeria and sustain yourself”. The same letter then added: “You do not have leave to enter or remain in the UK and can be removed to Qatar (Doha) India (Mumbai), Oman (Muscat) and Turkey (Istanbul).”

The Home Office said: “Mr Wallfall’s case was reconsidered in light of further information being provided. This was unrelated to the error in the initial decision letter.”


Diane Taylor

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Jamaican diplomat criticises Home Office over deportation flight
Up to 50 Jamaicans, some of whom came to UK as children, are due to be on flight next week

Diane Taylor

05, Nov, 2021 @4:52 PM

Article image
Home Office cites Iraq in 'copy and paste' refusal letter to Jamaican man
O’Neil Wallfall refused leave to remain for failing to show his life would be at risk in country he has never visited

Diane Taylor

31, Oct, 2019 @11:11 AM

Article image
Jamaican-born deportees mount last-minute challenges against Home Office
Up to 50 people are due to be forcibly returned to Jamaica on a flight leaving this week

Diane Taylor

10, Feb, 2020 @6:00 AM

Article image
Home Office abandons plans to deport Osime Brown to Jamaica
Family celebrate success of campaign to halt deportation of 22-year-old, who has autism

Diane Taylor

15, Jun, 2021 @6:15 PM

Article image
Jamaican high commissioner calls for halt to deportations from UK
Top diplomat hosts emotional meeting of relatives of those deported this month

Amelia Gentleman

21, Feb, 2019 @6:48 PM

Article image
Fish and chips but no passport: Windrush victim returns to UK
Ken Morgan enjoys his first day home after 25 years in Jamaica but wants his seized passport

Aamna Mohdin

11, Oct, 2018 @6:00 PM

Article image
'I feel disgusted': how Windrush scandal shattered two brothers' lives
Trevor and Desmond Johnson’s family units have been destroyed, but they sense Home Office cruelty is routine

Amelia Gentleman

22, Apr, 2018 @6:56 PM

Article image
Retirees returning to Jamaica face extreme murder risk, say police
Returnees warned they are seen as soft targets following multiple killings of UK expats

Josh Halliday

29, Jun, 2018 @12:28 PM

Article image
'I was like a lamb to the slaughter': deported after 35 years in the UK
After visiting Jamaica for his sister’s funeral in 1998, Windrush victim Ivan Anglin was given two days to pack up his life

Amelia Gentleman in Mandeville, Jamaica

02, Sep, 2018 @1:34 PM

Article image
UK deportation flight to Jamaica leaves with just seven people on board
Home Office-chartered flight costs an estimated £43,000 a person after Covid fears and high court challenges

Diane Taylor

11, Aug, 2021 @10:24 AM