Smacking children to be banned in Wales

New law will remove Victorian defence of ‘reasonable punishment’ by parents

Parents are to be banned from physically punishing children under legislation being introduced on Monday by the Welsh government.

Ministers in Cardiff are hoping Wales will become the first country in the UK to stop fathers, mothers and other adults acting in a parental capacity from smacking children to punish them.

The law would remove the defence of “reasonable punishment” that has been in force since Victorian times in England and Wales.

The Welsh government insisted mothers and fathers would still be able to parent effectively. It said the proposed law would not stop a parent from grabbing a child about to step out into a busy road, or brushing a youngster’s hair against his or her will.

But it argued that the time when it was acceptable to strike a child to punish misbehaviour had gone.

Julie Morgan, the deputy minister for health and social services, said: “We are sending a clear message that the physical punishment of children is not acceptable in Wales.

“What may have been deemed as appropriate in the past is no longer acceptable. Our children must feel safe and be treated with dignity. The legislation will be accompanied by an awareness-raising campaign and support for parents.”

Research published last year found one in 10 parents in Wales said they had recently smacked a child to manage their behaviour. In 2015 it was one in five. According to the study, 81% disagreed with the statement “It is sometimes necessary to smack a naughty child.”

The bill is also significant because if enacted it will be seen as the first major divergence between Welsh and English law since Wales was given more lawmaking powers two years ago.

A private member’s bill to ban the physical punishment of children has been introduced in Scotland and it is not clear whether it or Wales will be the first to bring in a ban.

About 50 countries have already brought in a ban and another 50 are considering doing so, but there are no plans in England for a such a law.

Morgan added: “I don’t see any signs of the UK government doing this.” She has campaigned against smacking for 20 years as an assembly member and before that as MP for Cardiff North. “I think that they [the UK government] felt nervous about it, they felt the time was not right; it feels in Wales the time is right. I’m sure England will follow.”

The Children Wales bill was being introduced on Monday and is expected to receive cross-party support.

If passed, adults acting in a parental capacity will not be able to use the common law defence of reasonable punishment if accused of assault or battery against a child. The Welsh government said it would be up to citizens to decide if they should report a parent they saw smacking a child and down to the police and Crown Prosecution Service to judge whether to prosecute. But it said the proposed law was all about changing attitudes.

Physical punishment is already against the law in schools and other education settings. Removing the defence is seen as the last step in making the physical punishment of children illegal in all settings.

Welcoming the announcement, Sally Holland, children’s commissioner for Wales, said: “There’s nothing reasonable about physically punishing a child. This bill sends a clear signal that Wales is a country which protects children; a country which will afford children equal protection from physical punishment as adults; a country which promotes children’s rights.”

Viv Laing, head of policy at NSPCC Cymru, said: “It’s wrong that children in Wales have less protection from assault and that a legal defence which does not exist when an adult is hit can be used to justify striking a child.”

The defence of reasonable punishment has been in place in England and Wales since the notorious trial of the teacher Thomas Hopley in 1860, who beat a pupil to death. He was convicted of manslaughter but the judge said “moderate” corporal punishment was allowed to correct “what is evil in the child”.

Contributor

Steven Morris

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Smacking children ban moves step closer in Wales

Welsh assembly approves call to withdraw defence of 'legal chastisement' that parents can currently use

Steven Morris

19, Oct, 2011 @8:08 PM

Article image
Sport protects mental health of children who experience trauma
Study finds abused or neglected children who play sports are less likely to develop mental illness

Steven Morris

18, Jan, 2018 @12:01 AM

Article image
Wales introduces ban on smacking and slapping children
Welsh government hails ‘historic moment’ for children’s rights amid calls for England to follow suit

Steven Morris

21, Mar, 2022 @12:01 AM

Article image
Inquiry calls for new offence in England and Wales of failing to report child abuse
Final report of independent inquiry into child sexual abuse also urges creation of scheme to compensate victims

Haroon Siddique Legal affairs correspondent

20, Oct, 2022 @12:01 PM

Article image
Wales could ban parents and carers from smacking children
Government proposes removing defence of reasonable punishment from offences of assault and battery

Steven Morris

09, Jan, 2018 @6:00 AM

Article image
Labour MP backs smacking of children

David Lammy steps back from partly blaming riots on anti-smacking laws but says law must be relaxed so parents can instil discipline at home

Alexandra Topping

29, Jan, 2012 @7:17 PM

Article image
Epidemic of violence against women under way in England and Wales – report
Radical shift needed in how police tackle crimes disproportionately affecting female victims, says watchdog

Jamie Grierson Home affairs correspondent

07, Jul, 2021 @12:08 PM

Article image
Child sexual abuse inquiry’s findings fall short for many victims
Lawyers criticise ‘loopholes’ in call for mandatory reporting in England and Wales

Rajeev Syal

20, Oct, 2022 @5:14 PM

Article image
Logan Mwangi’s murder: major review of Welsh social care needed, says expert
Senior social worker calls for action in the only country of the UK that has not had a recent review

Patrick Butler Social policy editor

22, Apr, 2022 @5:22 PM

Article image
Caldey Island victim: 'It should be given over to the National Trust'
A victim of Thaddeus Kotik returns to Caldey after 35 years and is haunted by memories of abuse

Amanda Gearing and Steven Morris

20, Jul, 2018 @3:47 PM