Meghan, Duchess of Sussex, threatens to sue Mail on Sunday

Paper published letter from royal saying father Thomas Markle had ‘broken her heart’

Meghan, the Duchess of Sussex, has threatened the Mail on Sunday with legal action under the Copyright, Designs and Patents Act for publishing a private letter she sent to her father, in which she said he had broken her heart “into a million pieces”.

Representatives of the duchess, formerly known as Meghan Markle, have been in touch with the newspaper after its decision earlier this month to publish the handwritten message sent to Thomas Markle in which, according to sources, she complained with a “heavy heart” about the pain her father was causing by giving media interviews.

Meghan complained to her father about “manufacturing this fictitious narrative” about being cut out of her life with Prince Harry, aided by his regular newspaper and TV interviews. Thomas Markle missed last year’s royal wedding after it was revealed he had colluded with a paparazzi agency to stage photos of himself at home in Mexico.

He allowed the Mail on Sunday to publish extracts of the letter earlier this month, saying he was doing so in response to critical interviews given by the duchess’s friends in the US magazine People. The newspaper commissioned a “handwriting expert” to analyse the letter.

Royals have previously invoked the copyright act in an attempt to keep material out of the public domain. The Mail on Sunday was targeted by Prince Charles in 2005 after it published extracts from a journal he wrote for friends during the handover of Hong Kong to China. The Daily Telegraph has previously suggested that Kensington Palace was considering a similar approach over the recent letter penned by the duchess’s father.

It is unclear how the Mail on Sunday will respond to the potential legal action and the letter remains available on Mail Online.

“A letter is a copyright work as it is a literary work,” said Alex Newman, the national head of intellectual property law at solicitors Irwin Mitchell. “As soon as you create a copyright work, you will own the copyright until it expires automatically. This gives you the right to prevent anyone else copying, or issuing to the public, the whole or a substantial part of your copyrighted work.”

The Mail on Sunday printed nine separate extracts from the five-page handwritten letter, which were promoted on the front page as a world exclusive.

Newman said there were exceptions from copyright law for “fair dealing” when reporting current events and reviews, meaning it was possible to publish extracts without the approval of the creator in certain circumstances.

He said the newspaper’s legal justification for publishing could rest on whether it published a “substantial part” of the letter, taking into account both the proportion of the letter that was printed and the importance of the sections that were used.

Buckingham Palace, which looks after the affairs of the most senior royals, has separately written to the Mail on Sunday to complain about the decision to publish photographs in January featuring the Queen on a pheasant shoot on her Sandringham estate, arguing the monarch had a reasonable expectation of privacy when on her private land.

The newspaper has stood by its decision to print the pictures of the Queen carrying dead birds while on a shoot with Princess Anne and the former Formula One driver Jackie Stewart, insisting that the photographs were taken from a public road.

Kensington Palace and the Mail on Sunday declined to comment.

Contributor

Jim Waterson Media editor

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Meghan calls for tabloid industry overhaul as Mail on Sunday loses appeal
ANL had brought appeal after duchess sued publisher over articles relating to letter she sent to estranged father

Caroline Davies

02, Dec, 2021 @2:43 PM

Article image
Meghan to receive just £1 from Mail on Sunday for privacy invasion
Newspaper accepts defeat and will pay additional unspecified sum for infringing her copyright

Jim Waterson Media editor

05, Jan, 2022 @6:00 AM

Article image
Meghan wins privacy case against Mail on Sunday
Judge gives summary judgment in favour of royal over extracts of letter by estranged father, Thomas Markle

Caroline Davies

11, Feb, 2021 @6:01 PM

Article image
The Duke and Duchess of Sussex may win the battle but lose the war
The Mail on Sunday lawsuit will draw a line in the sand between the royals and the media

Jane Martinson

06, Oct, 2019 @1:45 PM

Article image
Mail on Sunday publishers to pay ‘financial remedies’ to Duchess of Sussex
Newspaper runs front-page statement and 64-word story stating it infringed copyright over letter to father

Mark Brown

26, Dec, 2021 @2:41 PM

Article image
‘Palace Four’ drawn into Meghan’s dispute with Associated Newspapers
Ex-employees of royal couple could shed light on drafting of letter to Thomas Markle, high court hears

Caroline Davies

20, Jan, 2021 @2:47 PM

Article image
Why is Meghan suing the Mail on Sunday?
Action comes after newspaper has published numerous embarrassing stories about her

Jim Waterson Media editor

02, Oct, 2019 @1:58 PM

Article image
Meghan wins copyright claim against Mail on Sunday over letter
Duchess granted summary judgment after lawyers argue publisher advanced its defence dishonestly

Caroline Davies

05, May, 2021 @2:34 PM

Article image
Mail on Sunday can print smaller statement than Meghan requested, says judge
Lord Justice Warby reviews mock-up of front page and finds notice is ‘sufficiently prominent’

Ben Quinn

22, Mar, 2021 @6:02 PM

Article image
Meghan granted £450k interim payment in Mail on Sunday privacy case
Duchess of Sussex wants front-page apology and for newspaper to hand over copies of letter to her father

Caroline Davies

02, Mar, 2021 @4:00 PM