Westminster attack: police urged to review questioning of terror suspects

Watchdog concludes that it is not always appropriate to ask detailed religious questions of detainees

Police were “reasonable and proportionate” in arresting 12 innocent people after the Westminster terrorist attack, but should review when it’s right to interrogate suspects about their religious views, an official report has said.

The 12 people were arrested after Khalid Masood first mowed down pedestrians on Westminster Bridge, killing four people, before running into the grounds of parliament before he stabbed PC Keith Palmer to death.

The report into the police investigation by Max Hill QC, the independent reviewer of terrorism legislation, concludes that detectives from Scotland Yard’s counter terrorism command got it right and mounted an “impressive” operation.

Police officers, under Operation Classific, hunted for any accomplices to the 22 March 2017 attack, which was the first mass casualty terrorist atrocity to strike Britain in over a decade.

Those arrested were mainly British Muslim, though did include Hungarian and Saudi nationals as well as Masood’s wife.

All were released without charge having come under suspicion for reasons ranging from repeated phone or electronic contact with Masood, connection with an address Masood had lived at in Birmingham and placing money in his bank account for professional reasons.

Hill said questioning people about their religion will cause “understandable concern”, but police believed the attack may have been incited by the violent extremist ideology of Islamic State.

Masood sent a document via WhatsApp and an Apple iMessage justifying violence to a number of people while behind the wheel of the vehicle he used to stage the attack. The document contained passages from the Qu’ran and was called “Retaliation”.

Hill said: “Operation Classific did not lead to the arrest and detention of any person based on ethnicity or religion.

“When challenged by me as to why questions about religious belief and adherence were asked during post-arrest interviews, Operation Classific officers pointed to the religious extremist nature of Masood’s views and intention, evidenced in his final communications before crossing Westminster Bridge on 22 March. The police reasonably believed there was a ‘pro-Islamic State’ element to the attack that day.”

The independent reviewer, a barrister by profession, said police should carry out a review: “It does not follow that it would be appropriate to ask detailed religious questions in every case where a Muslim has been arrested on suspicion of [terrorism].

“I therefore recommend, in the interest of clarity, that the police take this opportunity to review training on the circumstances and extent to which such questions will be necessary in future interviews. I accept, however, that questioning detainees about religion or any other matter occurs with careful thought and planning.”Hill praised the police operation: “It is against that background that Operation Classific amounted to what in my view was an impressive, flexible, fast-moving investigation which appeared to face significant challenges, but which reached fruition over several days, where a longer exercise might have been understandable or expected.”

The security minister, Ben Wallace, said: “Our comprehensive terrorism legislation gives the police the powers they need to investigate terrorist atrocities and we were all witness to their swift and effective work following the Westminster attack.

“We are pleased that Max Hill QC has concluded that the investigation was impressive, flexible and fast-moving.”

Hill said none of the 12 arrested co-operated with his review.


Vikram Dodd Police and crime correspondent

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Westminster attack: Masood did act alone, police conclude
Counter-terrorism officials are seeking no one else but are rethinking how to stop unsophisticated attacks like Khalid Masood’s atrocity

Vikram Dodd Police and crime correspondent

13, Apr, 2017 @7:09 PM

Article image
MPs raise concerns about parliamentary security after attack
Met review of Palace of Westminster will focus on Carriage Gates, where terrorist fatally stabbed PC Keith Palmer

Rajeev Syal, Rowena Mason and Heather Stewart

23, Mar, 2017 @11:58 PM

Article image
Westminster attack: 75-year-old man becomes fourth victim – as it happened
Police name Khalid Masood, 52, born in Kent as man responsible for attack in which three victims have died and seven more are critically injured

Claire Phipps, Andrew Sparrow, Jessica Elgot and Chris Johnston

24, Mar, 2017 @6:03 AM

Article image
Police unravel multiple aliases of Westminster terrorist Khalid Masood
The 52-year-old Kent-born attacker had been convicted of violent offences and may have been a late convert to Islam

Vikram Dodd, Nazia Parveen, Ewen MacAskill and Jamie Grierson

24, Mar, 2017 @8:29 AM

Article image
Police hunt man who tried to frame person for Westminster terror attack
Gerald Banyard found guilty of perverting course of justice over attack by Khalid Masood in 2017

Alex Mistlin

12, May, 2021 @4:36 PM

Article image
UK's anti-terror chief fears rights group boycott threatens Prevent review
Neil Basu says move to oppose appointment of William Shawcross could harm process

Vikram Dodd Police and crime correspondent

22, Feb, 2021 @12:32 AM

Article image
Parliament security to be reviewed by police and authorities
Met and authorities to examine arrangements following terror attack with focus on Carriage Gates entrance

Rajeev Syal and Anushka Asthana

23, Mar, 2017 @10:30 AM

Article image
Westminster attack: PC's family accuse Met of ‘closing ranks’
Keith Palmer’s loved ones hit out at police force as inquest finds armed officers misinterpreted orders

Aamna Mohdin and Vikram Dodd

03, Oct, 2018 @4:28 PM

Article image
Met police hit back at criticism of ex-chief over Westminster attack
Sir Craig Mackey remained in his car while Khalid Masood killed an officer last year

Haroon Siddique

12, Oct, 2018 @4:33 PM

Article image
Met police face legal action over death of PC Keith Palmer
Officer stabbed and murdered during a terrorist attack on parliament in March 2017

Vikram Dodd Police and crime correspondent

20, Apr, 2020 @1:33 PM