The Traitors US review – pure, evil, shout-at-the-TV brilliance

If you thought the unbearably tense gameshow couldn’t get any more vicious, try adding celebrities. Episode eight will be the best hour of reality TV in 2023, hands down

There’s nothing like a bit of backstabbing to liven up the doldrums of January. Clearly, someone at the BBC agrees, as arriving on iPlayer in its entirety is the US version of 2022’s best reality show, The Traitors. A word-of-mouth hit, this bum-clenchingly tense gameshow revitalised the watercooler moment, set group chats alight and garnered huge iPlayer numbers.

For those who missed it, the gameplay went something like this: 22 contestants headed to a castle in the Highlands where, joined by the host, Claudia Winkleman, they competed to win a cash prize. Sowing seeds of discontent were the traitors, three members of the group who were chosen to “murder” their fellow contestants and thereby reduce the player pool. The rest of the players – the faithful – were tasked with unhooding the traitors at nightly roundtable discussions, where accusations and paranoia rose to the surface. During the day, meanwhile, they worked as a team to win money. If the faithful successfully eliminated all the traitors before the final, they got to share the prize pot. If a traitor remained, they won everything.

While a second series has yet to be officially commissioned, the US version of the show, which is based on the Dutch series De Verraders, has already been filmed. Replacing Winkleman is the debonair actor Alan Cumming, who switches the former’s collection of knitwear for a patchwork of tartan suits and a wild mid-Atlantic Scottish accent. Unlike in the British version, the contestants are a mix of normal people and former reality TV stars, from The Real Housewives of Beverly Hills, Below Deck, The Batchelor, Survivor and US Big Brother plus, for some reason, the Olympic swimmer Ryan Lochte.

Debonair … Alan Cumming in The Traitors US.
Debonair … Alan Cumming in The Traitors US. Photograph: Euan Cherry/BBC/Studio Lambert & All3Media International

Anyone who delighted in the camaraderie between contestants on the British show might find the dynamic between almost-famous faces and normies difficult to begin with. This is a group of people who, from the off, are at odds with each other, and they remain so until the last few episodes. Part of this, perhaps, is down to the inclusion of so many big personalities. The former Real Housewife Brandi Glanville and Below Deck’s Kate Chastain are the most divisive characters by far, bringing a wicked but entertaining quality to the round tables and hushed gossip sessions.

Kate’s feud with Rachel Reilly, a contestant from US Big Brother, becomes particularly barbed, albeit with some fabulous one-liners from Kate, who at one point says Rachel’s outfits look like community theatre costumes. This hostility runs over into the round tables, where allegations of deceitful gameplay morph into personal attacks. “If I’m incorrect,” Kate says after voting for Rachel, “I’m OK with it, because I find you really offensive.”

The slanging matches aren’t solely between these two, though: one early suspect for traitor, a 35-year-old office manager called Michael, is pummelled from every angle, his personality dissected and criticised over numerous round tables. You would feel sorry for him if he hadn’t spent one of the challenges whispering ultimatums to the other contestants to convince them to banish a 29-year-old actor, Geraldine, who, much to Michael’s chagrin, turns out to be a faithful.

There is far more scheming and duplicity among these contestants. While UK players often resorted to groupthink during round tables, here you see faithful and traitors manipulating weaker players throughout the day, setting them on anyone perceived as suspicious. The traitors are far more distrusting of one another, which results in some jaw-dropping plot twists.

Far more duplicitous … The Traitors US.
Far more duplicitous … The Traitors US. Photograph: BBC/Studio Lambert & All3Media International

Overall, it’s a far more vicious approach, which only highlights how dynamic and unpredictable the format is. No two people will play the same way, even when they are meant to be working in tandem. The misstep here is the decision to drop all episodes at once: The Traitors feels best enjoyed through the communality of linear broadcasting.

Still, by the time you reach episode eight (which could already scoop the award for the year’s best hour of reality TV), the tension is so unbearable that you will be glad the last two episodes are there for binging. Just be prepared for the stress-inducing final episode, which is pure shout-at-the-TV brilliance. As one contestant says in episode nine: “Everybody’s all in love now, but there will be blood later.” They are not wrong.


Alim Kheraj

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Rise and Fall review – it’s The Traitors meets The Apprentice!
This reality series from the makers of the Claudia Winkleman hit shares a lot of DNA with the BBC show – and Big Brother, and a certain Alan Sugar vehicle …

Jack Seale

19, Mar, 2023 @10:15 PM

Article image
The Traitors review – Claudia Winkleman’s new show is sick, twisted … and totally addictive
Paranoia, guilt and sociopathy plague the 22 strangers collaborating to win cash – because the Strictly host is secretly ordering some of them to ‘murder’ at night. You’ll be hooked

Lucy Mangan

29, Nov, 2022 @10:30 PM

Article image
The Traitors finale review – so thrilling your heart won’t stop hammering in your chest
The pay-off of this gloriously twisted gameshow has such high stress, hellish back-stabs and helicopter dives that everyone ends up crying … even Claudia Winkleman

Alim Kheraj

22, Dec, 2022 @10:15 PM

Article image
Wellmania review – this wellness-spoofing comedy is incredibly watchable
This Netflix series from Instagram star Celeste Barber is absorbing, amusing, no-nonsense TV. It’s the perfect way to unwind

Rachel Aroesti

29, Mar, 2023 @4:14 PM

Article image
Citadel review – this absurdly fun spy thriller is televisual crack
Prime Video paid $250m for this spy caper. Is it worth it? You betcha. It’s Mission: Impossible meets The Bourne Identity - with twists, turns and Stanley Tucci. What addictive bliss

Lucy Mangan

28, Apr, 2023 @5:00 AM

Article image
Maryland review – no one is more moving than Suranne Jones
Jones and Eve Best star in this joyful and incredibly affecting drama about two sisters forced to confront their mother’s mysterious death and double life

Lucy Mangan

22, May, 2023 @9:00 PM

Article image
Mulligan review – Tina Fey is a post-apocalypse Liz Lemon!
The team behind 30 Rock offer up a cartoon dystopia about an alien invasion that leaves the idiots ruling the Earth – but where are the gags? Frankly, this just won’t do

Lucy Mangan

12, May, 2023 @8:00 AM

Article image
The Days review – this nuclear disaster drama is no Chernobyl
Netflix’s recreation of the 2011 Fukushima nuclear disaster is disappointingly insight free. It’s obsessed with facts to the point where it neglects both character and story

Jack Seale

01, Jun, 2023 @8:00 AM

Article image
Great Expectations review – Olivia Colman is mesmerisingly sinister
The Oscar winner is so good that the rest of this adaptation from the Peaky Blinders creator feels like filler. But do we really need yet another take on Dickens’ novel?

Lucy Mangan

26, Mar, 2023 @9:00 PM

Article image
Treason review – say hello to TV’s cuddliest spy
Gripping as this fun, frenetic espionage thriller is, its lead isn’t exactly a hard nut. Think cheerful lectures to schoolkids and channelling the personality of a lovely labrador …

Stuart Heritage

26, Dec, 2022 @6:00 AM