Inside Man review – Stanley Tucci goes full Hannibal Lecter in rollicking death row drama

Tucci is a smug prisoner; David Tennant is a sweet vicar with a secret. Their tales come together confidently in this funny and typically meaty mystery from Steven Moffat

I wonder how Anthony Hopkins feels about being a serial killer, not just for an age but, the way things are shaping up, for all time? It is 31 years since he gave us his Hannibal Lecter in The Silence of the Lambs – since he sucked his teeth and looked down the lens straight into our livers and spoke in the light, Larry Hagmanish drawl that made everything he said 300 times more gruesome. He remains the nonpareil and it is hard to come out from under his boiler-suited shadow.

In the new Steven Moffat drama Inside Man (BBC One), Stanley Tucci is burdened by many parallels with the great man/awful character. He plays Jefferson Grieff, a softly spoken, highly intelligent prisoner, on death row for murdering his wife. People come to him for insight into their stalled cases and he enjoys toying with them until he deigns to provide his unsettled visitors with solutions to their problems. The latter are deduced in a manner that can only be described with reference to another great man/awful character, Sherlock Holmes, whom Moffat himself resurrected in a way that will probably prove as hard to beat for the next few generations. Tucci works hard to make him his own man, but it is elsewhere that the real innovation lies.

Grieff’s story at first runs alongside an apparently unrelated narrative unfolding in an English village, around sweet vicar Harry (David Tennant) and a – pivotally – unsweet maths tutor Janice (Dolly Wells). We meet her seeing off a young, drunk man (that unmistakable blend of creepiness and aggression perfectly captured by Harry Cadby) who is intimidating young journalist Beth Davenport (Lydia West) and other women on a tube carriage. This core of steel, and possibly this journalist, are going to make Harry’s life very difficult soon.

Vicar Harry is given a flash drive by his troubled young verger Edgar (Mark Quartley) that turns out to contain child sexual abuse images. An unlucky chain of events means Janice sees it, and believes it belongs to Harry’s son Ben (Louis Oliver). He is an incredibly unrewarding teenager, but Harry loves him and tries to convince Janice that she is mistaken, without betraying Edgar. This is a weak point in the tale. I suspect a lot of people were screaming, like me, at the television: “Betray the paedophile!” But we all understand how fiction works, so a little more effort to suspend disbelief is applied and on we go.

A struggle between Harry and Janice ensues and she ends up unconscious in the cellar. Harry locks the door behind him. And the show becomes a twisting interrogation of Grieff’s assertion that we are all murderers – we just haven’t met the right person yet.

When Beth visits the prison to interview Grieff for a piece, and then ask his advice about the missing Janice, the weaving together of the stories begins. Only the first two of the four episodes were provided for review but the mystery is clearly going to deepen.

Inside Man is typical Moffat fare. Rollickingly confident, meaty, funny, clever (if not quite as clever, on a line by line basis, as it appears). Wells – cast here after her tremendous turn in Moffat’s last project, the glorious Dracula, and hopefully now a permanent member of his rep company – is brilliant as Janice. The ineffable oddity and unremitting moral authority she brings to the trapped woman gives the whole thing an anything-could-happen air that shifts you anxiously to the edge of your seat, even though nothing truly terrible has occurred. Tennant is in non-frantic, non-spitty mode – which is a relief. Tucci sells his slightly smug, slightly portentous section of the script well, and some fine comic relief is provided in the form of his sidekick, Dillon (Atkins Estimond), a serial killer (“I went to a therapist – I really opened up! She left the profession”) from the next cell. Think Brooklyn Nine-Nine’s Doug Judy with a murderous edge. If you aren’t a Moffat fan, watch it for Dillon alone. If you don’t get sucked into the rest of the romp, I would be surprised, but I’d like to think you had this joy at least.

• This article was amended on 3 October 2022 to include the name of the actor who plays Dillon – Atkins Estimond.

Contributor

Lucy Mangan

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
There She Goes review – a beautiful, cathartic return for David Tennant and Jessica Hynes
This taboo-breaking comedy about parenting a child with disabilities is back for a one-off special with an air of finality. It’s sad, funny, lovely and tearjerking all at once

Jack Seale

21, Jun, 2023 @9:00 PM

Article image
Stanley Tucci: Searching for Italy review – a sweet, light delight of a documentary
Be warned: the actor’s so charming that you risk becoming pregnant through the screen as he guides us round the land of his forefathers

Lucy Mangan

27, Feb, 2022 @8:02 PM

Article image
Around the World in 80 Days review – David Tennant channels a Victorian Jeff Bezos
An ode to travel in a time before PCR tests, Tennant’s Phileas Fogg is a wealthy chaser of a fantastical journey in this big, lively and timely adaptation

Rebecca Nicholson

26, Dec, 2021 @7:30 PM

Article image
Then Barbara Met Alan review –a true 1990s love story of people power in action
This nimble biopic tells the tale of a comedian and a musician, both with disabilities, who were fed up of being patronised and marginalised. Their protest-packed tale is perfect for our times

Jack Seale

21, Mar, 2022 @10:10 PM

Article image
Litvinenko review – this woeful David Tennant drama is nigh-on pointless
This dramatisation of the poisoning of an ex-Russian spy takes a murder and turns it into a plodding police procedural that’s far less interesting than the truth. Why bother?

Lucy Mangan

15, Dec, 2022 @10:48 AM

Article image
Criminal season two review – stripped down police drama is catnip for mystery lovers
With each episode set in a single interview room, its meaty exploration of thorny modern dilemmas and brilliant performances by Sophie Okonedo and Kunal Nayyar elevate the Netflix drama

Rebecca Nicholson

16, Sep, 2020 @2:52 PM

Article image
Mayflies review – Martin Compston reveals hidden depths in this drama of death and betrayal
The Line of Duty actor displays impressive restraint in this series – an adaptation of a novel about a fortysomething who makes a death pact due to his terminal cancer

Stuart Jeffries

28, Dec, 2022 @10:00 PM

Article image
Champion review – Candice Carty-Williams’s confident rap drama is full of certified bangers
This hugely entertaining show from the Queenie author sees Top Boy’s Malcolm Kamulete shine as a British rap star battling his sister. Is its writer now south London’s TV bard?

Ellen E Jones

01, Jul, 2023 @9:00 PM

Article image
Trigger Point series two review – Vicky McClure’s bomb disposal drama goes harder than ever
Expect plenty of explosions, shouting and TV that isn’t exactly subtle. It may be nonsense, but it’s gripping nonsense

Rebecca Nicholson

28, Jan, 2024 @10:00 PM

Article image
Death of England: Face to Face review – state of the nation drama is a fast, furious triumph
This amalgamation of two National Theatre monologues makes for an unflinching, highly impressive examination of race, identity and toxic masculinity

Lucy Mangan

25, Nov, 2021 @11:25 PM