Mind Over Murder review – a truly moving testimony to the healing power of art

This psyche-shatteringly crazy true-crime documentary meticulously shows not just the frailty of humanity – but how a damaged community can be repaired

In terms of its content, Mind Over Murder (Sky Crime) is as psyche-shatteringly batshit as any of its many stablemates in the true-crime documentary genre. Formally, it is a thing of precision-engineered beauty.

It could have, should have sprawled, if for no other reason than the number of alleged perpetrators involved. The Beatrice Six, as they came to be known, comprised Joseph White, Thomas Winslow, JoAnn Taylor, James Dean, Debra Shelden and Kathy Gonzalez. The terrible murder of which they were accused and the case built against them nearly 40 years ago are laid out in the first two episodes of this meticulous six-part docuseries by Nanfu Wang.

Helen Wilson, a 68-year-old grandmother, was “the glue that held us all together”, says her grandson Shane, interviewed along with many of her other relatives, all of whom have been repeatedly devastated by her killing and the events that unfolded thereafter. She was raped and murdered in her apartment in Beatrice, Nebraska, in 1985. She had clearly fought for her life. The family got a call that she had died and assumed it was of the pneumonia she had been suffering from. They heard the truth on the car radio as they drove into town. Shane hid under the blanket she had made that was in the back of the car when he heard, so that his brothers wouldn’t see him cry.

There was little evidence for the police to work with, beyond some blood – non-secretor type B – that didn’t match Helen’s. In the days before DNA testing, this didn’t allow them to do much more than eliminate people as they conducted their inquiries.

Former police officer Burt Searcey offered to run a private investigation for the family. He turned up a lead from a woman who said Taylor had confessed that she and White had committed the crime. Using footage from the interviews with Searcey and the police, Wang reconstructs the investigation that led to confessions from Taylor and the others who would be implicated in the murder.

And then, of course, over the next four episodes, comes the peeling back of the layers of apparent truth (which took in reality the next 35 years) to reveal the innocence of the six, how they came to be convicted and exonerated and the real murderer identified.

Four years after Helen Wilson’s murder, investigator Burt Searcey makes a breakthrough in the case, as police start to piece together the victim’s final hours
Four years after Helen Wilson’s murder, investigator Burt Searcey makes a breakthrough in the case, as police start to piece together the victim’s final hours. Photograph: HBO

The frailty – moral, mental, emotional – of humans is everywhere. There are the egos of those in power, be it the police, psychologists or the attorney general, who cannot bear to admit they might have made mistakes – and those who seemingly just don’t care. There is the extraordinary vulnerability and suggestibility of people already battered by life and well-trained in the need to bow to authority to try to avoid extra punishment. There is the desperate need of grieving people for answers. There is the more desperate need for the human mind to find the best way of making sense of the most absurd and awful reality, even if it means agreeing with a psychologist that your dreams about the murder you have been arrested for mean that you must have been there, and just blocked out the memory.

From this toxic mass arise a set of false confessions and a sextet of convictions (only White, less disadvantaged intellectually and socially than the others, insisted on his innocence throughout), despite no DNA or other reliable evidence linking any of them to the crime. A new state attorney comes in and has a team re-examine the case; the interviews Wang conducts with its members and lawyers – who eventually secured the six exonerations and conducted a successful civil suit against the county – make their incredulity clear, along with the fury that their clients seem still too traumatised to express fully.

Wang also tracks the effects on Beatrice itself. How the rumours grew, how the town divided as new doubts and evidence surfaced – and how it still remains conflicted. Most of the inhabitants Wang interviews – a measure of the trust she gained while embedded there – retain some vague sense, handed down through generations now, that the six must have been there even if they didn’t kill the widow Wilson.

To add what seems at first like an unnecessary further layer, the programme-makers have commissioned a play to be performed by the local theatre group, using verbatim dialogue from interview, trial and appeal transcripts. But what seems at first a gimmicky flourish turns out to be an inspired decision. After nearly six hours spent examining how we can warp and ruin lives, the final 20 or 30 minutes offer a measure of hope and a truly moving testimony to what often sounds like a dead phrase, but here is on display as a living, breathing thing: the healing power of art.

  • Mind Over Murder is available to watch on Sky Crime in the UK and Binge in Australia.


Lucy Mangan

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Saved by a Stranger review – moving stories of reunion and healing
Two people – one a victim of terror, the other a survivor of war – search for the individuals who changed their lives in BBC Two’s profoundly affecting new series

Rebecca Nicholson

29, Apr, 2021 @9:00 PM

Article image
Devil’s Advocate review – a mind-boggling tale of a real-life grifter
This documentary looks at the rise and fall of the ‘lawyer’ Giovanni di Stefano, whose list of clients reads like a Who’s Who of criminality – from Saddam Hussein to Harold Shipman

Lucy Mangan

15, Feb, 2022 @11:00 PM

Article image
Murder Island review – a contest to solve the killing of a young woman? Bad timing
Teams of amateur detectives compete to crack a grisly case and win £50,000. So far, this new hybrid reality show seems half-baked and unpropitious

Lucy Mangan

05, Oct, 2021 @9:30 PM

Article image
Oti Mabuse: My South Africa review – proof that TV has the power to educate like no other medium
The Strictly star returns to the township near Pretoria where she grew up, bringing a light and upbeat touch to issues of racial injustice that occasionally leave a chill in the air

Jack Seale

17, Nov, 2022 @10:00 PM

Article image
Kathy Burke: Money Talks review – TV filler that’s 10 a penny
With trademark directness and authenticity, the actor offers glimpses of insight in this two-parter exploring wealth in Britain. However, analysis is severely lacking

Lucy Mangan

05, Jul, 2021 @10:05 PM

Article image
The Money Maker review – Obama guru leads a one-man Dragons’ Den
This new series sees CEO and ex-presidential adviser Eric Collins help flailing British businesses. Will his calm authority – and southern charm – stop them from going bust?

Lucy Mangan

04, May, 2021 @9:00 PM

Article image
Myanmar: The Forgotten Revolution review – as chilling and courageous as TV gets
As we watch young protesters become a guerrilla army with just one firearm between them, this startling film lays out the brutality of last year’s military coup. This is not just television – it is evidence for a future war crimes trial

Phil Harrison

25, Jul, 2022 @11:05 PM

Article image
Super Surgeons review – the cancer doctors who really should have God complexes
This awe-inspiring documentary follows the doctors at the Royal Marsden hospital, who are pushing the limits of what is medically possible … and seem impossibly modest with it

Lucy Mangan

18, Jul, 2022 @10:05 PM

Article image
Undercover Ambulance: NHS in Chaos review – a lethal lottery seen through horrified eyes
An emergency medical worker spent months secretly filming his harrowing existence for this heartrending documentary about our broken health service. How much more can we take?

Jack Seale

09, Mar, 2023 @10:00 PM

Article image
The Gold: The Inside Story review – follow that smelter in the Rolls-Royce!
As a companion to the superb drama, this documentary confirms, and occasionally corrects, the astonishing details of the 1983 Brink’s-Mat robbery. But there are just too many nuggets to fit in

Jack Seale

20, Mar, 2023 @10:00 PM