Trouble harfoot? Amazon’s Lord of the Rings epic divides Tolkien fans

There can be no middle ground on Middle-earth, as reactions to The Rings of Power demonstrate

Being one of the richest people on the planet, Jeff Bezos is not used to being told what to do. But when Amazon announced it was creating The Lord of the Rings: The Rings of Power, which is likely to become the most expensive television series ever made, he received a blunt order from his son: “Dad, don’t fuck this up.”

With legions of diehard JRR Tolkien fans ready to pore over every detail of the series, pleasing them all was always going to be as hard as traversing Mordor. And the global release of its opening shows on Friday has revealed there is, unsurprisingly, no middle ground when it comes to Middle-earth.

After greedily devouring the first two episodes, released at 2am in the UK, some fans were in seventh Valinor, while others have lambasted its creators for, in the words of one energised armchair critic, “​​spitting on the legacy of Tolkien”.

Away from the furies of social media, the reaction is nuanced, says Shaun Gunner, the chair of the Tolkien Society. Although with more than 500 members of the society gathering for Oxonmoot in Oxford this weekend, and a screening of the first two episodes and a panel discussion planned, debate is likely to be impassioned.

“I think it’s fair to say there are some mixed reactions from members about what they’ve seen,” says Gunner. “Some of them are saying it’s amazing, beautiful, spectacular. Other members are not so sure.”

Gunner says the show’s creators have taken great pains to engage the Tolkien community, and was among 100 fans who went to the star-studded premiere in Leicester Square, London, graced by Bezos. His verdict? “I’m excited to see more,” he says. “Very few people are just writing it off … I would say cautious optimism is probably where most people are at.”

The Rings of Power – which the Guardian review called so astounding it made the rival HBO series House of the Dragon “look amateur” – covers the Second Age of Middle-earth. It is set around 2,000 years before Frodo Baggins sets out on his fateful journey from The Shire in Lord of the Rings and introduces the dark lord Sauron and the story behind the forging of the Rings of Power.

Unlike the Peter Jackson adaptations of The Lord of the Rings and The Hobbit, the Amazon Prime series is not based on a novel, explains Dr Dimitra Fimi, a lecturer in fantasy and children’s literature and specialist on JRR Tolkien at the University of Glasgow, but on the appendices of The Lord of the Rings trilogy – the rights of which cost a cool $250m (£216m).

Sir Lenny Henry at The Rings of Power world premiere at the Odeon, Leicester Square, London.
Sir Lenny Henry at The Rings of Power world premiere at the Odeon, Leicester Square, London. Photograph: Jeff Spicer/Getty Images for Prime Video

“They have the bare bones of a story, but they don’t have the detail,” she says. “They have to invent characters, they have to invent storylines, but keep it within that skeleton. It’s an interesting creative challenge.”

Some have taken umbrage at the fact that there are “Hobbit-esque” characters – called harfoots – in the show, as Tolkien wrote that hobbits did nothing noteworthy before the Third Age. Other less savoury criticism has focused on the diverse casting, because, as Lenny Henry, who plays the harfoot elder Sadoc Burrows, put it: “They have no trouble believing in a dragon, but they do have trouble believing … a black person could be a hobbit or an elf.”

In the farther reaches of the internet there was a “really awful backlash”, says Fimi. “Scholars were rushing to say, well, [Tolkien’s world] wasn’t as white as you think. But we were attacked, it was quite serious. That shows the strength of feeling here but, at the same time, how it can go a bit extreme.”

Andrew Higgins, a Tolkien scholar and fan, argues the move is important – not only because, he argues, Tolkien never wrote that all elves should be white, but because it helps bring new fans to the writer.

“If someone sees a character that they can relate to, that’s a great way to get into Tolkien,” he says.

Away from the so-called culture wars, the grumbles are more likely to increase if the show’s writers – the relatively unknown writing duo Patrick McKay and JD Payne – create a world that does not feel authentically Tolkienian, says Dr Mark Atherton, a lecturer in English language, Old English and medieval English literature at Regent’s Park College, Oxford.

“It’s all in the detail,” says Atherton. “If you don’t get that right […] then you should do something else, you should make your own fantasy, not base it in Tolkien’s world, it seems to me – but I might be biased, I teach medieval literature.” Atherton is reserving judgment as he is yet to see the show, but has – Bezos will be no doubt pleased to hear – subscribed to Amazon Prime in order to watch.


Alexandra Topping

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Amazon’s Lord of the Rings cast reveal clips from The Rings of Power at Comic-Con
Morfydd Clark, Owain Arthur and more tease scenes from new series for fans at San Diego fantasy convention

Harry Taylor

22, Jul, 2022 @10:08 PM

Article image
Full-length trailer for Amazon’s £1bn Lord of the Rings prequel is released
The Rings of Power series to air on Prime from September, and is set thousands of years before films based on JRR Tolkien’s stories

Nadeem Badshah

14, Jul, 2022 @11:00 PM

Article image
The Lord of the Rings: The Rings of Power review – so astounding it makes House of the Dragon look amateur
The visual splendour of this rich, gorgeous Tolkien drama will make you gawp throughout. Watch it on the largest TV you can

Rebecca Nicholson

31, Aug, 2022 @2:00 PM

Article image
Game of Thrones v Lord of the Rings: who will win the epic battle of the spin-offs?
Hundreds of millions of dollars have been flung into making prequels of the fantasy franchises. But which will triumph? Or, with no familiar characters, could both end in disaster?

Steve Rose

28, Jul, 2022 @5:00 AM

Article image
Amazon's new Lord of the Rings 'cannot use much of Tolkien's plot'
Scholar working on the show says the author’s estate has refused permission to depict any of the events shown in Peter Jackson’s films

Sian Cain

09, Aug, 2019 @3:27 PM

Article image
Amazon delays The Rings of Power ratings to combat fake reviews
Move by Prime Video comes amid ‘anti-woke’ backlash to diverse casting in Lord of the Rings prequel

Alex Hern

04, Sep, 2022 @1:48 PM

Article image
‘Until now, audiences have only seen the story of the One Ring’: details announced for Lord of The Rings TV show
The most expensive show of all time reveals the title of a prequel that’s set to feature 20 different rings of power

Alexi Duggins

19, Jan, 2022 @4:53 PM

Article image
Amazon announces Lord of the Rings TV adaptation
The streaming service has acquired the rights to JRR Tolkien’s fantasy epic and has committed to a multi-season series with potential spin-offs

Guardian staff

13, Nov, 2017 @7:39 PM

Article image
The Lord of the Rings: The Rings of Power recap episode eight – finally, evil shows its face
In this first season finale, mysteries are answered, characters show their true selves and we say goodbye to a friendly face

Andy Welch

14, Oct, 2022 @1:25 PM

Article image
The Lord of the Rings: The Rings of Power recap episode three – less slow-motion horse riding please!
Is this a show full of action-packed fight sequences? Or painfully whimsical equestrian moments and harfoot migration? Both, but it would be nice to see more of the former …

Andy Welch

09, Sep, 2022 @8:00 PM