Netflix’s The Crown ‘cruelly unjust’ for leaving off accuracy disclaimer, says Judi Dench

The actor is accusing programme-makers of blurring the lines between historical accuracy and crude sensationalism, thereby damaging the monarchy

Dame Judi Dench is calling for a disclaimer to be added to The Crown to tell viewers the show is not historically accurate.

In a letter to the Times, Dench said the Netflix hit “seems willing to blur the lines between historical accuracy and crude sensationalism” the closer the drama comes to the present day.

She goes on to express her concern that “a significant number of viewers, particularly overseas, may take its version of history as being wholly true.

“Despite this week stating publicly that The Crown has always been a ‘fictionalised drama’, the programme-makers have resisted all calls for them to carry a disclaimer at the start of each episode … the time has come for Netflix to reconsider.”

Dench also notes events due to be covered in the upcoming fifth series, some of which have already drawn criticism: “Given some of the wounding suggestions apparently contained in the new series – that King Charles plotted for his mother to abdicate, for example, or once suggested his mother’s parenting was so deficient that she might have deserved a jail sentence – this is both cruelly unjust to the individuals and damaging to the institution they represent.”

Speaking to the Mail on Sunday, former prime minister Sir John Major said a scene which apparently portrays a plot to oust Elizabeth II was “a barrel-load of malicious nonsense”.

Major’s office released a statement that said: “Sir John has not cooperated in any way with The Crown. Nor has he ever been approached by them to factcheck any script material in this or any other series.

“As you will know, discussions between the monarch and prime minister are entirely private and – for Sir John – will always remain so. But not one of the scenes you depict are accurate in any way whatsoever. They are fiction, pure and simple.”

In response to Major’s comments, a spokesperson for The Crown said: “The Crown has always been presented as a drama based on historical events.

“Series five is a fictional dramatisation, imagining what could have happened behind closed doors during a significant decade for the royal family – one that has already been scrutinised and well-documented by journalists, biographers and historians.”

The Crown returns on Netflix on 9 November.


Sammy Gecsoyler

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Judi Dench wins royal rumble as Netflix labels The Crown ‘fictional dramatisation’
Trailer now comes with disclaimer after the actor accused the show of sacrificing accuracy for ‘crude sensationalism’

Sammy Gecsoyler

21, Oct, 2022 @12:13 PM

Article image
John Major dismisses The Crown as a ‘barrel-load of nonsense’
Former PM angered by fictitious storyline in which Charles seeks his help in getting the Queen to abdicate

Emine Sinmaz

16, Oct, 2022 @4:46 PM

Article image
Elvis Costello's teenage obsessions: 'I had a massive crush on Judi Dench in 1966'
The musician remembers using Fleetwood Mac to learn the guitar, house parties with advocaat and Motown, and being wowed by The Clangers

Interview by Dave Simpson

01, Oct, 2020 @2:12 PM

Article image
Y-fronts at the ready! Why the Crown casting Jonny Lee Miller as John Major is discomfiting fans
After Gillian Anderson as Margaret Thatcher, the series has cast the Trainspotting star as the former PM known as the grey man of politics

28, Jun, 2021 @4:50 PM

Article image
Judi Dench: 'In my mind's eye I'm six foot and willowy and about 39'
At 86 and in lockdown, the actor finds herself in the rare position of not working. Instead, she talks about theatrical ghosts, her friendship with Harvey Weinstein and definitely not being a national treasure

Xan Brooks

22, Jan, 2021 @6:00 AM

Julie Walters and Judi Dench: hallmarks of quality

While not everything they do is brilliant, their appearance in a drama certainly raises the bar

Gareth McLean

27, May, 2008 @12:30 PM

Article image
Judi Dench: 'Does nobody ever believe anything I do?'
'It's Alan Bennett and I behind glass in some forgotten old cupboard – I don't like it at all': Dame Judi Dench tells Kira Cochrane what she really thinks about being a national treasure

Kira Cochrane

11, Sep, 2009 @11:05 PM

Article image
Judi Dench is right about The Crown: the truth counts. But it’s not everything | Stephanie Merritt
The actress suggested that the drama should carry a health warning about its imperfect connection to reality

Stephanie Merritt

23, Oct, 2022 @7:00 AM

Article image
Friday’s best TV: Noel Edmonds, Judi Dench and Delicious
The Swap Shop host’s one-off live show strikes a nostalgic chord, while the Dench’s glittering career is profiled in a thoroughly entertaining retrospective. Plus, Sky cooks up a soapy drama starring Dawn French and Emilia Fox

Graeme Virtue, Luke Holland, Grace Rahman, Jack Seale, David Stubbs, Ali Catterall, Paul Howlett

30, Dec, 2016 @6:20 AM

Article image
Every Judi Dench film – ranked!
From her 1964 big-screen debut to the 90s roles – including James Bond’s boss, M – that made her a Hollywood star, here’s the rundown of every single Dench movie

Peter Bradshaw

18, Apr, 2019 @12:00 PM