The Traitors review – Claudia Winkleman’s new show is sick, twisted … and totally addictive

Paranoia, guilt and sociopathy plague the 22 strangers collaborating to win cash – because the Strictly host is secretly ordering some of them to ‘murder’ at night. You’ll be hooked

The Traitors (BBC One) is the Highlands Hunger Games. It is terrible – a pandering to our basest, most voyeuristic, atavistic instincts, an exercise in exquisite cruelty lasting 12 weeks. You’re going to love it.

Like all the best tortures, the set-up is simple. Twenty-two people are taken to an isolated spot – a huge castle in the wilds of Scotland – to complete a series of tasks together that will increase the prize money (up to a possible £120,000), which will be split among the winners. Fine! Dandy, you might even think! Except that three of the contestants are secretly designated – by host Claudia Winkleman – “traitors”. They get to “murder” one person a night to reduce the competition. The group can eliminate one person a day. They must try to identify the traitors and get them out because if a traitor survives to become one of the prizewinners, he or she will walk away with the whole sum. Thus are the seeds of discord sown with a lavish hand.

Somehow, I’ve made it sound complicated. It really isn’t. Not least because the rules are, in a sense, immaterial – all you really need to know is that the game has been ruthlessly designed to set individual against individual, exploit every inch of humanity’s capacity for suspicion, dissembling, paranoia, guilt, sociopathy and every other unpleasantness you can think of. The knowledge that there are three traitors in their midst is like a poison creeping through the group. But as it works on them, they must come together to do the tasks as a unified whole to maximise their profit. If the makers had had the balls, they would have called it Headfuck.

The participants in this evilly addictive venture are – in a masterstroke of casting – very, very normal. Although in many ways it is a mixture of The Apprentice and Big Brother, The Traitors has managed to avoid the attention-seeking desperadoes, poseurs and chaos demons that habitually infest reality TV and given us the more terrifying spectacle of ordinary people coming undone instead.

There is 54-year-old “glam-ma” Amanda from Swansea. There is hearty Andrea (72, retired), young blond Alex and young red-haired Tom who are secretly a couple, 25-year-old wholesome BMX athlete Aaron who fancies Alex “more than anything in the world!”, slightly robotic PhD holder Imran, 49-year-old John (Scottish spa therapist) and many others.

Amos, Maddy, Fay, Ivan, John, Theo, Kieran, Andrea, Wilfred, Meryl, Alyssa, Tom, Claudia Winkleman, Aisha, Imran, Alex, Claire, Nicky, Matt, Amanda, Rayan, Hannah and Aaron.
Amos, Maddy, Fay, Ivan, John, Theo, Kieran, Andrea, Wilfred, Meryl, Alyssa, Tom, Claudia Winkleman, Aisha, Imran, Alex, Claire, Nicky, Matt, Amanda, Rayan, Hannah and Aaron. Photograph: Mark Mainz/BBC/Studio Lambert Associates

As ever at the start of such shows, the number of people to keep track of is slightly overwhelming. Twenty-two is a lot of competitors. But Winkleman – in a series of tweed suits at least as fabulous as any of her Strictly outfits – is a pro and marshals them with aplomb. She’s an inspired choice for the job in other ways, too. The requirement to stay detached and deliver awful news or instructions, to be the spectre at the feast, is balanced by her natural warmth and the sense of her fibrillating desire to help only barely being constrained. Without that, the show would tip over into irredeemably bleak hellscape. Even faster.

The three traitors are designated and meet at night to discuss who their first victim should be. This requires thinking at least five steps ahead, and you can only marvel at what the human mind can do when the prospect of £120,000 lies in front of it. One traitor gleefully volunteers to sign the death warrant, while another shakes at the magnitude of what has been done.

Thus one person is missing at next morning’s breakfast table and the first hairline cracks begin to appear in individuals’ and the collective psyche.

Reviewers have signed a blood oath not to reveal any of the murders or banishment results in the three episodes we’ve been permitted to see. So I will just say: hmm, fair enough; OMG – really?! Have a good goddamn look at yourselves, people; you have GOT to be kidding me; and, if you hurt that sweet boy I am coming for you, oh, OK, I see it but really, this is not the way to be going about things and – oh, what?! THAT’S a new colour on you! God, I hope you’re next, I really do.

Check back with me in a month and see if you agree.


Lucy Mangan

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
The Piano review – Claudia Winkleman’s new talent show is an utter delight
The sheer wonder of tinkling the ivories is showcased in this new series’ diverse selection of instant stars. They perform in train stations, wow commuters and are absolutely fascinating

Jack Seale

15, Feb, 2023 @10:00 PM

Article image
TV tonight: Claudia Winkleman’s new show is a world away from The Traitors
She meets the pianists who play in train stations. Plus, Next Level Chef. Here’s what to watch this evening

Hollie Richardson, Ali Catterall, Jack Seale, Graeme Virtue, Ellen E Jones and Simon Wardell

15, Feb, 2023 @6:20 AM

Article image
Rise and Fall review – it’s The Traitors meets The Apprentice!
This reality series from the makers of the Claudia Winkleman hit shares a lot of DNA with the BBC show – and Big Brother, and a certain Alan Sugar vehicle …

Jack Seale

19, Mar, 2023 @10:15 PM

Article image
Scared of the Dark review – the stupidest reality show of all time
Boring, derivative and occasionally downright horrible, this series convinces celebrities to spend a week fumbling around a pitch-black bunker. It’s tedious in the extreme

Lucy Mangan

16, Apr, 2023 @9:15 PM

Article image
100% ruthless: why the nasty US Traitors ruins the reality show
It’s full of reality TV stars, packed with mean competitiveness and has none of the charming sincerity of the UK version. Hopefully it’s not a warning sign for series two …

Rebecca Nicholson

19, Jan, 2023 @11:30 AM

Article image
Alone review – have any of this survival show’s contestants even been outside before?
They have to survive in the wilderness for as long as possible – but these Brits can’t start fires, are constantly terrified and can’t be trusted with sharp objects. Which isn’t as funny as you might think…

Lucy Mangan

06, Aug, 2023 @9:00 PM

Article image
The Traitors finale review – so thrilling your heart won’t stop hammering in your chest
The pay-off of this gloriously twisted gameshow has such high stress, hellish back-stabs and helicopter dives that everyone ends up crying … even Claudia Winkleman

Alim Kheraj

22, Dec, 2022 @10:15 PM

Article image
Alone: the finale review – a slog from beginning to end (for viewers, at least)
Challenging solo travellers to survive in the wilderness may sound like the most extreme show ever – but all it’s been is endless clips of bored, lonely people trying to fish

Jack Seale

10, Sep, 2023 @9:00 PM

Article image
Strangers on a Plane review – so dim it makes Made in Chelsea seem like Newsnight
Take five strangers, fly them to Benidorm and get them to each curate a day of entertainment – it must have been a desperate morning at the ideas meeting when this was commissioned

Stuart Jeffries

03, Apr, 2023 @5:00 PM

Article image
My Mum, Your Dad review – Davina McCall’s ‘middle-aged Love Island’ is hilarious ... and excruciating
This reality show is not only full of fascinating and genuinely funny moments; it’ll also make you weep. The kids forced to watch their parents flirt will want to vomit – the rest of us will have a marvellous time

Lucy Mangan

11, Sep, 2023 @9:00 PM