Mammals review – James Corden is a loutish manbaby in this lame, risible drama

Superstar playwright Jez Butterworth makes a rare foray into TV – and casts a shouty Corden as a husband you may not be very surprised has been cuckolded

Mammals (Amazon Prime) is a rare foray into television by wunderkind playwright Jez Butterworth, starring his friend James Corden. If that conjunction gives you mental whiplash, at least it will be good preparation for watching the thing.

Corden plays Jamie Buckingham, a devoted husband to Amandine (Melia Kreiling), who is expecting their first child. We meet them holidaying next to Sir Tom Jones (playing himself) and watching in awe as a whale surfaces majestically in front of them. Everything, you see, is going to be metaphor, even if it is not yet and may never be entirely clear for what.

Corden is shoutily one-note from the off and things do not improve much thereafter, though he is given more to work with. Amandine miscarries and, using her phone to call all those who need to be given the awful news, Jamie discovers she has been having an affair with someone called Paul. The fundamentally unbelievable pairing of Jamie, imbued as he is with Corden’s ineradicable loutish manbaby quality, and his luminously beautiful, gracious and intelligent wife makes this less of an upset to the viewer than Butterworth was perhaps hoping.

There is a twist at the end of the first episode that you may or may not see coming, but which you will hugely enjoy either way, and which heralds the relentless implosion of the rest of Jamie’s life over the remaining five short instalments.

Bolted on to the main narrative is that of his – at first unfathomably – unhappy and distracted sister Lue (Sally Hawkins), who takes refuge from life in daydreams about being Coco Chanel’s assistant, enjoying all the freedom and glamour of high fashion society in 1920s Paris. These, along with Tom Jones and various cetacean interludes, provide a surrealist element to the otherwise straightforward relationship drama that is obviously part of a reach for profundity that never quite gets there.

Sinking feeling … Sally Hawkins in Mammals.
Sinking feeling … Sally Hawkins in Mammals. Photograph: Dignity Productions/Amazon Studios

Mammals is concerned with fidelity – how we define it, why we place so much importance on it and what happens when a party fails in it. The problem is that it barely raises these questions, let alone interrogates them. Amandine’s motivations – much like Amandine herself, who is less character than cipher – remain opaque until the very end (with another twist that I think it is more likely you will have seen coming). The infidelities that play out are the stuff of a thousand dramas, films and novels we have seen before. And the script rarely shows any sign of having flowed from the pen of one of the finest writers of his generation. “We’re still a family, aren’t we?” asks Amandine’s young daughter after the miscarriage, which is an emetic rather than heartbreaking line, and the scene in which Amandine’s mother hands over a family heirloom violin at the memorial service verges on risible. Its only purpose, it becomes clear, is to give Jamie something significant to smash in episode two when further revelations have made his feelings need loutish manbaby expression.

It clearly has ambitions, philosophically and formally, but nothing works well enough for it to succeed on its own terms. But if you ignore the clever-clever bits, the basic story holds the interest well enough over its half-hour stints. Hawkins, Kreiling and Colin Morgan (as Hawkins’ neuroscientist husband Jeff, whose university lecture is used to flag the fact that only 3-5% of mammals have any concept of sexual fidelity) do sterling work. But while Corden is a better actor than is often remembered, here he only engenders the feeling that the project overall represents a wasted opportunity.


Lucy Mangan

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
‘I think I can improve greatly’: James Corden on inadequacy, nerves and his return to TV acting
The chatshow host’s new Amazon show Mammals sees him team up with revered playwright Jez Butterworth for a knockout turn as a grumpy chef. The pair explain how their brilliant new show is like ‘a duet’

Ryan Gilbey

28, Oct, 2022 @12:00 PM

Article image
Solos review – a dystopian dud even Anne Hathaway can’t rescue
Despite its A-list cast – including Hathaway, Helen Mirren and Morgan Freeman – Amazon’s Black Mirror-inspired anthology is stodgy, cheesy and woefully underdeveloped

Jack Seale

21, May, 2021 @3:00 PM

Article image
The Underground Railroad review – harrowing, magical, masterful TV
Barry Jenkins’ extraordinary adaptation of the Colson Whitehead novel about escaping the clutches of slavery is hallucinatory and heartbreaking. Just don’t binge-watch it

Lucy Mangan

14, May, 2021 @5:00 AM

Article image
Love Life review – this deeply romantic drama portrays love impeccably
Never sickly, full of nuance and with a star turn by The Good Place’s William Jackson Harper, series two of this romantic anthology shows love in all its flawed, human glory

Rebecca Nicholson

06, May, 2022 @10:45 PM

Article image
Black Bird review – Ray Liotta is heartbreaking in this posthumous prison drama
This exquisitely pitched true-crime series about an inmate having to befriend a serial murderer at the behest of the FBI is a fitting farewell to the Goodfellas actor

Lucy Mangan

08, Jul, 2022 @5:00 AM

Article image
Top Boy review – this brilliant crime drama always leaves you guessing
Netflix’s show about London drug gangs is back, adding instantly engaging new characters to an incredibly impressive cast. It’s at its peak – and not moving from that spot

Ellen E Jones

18, Mar, 2022 @6:00 AM

Article image
Extrapolations review – even Meryl Streep can’t save this convoluted eco drama
An impossibly starry cast put in brilliant performances in this anthology series about the climate crisis. If only it weren’t a chaotic, overly worthy plod

Lucy Mangan

17, Mar, 2023 @9:00 AM

Article image
My Brilliant Friend review – this gorgeous drama is television at its best
Series three of this impeccably stylish adaptation of Elena Ferrante’s novels is seductive, cinematic and weaves a spell unlike anything else

Rebecca Nicholson

10, Mar, 2022 @10:05 PM

Article image
Deceit review – Rachel Nickell drama probes the ethics of entrapment
Niamh Algar puts in a phenomenal performance in this four-parter about the controversial undercover police operation which followed Nickell’s death, and events that beggar belief

Lucy Mangan

13, Aug, 2021 @9:00 PM

Article image
Gavin and Stacey Christmas special review – absolutely crackin'!
The Billericay-Barry massive are back. And we won’t tell a lie ... in these less innocent times, they are most welcome

Lucy Mangan

25, Dec, 2019 @9:30 PM