Australian Monarchist League calls for boycott of The Crown and Netflix

AML says Netflix must ‘correct the record’ and add disclaimer to address ‘falsehoods’ about the royal family

The Australian Monarchist League has called on audiences to stop watching The Crown and boycott Netflix if the streamer “does not act to correct the record” and add a disclaimer to episodes of the drama to address purported “falsehoods and inaccuracies” about the royal family.

The streaming service added a disclaimer to the trailer for the drama’s fifth season last week, following growing criticism about the show’s accuracy, including from the likes of former UK prime ministers Sir Tony Blair and Sir John Major, as well as actor Dame Judi Dench.

Dench wrote a letter to the UK’s Times newspaper, stating that the show “seems willing to blur the lines between historical accuracy and crude sensationalism” and accused Netflix of misleading viewers by failing to warn that it is not “wholly true”, calling on the steaming service to add disclaimers to episodes.

While a disclaimer was subsequently added to the season five trailer, stating that the show is a “fictional dramatisation” and “inspired by real events”, Netflix has yet to add disclaimers to any episodes.

The AML chairman, Philip Benwell, said that while the league had not endorsed the show previously, it was calling on “monarchists and right-minded people” to boycott both the show and Netflix if “falsehoods and inaccuracies” were not more strongly acknowledged.

“It is one thing to create a clearly fictitious narrative such as Robin Hood, but quite another to purposefully build a series including falsehoods and inaccuracies about people still living,” Benwell said.

He said the disclaimer on the trailer was “inadequate”.

“Many people who watch historical series do so believing them to be a true depiction of events and a sort of semi-documentary, which undeniably many are,” he said. “These unsuspecting people, unaware of the true situation, will undoubtedly take the falsehoods and inaccuracies contained in The Crown to be genuine.

“It is also disgraceful that Netflix is airing their new series two months after the death of the Queen and just over six months from the coronation of the King about whom the series contains falsehoods.”

Of particular concern to the AML was a scene in the upcoming season in which King Charles, then the prince of Wales, meets with Major to discuss ousting his mother, Queen Elizabeth II. Major has been outspoken in his displeasure about the scene, writing most recently to the UK’s Daily Telegraph: “Fiction should not be paraded as fact.”

Benwell said: “Even before Sir John issued a statement saying that that fictitious conversation was ‘a barrel-load of malicious nonsense’, it is fundamentally clear that Prince Charles would never have spoken about the Queen abdicating because he of all people knew that because of the oath her majesty swore at her coronation, she would never abdicate as the commitment she gave was for life.”

Charles, portrayed by Dominic West, is also reportedly shown trying to recruit Blair as an ally to protect his future and pave the way for him to marry Camilla, shortly after the 1997 general election. A spokesperson for Blair has called it “complete and utter rubbish”.

However, actor Claudia Harrison, who portrays Princess Anne in the fifth season of the Netflix hit, has said disclaimers would “patronise the audiences worldwide, and to think people are genuinely sitting down thinking this is a documentary and that everything they see is fact, I feel uncomfortable with that … Patronise an audience at your peril.”

As an actor, she was “incredibly uncomfortable” with the idea of putting disclaimers on art, she added.

At the season five premiere in London on Tuesday night, Netflix chief executive Ted Sarandos called The Crown a “dramatisation”.

The new season launches on 9 November around the world.

Netflix has been approached for comment.


Sian Cain

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
The Crown creator rejects criticism show is ‘unkind’ to King Charles amid row over facts
Peter Morgan says he has ‘enormous sympathy’ for royal family, while Netflix reportedly pauses Harry and Meghan documentary over criticism

Sian Cain

19, Oct, 2022 @3:08 AM

Article image
The Crown has slipped: how the Netflix epic captures our relationship with the royals
While the fourth series has come under fire for factual inaccuracy, it is just one of many series to reflect the royals’ long history of mythmaking

Phil Harrison

02, Dec, 2020 @11:00 AM

Article image
John Major dismisses The Crown as a ‘barrel-load of nonsense’
Former PM angered by fictitious storyline in which Charles seeks his help in getting the Queen to abdicate

Emine Sinmaz

16, Oct, 2022 @4:46 PM

Article image
The Crown season four, first look review – enter Diana, Thatcher, bombast and bomb blasts
The best series so far of the royal drama, with the family sliding into dysfunction and new characters providing 80s shoulder-padded spectacle

Rebecca Nicholson

10, Nov, 2020 @1:11 PM

Article image
'Famously the most Spanish city': The Crown mocked for lacklustre recreation of Australia
Episode six of the new season focuses on Charles and Diana’s 1983 tour of Australia – but none of it was shot there

Guardian staff

23, Nov, 2020 @4:17 AM

Article image
The Crown's fourth season: Charles and Diana tour Australia in festival of nostalgia
In the new episodes, which land on 15 November, we revisit the 1983 trip that marked the global rise of the ‘people’s princess’ – and the beginning of the end of her marriage

Alexandra Spring

09, Nov, 2020 @10:36 PM

Article image
Filming The Crown: on the set of the lavish Netflix series – in pictures
Photographer Sarah Lee gained exclusive access to Elstree Studios, production base of US-British series The Crown, created and written by Peter Morgan and produced by Left Bank Pictures

Sarah Lee and Guy Lane and Matt Fidler

01, Nov, 2016 @7:39 AM

Article image
Netflix has 'no plans' to add disclaimer that The Crown is work of fiction
Statement comes after the UK culture secretary said he was going to write to company to request caveat

Guardian staff and agencies

06, Dec, 2020 @7:41 PM

Article image
From The Crown to His Dark Materials: what's streaming in Australia in November
Plus love stories from New York, Deborah Mailman takes control, and a deep dive into the harrowing consequences of China’s one-child policy

Debbie Zhou

01, Nov, 2019 @5:00 AM

Article image
From The Crown to Misery: the best of film and TV streaming in Australia in December
This month, the Windsors struggle with modernity, a filmmaker seeks out an extinct bird, and Snoop Dogg and Martha Stewart host a bizarre dinner party

Lauren Carroll Harris

09, Dec, 2017 @11:09 PM