Jeremy Kyle Show: Death On Daytime review – a shocking exposé of the ITV series

This rigorous documentary brims with quiet fury as it looks at The Jeremy Kyle Show and the death of Steve Dymond, who killed himself in 2019, days after appearing

Jeremy Kyle Show: Death On Daytime (Channel 4) is a crass title for a rigorous documentary. There is a sense that an investigation like this has been a long time coming. The Jeremy Kyle Show ran for 3,320 episodes over 14 years on ITV, and was at times the channel’s most popular daytime show. More than 1 million viewers regularly watched as its guests argued over paternity, addiction, deceit and betrayal, while Kyle bayed and roared in their faces. ITV claimed, and continues to claim via a lengthy statement at the end of this film, that the aim of the show was to provide “conflict resolution” for its guests.

The documentary’s director Kira Phillips pieces together a different picture, and she does so with quiet fury. Steve Dymond was a guest on the show in May 2019, taking a lie detector test to prove to his partner, Jane, that he had not been unfaithful. The test said he was lying. The episode was never broadcast, because Dymond killed himself a few days after filming. Shortly afterwards, ITV cancelled the series with immediate effect.

The opening episode of this two-part documentary takes Dymond’s story as its tragic centrepiece. We hear from Dymond’s friends and from his ex-partner, Jane, who speaks with moving honesty about his life and state of mind. It sounds as if he had a problem with lying, and he knew it. One of his hopes was that by appearing on the show, he might receive some help for that. The other was simply that he wanted to prove that he had not cheated on Jane, and the show offered him a lie detector test that he would not have been able to pay for privately. He saw The Jeremy Kyle Show as a potential saviour.

“You go on the show because you’re desperate,” says a former member of the production team. Four ex-employees have spoken to the film-makers about their time on the show, on the condition that they would not be identified; instead, actors speak their words, which seems a reasonable compromise. They talk about manipulating the mental health questionnaire that they were supposed to go through with guests. They talk about a culture that not only expected conflict but actively encouraged it; one camera operator who worked backstage describes it as “back-to-back psychological carnage”. They say they would lie to the families of addicts by telling them that they were in competition for a place at rehab, when they were going to be given a place anyway. The idea, it seems, was to push them for a better performance, although we’re told that ITV denies this and are shown a statement that says: “ITV would never condone any of its production staff misleading or lying to guests.”

It is a difficult watch, for a great many reasons. Class is an ugly spectre, and looms large. One of the production team accuses Kyle of looking down on his guests, and in unbroadcast footage, we see him call his guests that day “thick as shit”. The judge who famously described the show as “a human form of bear-baiting under the guise of entertainment” when sentencing one guest convicted of ABH when he head-butted another guest (the show was not broadcast) is scathing about its claims of “conflict resolution”. That guest appears here to talk about the effect the conviction had on his life. He lost his job, his home was repossessed and his mental health suffered.

All of the interviewees here are dealing with pain, and there is a real rawness on display. The mother of a young woman who was addicted to heroin has complicated feelings about the show now. Her daughter was put into rehab as a result of appearing, yet watching Kyle berate her daughter on the show, where he speaks to her with such appalling venom and disdain – “What are you?”, “You’re disgusting” – is abhorrent. It is an awful indictment of social care funding in the UK that for many of these guests, a TV show that turned their trauma into entertainment appeared to be the only way that they could get the help they needed.

There are attempts to explain the popularity of the show by linking it to British comedies that parodied people on benefits, for example, though I think that is an easy target, and there is no mention of the US culture of confrontational chatshows that the The Jeremy Kyle Show clearly adopted. Considering that this is a story about exploitation, great care has been taken to avoid that here, but there are moments that made me feel uneasy; I am not sure what there was to be gained by allowing viewers to hear the distressed, sobbing final voicenotes that Dymond left for his ex-partner.

But overall, this is a withering account of how The Jeremy Kyle Show functioned. Hearing insiders talk about how it was made, and what they did, is incredibly powerful. If some of the details are shocking, they are not surprising; it was all there for 14 years, on screen.


Rebecca Nicholson

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
‘A catalogue of exploitation’: the maker of a documentary about the Jeremy Kyle Show speaks
A new Channel 4 programme exposes the horrific culture of the ITV series. Here, the documentary’s executive producer reveals the show’s awful mistreatment of guests and staff alike

Graeme McAulay

11, Mar, 2022 @6:13 PM

Article image
Sins of our Mother review – this true-crime series gets more shocking with every episode
Murder, religious fanaticism and a belief in the apocalypse combine in this impossibly twisty Netflix series about a ‘Doomsday mom’ – and the investigation into deaths in her family

Rebecca Nicholson

15, Sep, 2022 @5:00 AM

Article image
Murder Island review – a contest to solve the killing of a young woman? Bad timing
Teams of amateur detectives compete to crack a grisly case and win £50,000. So far, this new hybrid reality show seems half-baked and unpropitious

Lucy Mangan

05, Oct, 2021 @9:30 PM

Article image
Vicky Pattison: Alcohol, Dad and Me review – the reality star is an absolute gift of a presenter
The Geordie Shore reality TV star is a commanding, charismatic, honest and articulate presenter, as she tries to make sense of how her father’s drinking affected her upbringing

Lucy Mangan

02, Aug, 2022 @10:05 PM

Article image
What Are We Feeding Our Kids? review – junk food exposé will leave you queasy
One half of TV’s twin doctor duo, Chris van Tulleken, gorges on ultra-processed, sugar-and-salt-filled foods to find out whether profits are being put before our families’ health

Lucy Mangan

27, May, 2021 @9:00 PM

Article image
Our Father review – an undeniably gripping tale of a fertility doctor’s shocking crimes
There’s plenty of shock value in this Netflix documentary about a church elder who secretly impregnated many women. But it needed to ask more way questions about the law and anti-female bias

Lucy Mangan

11, May, 2022 @12:14 PM

Article image
Kate Garraway: Finding Derek review – devotion and honesty in the face of Covid
Following the GMB presenter as she copes with husband Derek Draper’s time in intensive care, this one-off documentary shows a human side behind the statistics

Lucy Mangan

23, Mar, 2021 @10:00 PM

Article image
Investigating Diana: Death in Paris review – like Making a Murderer meets the royals
To mark the 25th anniversary of the princess’s death, Channel 4 give events a lengthy true-crime treatment. How will they commemorate the 50th?

Stuart Jeffries

21, Aug, 2022 @9:00 PM

Article image
The Bridge review – the TV version of a dire corporate away-day
It was supposed to be a show about teamwork and logistics in the face of adversity. Instead, this quest to win £100,000 consists mostly of participants bickering and moaning

Rebecca Nicholson

25, Oct, 2020 @10:00 PM

Article image
Kathy Burke: Money Talks review – TV filler that’s 10 a penny
With trademark directness and authenticity, the actor offers glimpses of insight in this two-parter exploring wealth in Britain. However, analysis is severely lacking

Lucy Mangan

05, Jul, 2021 @10:05 PM