His Dark Materials series three review – Ruth Wilson is as seductive as Satan

The BBC’s singular adaptation of Philip Pullman’s trilogy concludes with astonishing CGI and fantastic performances – particularly the deliciously evil Wilson

‘We’ve lost the rear oscillator,” says the snow leopard to Lord Asriel. James McAvoy’s face tightens, because his fascinatingly realised steampunkish flying machine is on a collision course with what air crash investigators call, in their quaint way, the ground. How does he propose to complete the recruitment drive for his war against the Authority if his corpse ends up pulled from the wreckage? Let’s not even go there. “Brace!” he yells to his daemon as he activates an appealingly old-school parachute.

Welcome to the final series of His Dark Materials (BBC One), one that will cover the action of The Amber Spyglass, the last volume of Philip Pullman’s trilogy. How poignant that the BBC has chosen the festive season to broadcast Jack Thorne’s virtuosic adaptation of Pullman’s no-less virtuosic inversion of Milton’s Paradise Lost. Not that I’m complaining, but its appearance in the yuletide schedules does clinch the point that Christmas is not the season to celebrate the birth of our redeemer, but for rampant atheism – whether in the form of the worship of mammon or Pullman’s compelling broadside against organised religion.

While in Milton’s poem Satan and his cohorts are cast out from heaven, Pullman’s fantasy has it that the empyrean is already ruled by an angel just as hubristic and power-crazed as that would-be usurper. “For many millennia the Authority has ruled the kingdom of heaven with absolute control,” says one angel to another in a delicately animated sequence of diaphanous spirits in a starry skyscape. “He named himself the Creator, the Father, the Almighty. He is none of those but just an angel like us.” I’m no theologian but it’s a speech that problematises the narrative that around this time 2022 years ago the almighty sent his only son to wash away our sins.

Thorne doesn’t balk at dramatising these weighty theological matters. Indeed, this opening episode has a contemplative mood, fittingly because we’re in the calm before the storm when Asriel will lead his mustered forces against the Authority, with the aid of Will Parry and his subtle knife, not to mention our heroine Lyra Belacqua and her manifest destiny, which is to kill death and lead the deceased back to life.

Unfortunately, though, the action sequences are all sizzle and no steak. Will unleashes his subtle knife for a fight to the death with armoured polar bear Iorek Byrnison, but it comes to nothing. Drones fly overhead but there is no battle. Even the crash landing leaves Lord Asriel with his inexcusable pony tail unruffled.

Faster than you can say “red alethiometer, yellow alethiometer”, Asriel and his snow leopard dust themselves down and rush across the countryside to spring a potential ally, Commander Ogunwe, from jail. Asriel singlehandedly kills all the guards in a scene that misfires – there is no doubt he will triumph in this task, which puts the body count in inverse relation to dramatic tension.

The CGI is superlative, though. I really do believe that an armoured polar bear is prowling the decks of a fishing trawler and that Will Parry’s miraculous blade can cut through sky to take us to other worlds.

And how lovely to see Adewale Akinnuoye-Agbaje as Ogunwe. He excels as a sad-eyed father whose daughter has been kidnapped and had her daemon surgically severed before she makes it home, traumatised. There is one especially poignant moment where McAvoy glances as Akinnuoye-Agbaje with empathy and also with pained envy for what is missing in his life. Unlike Ogunwe, Lord Asriel cannot soothe his daughter. He has chosen to save the world rather than accept parental responsibilities.

This theme of what parenting involves here proves more engaging than all the theology and action of the first episode. Asriel is a bad dad but outdone in parenting by his ex, Ruth Wilson’s captivatingly evil Mrs Coulter. Kidnapping then chloroforming your daughter to stop her fulfilling her manifest destiny battling crypto-fascistic priests is in no parenting manual I’ve read.

William Blake wrote that Milton, in creating a compelling Satan, was of the devil’s party without knowing it. Pullman has perhaps equally unwittingly created something similar in Mrs Coulter. Certainly Ruth Wilson’s seductively satanic turn eclipses Nicole Kidman’s merely chilly performance of the same role in the 2007 film. Wilson’s Mrs Coulter 2.0 is one-third Margaret Thatcher, one-third Cruella de Vil and one-third eloquent eyebrows – plus a succession of burgundy tops and Oxford bags that make her quite the diabolical clothes horse. It will be sad to see her get her comeuppance.

  • His Dark Materials season three is available to watch on BBC One and BBC iPlayer in the UK, and on Foxtel and Binge in Australia.


Stuart Jeffries

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
I Am Ruth review – Kate Winslet is endlessly watchable
Both Winslet and her real-life daughter, Mia Threapleton, are brilliant in Dominic Savage’s film – whose tale of an emotional family standoff is full of malevolent beauty

Lucy Mangan

08, Dec, 2022 @11:05 PM

Article image
His Dark Materials series two review – Ruth Wilson brandishes TV's scariest tweezers
Smartphones, a mysterious CGI town, and a terrifying torture scene are among the draws as Jack Thorne’s steampunkish Philip Pullman adaptation returns to screens

Stuart Jeffries

08, Nov, 2020 @9:00 PM

Article image
Race Across the World series three review – one of the greatest reality shows gets its best cast ever
A gameshow, travel show and reality show all in one, this series is a messy celebration of human foibles, resilience, diversity and generosity. It will break your heart and cheer your soul

Jack Seale

22, Mar, 2023 @10:00 PM

Article image
Beef review – Ali Wong’s dark, existential thriller is deliciously subversive
Entertaining chaos and extremely funny dialogue result from this Netflix show about two rage-fuelled drivers having a life-affirming feud. It’s a rare delicacy

Ellen E Jones

06, Apr, 2023 @5:00 AM

Article image
A Murder at the End of the World review – Emma Corrin is utterly seductive as the ‘Gen Z Sherlock Holmes’
From the makers of The OA, this stylish mystery about a modern-day sleuth who wants to solve crimes and fix the climate crisis will wow you – unless you’re a die-hard cynic

Rebecca Nicholson

14, Nov, 2023 @5:00 AM

Article image
Scared of the Dark review – the stupidest reality show of all time
Boring, derivative and occasionally downright horrible, this series convinces celebrities to spend a week fumbling around a pitch-black bunker. It’s tedious in the extreme

Lucy Mangan

16, Apr, 2023 @9:15 PM

Article image
Africa Rising With Afua Hirsch review – 51 more episodes of this fascinating series please!
This skilful three-part documentary about Africa’s cultural renaissance looks at Nigeria, Morocco and South Africa. Expect everything from TikTok dances to the legacy of Fela Kuti

Leila Latif

13, Jun, 2023 @9:00 PM

Article image
The Lazarus Project series two review – the spectacular action scenes are worthy of Bond
This twisty time-loop thriller gets even more dramatic in its second outing. Paapa Essiedu’s George is a jittery joy in a smart, sharply scripted show that’s lots of fun to watch

Leila Latif

15, Nov, 2023 @10:00 PM

Article image
Boat Story review – Daisy Haggard’s hilariously dark drama is worthy of Tarantino or the Coen brothers
Funny, moody, moving and complex, the Williams brothers’ series about a couple who stumble upon a huge cocaine haul is as gripping as it is rewarding

Lucy Mangan

19, Nov, 2023 @10:10 PM

Article image
Time series two review – Jodie Whittaker shines a light on the idiocy of our legal system
The ex-Doctor puts in a brilliant performance alongside Bella Ramsey, as a jailed mum who isn’t allowed enough phone calls to get her kids looked after. It’s a powerful message

Lucy Mangan

29, Oct, 2023 @10:00 PM