Ready to Mingle: are we suffering from TV dating show fatigue?

ITV2’s complicated new series sees a single mingler pick one of 12 possible suitors, some of whom are already taken. It’s exhausting

Right, that’s it, it’s finally happened. The doctor just called and confirmed. I have Reality TV Dating Show Fatigue, a rare disorder that primarily affects TV reviewers and people whose girlfriends watched not one but both seasons of Too Hot to Handle. “A single episode of Celebs Go Dating on E4 has enough scenes of men in skinny jeans guessing the age of girls they are on dates with to kill you,” the doctor warned me. It is incredibly medically inadvisable that I do this – I have an EMT on hand and they’ve already dialled two nines – but: I am going to watch the first episode of the Katherine Ryan-fronted Ready to Mingle (Monday, 9pm, ITV2).

I was smart in primary school, and though that tailed off a lot during secondary I did manage to get OK A-levels, and I have a degree and I read a fair amount of books, so intellectually I think I am in decent enough shape. I am never going to be a change-the-world genius, but I think I’m bright enough to get through a dinner party without embarrassing myself. That said, I thought all this right up until I tried to understand the rules of Ready to Mingle, which … hold on, go through them one more time …


So there is a central woman, our mingler: the bright and beautiful Sophia, a design student from Brighton, who is single in that very damaged reality TV show fashion and has decided that the only way to now find love is to go through an elaborate, villa-based deduction game, a sort of horny Cluedo. And there are 12 boys, whom we spend more than half of the opening episode meeting. How many personal trainers will I watch throw their shirt off in front of a neon backdrop before I die? How many straightforward labourers with perfect teeth will I see rub their hands in slow motion before I succumb to the abyss?

Over the course of three weeks she has to deduce whether they are single and, ideally, fall in love with one of them along the way. If they are single, and they win the dating show, Sophia and the boy split the money. If they are not single, the boy and his actual partner split the money instead. Mustering the strength to semi-explain this has almost certainly pushed some more vital knowledge out of my head. I’m going to wake up tomorrow and not know what geography is.

I mean, it’s fine. It’s a Reality TV Dating Show. It has all the exact aesthetic markers of Love Island (white plastic wine glasses, men with six-packs sleeping in the same room, leather jackets worn like capes, conversations primarily held next to a swimming pool), but embellished with 2021’s favourite TV dynamic: “Someone is lying and you need to figure out who” (see: The Circle, or my personal TV highlight, This Is My House).

Katherine Ryan is doggedly keeping this train on the tracks – she is both the absolutely-loving-the-carnage presenter and the sniping narrator – and answers the question that TV executives must be asking themselves: “What if the host of Love Island actually enjoyed the show?”

This is all fine. But I can’t do this any more. This show lasts three weeks and my legs are already beset with tremors. Enjoy your little Reality TV Dating Show; I’m unplugging my laptop and heading towards the sea.

Contributor

Joel Golby

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Hello Stranger: the naff new dating show where couples lose their minds
Just when you thought 21st-century television had plumbed all available depths, here’s a programme that goes even lower

Fiona Sturges

02, Jun, 2018 @10:00 AM

Article image
The Bridge: a rugged reality show built on wobbly foundations
A bunch of under-30s flirt on crap rafts while a solitary 60-year-old fumes about it in Channel 4’s disappointing survival series

Joel Golby

10, Oct, 2020 @10:00 AM

Article image
Galdem Sugar: can a grime reality show ever work?
Instead of sipping cocktails and having fights, the female rappers work out in a dog poo-covered park in Edmonton

Issy Sampson

25, May, 2019 @10:00 AM

Article image
House Share: the BBC Three reality show that reveals why communism doesn’t work
When six 21-year-olds move to London and have to share every penny, disaster ensues. This is Boot on the Face TV

Joel Golby

09, Nov, 2019 @11:00 AM

Article image
When I Grow Up – the TV show that puts a seven-year-old in charge of Hello!
A group of kids are let loose in the media in this new ‘social experiment’, proving we are all doomed

Joel Golby

27, Apr, 2019 @10:00 AM

Article image
Maggot-eating and weeping in hammocks: what to expect from 2018’s I’m a Celebrity
From hunky mum favourites like Nick Knowles, to a barrage of tepid soap stars, here’s what might happen in the reality show camp

Joel Golby

16, Nov, 2018 @8:00 AM

Article image
Celebrity Ex in the City: not even Covid can stop this dating show cringefest
Celebs such as Calum Best and Megan Barton-Hanson try their best to find love – within social distancing guidelines, of course

Joel Golby

05, Dec, 2020 @11:00 AM

Article image
This Time Next Year: like Comic Relief without the laughs
With Davina McCall stuck in presenter purgatory, it’s unfortunate she’s destined to host saccharine sobfests such as this

Sam Wolfson

07, Apr, 2018 @10:00 AM

Article image
Seven Year Switch: Wife Swap with the looming threat of divorce
Four sets of spouses dispatched to an island to couple up with strangers … what could possibly go wrong?

Fiona Sturges

03, Mar, 2018 @11:00 AM

Article image
Five Star Hotel: shiny teeth, handsy pillocks and hostile hospitality
Take five celebrities, put them in charge of a fancy hotel … and hope for the worst

Fiona Sturges

10, Mar, 2018 @11:00 AM