Bachelorette Australia’s first Brooke Blurton episode is a triumph. I finally have my church back | Matilda Boseley

With its first bisexual and first Indigenous lead, the franchise may have saved itself – and its community

Some say love is like the warm breath of spring after a long cold winter. That’s exactly how I feel about Brooke Blurton’s season of The Bachelorette Australia, which premiered on Wednesday night.

That “winter” wasn’t the country’s economic downturn. It wasn’t Covid-19, or the months-long lockdowns.

It was the cruel, cold tundra of heterosexuality.

Brooke single handedly reviving the franchise#BacheloretteAU pic.twitter.com/U8Uu6AzUJt

— Rose Callaghan (Friendship Rose podcast!!) (@operation_rosie) October 20, 2021

I love The Bachelor franchise with all my heart. Not because it’s a masterpiece of modern cinema, but because of the community that is built around the show.

I watch it while on speakerphone to friends, scrolling social media for reactions, live tweeting and taking notes for the podcast I record with my dad. I often joke that reality TV is the closest thing non-religious Australians have to church, but deep down I do mean it.

And these last few years, the pews of that church have been nearly empty. Every Bachelor or Bachelorette season was the same. The formulaic nature of the show transformed from comforting to stale, the #BachelorAU hashtag was basically barren, and many of the funniest re-cappers were struggling to find interesting things to make fun of.

By the time Jimmy Nicholson’s season aired this year it seemed even the network had thrown in the towel. Network 10 denies it, but many suspect its choice to play multiple episodes back-to-back was an attempt to get the tanking season over with, and free up those prime Wednesday and Thursday time slots.

The diminished audience were resigned to the show probably not returning in 2022.

Then something magical happened. This year’s Bachelorette was announced: Brooke Blurton. She is the best possible choice for three reasons.

One: Blurton is the franchise’s most beloved alumni – a frontrunner in the Honey Badger’s 2018 season, and the star of Bachelor in Paradise season two. Australia knows her; viewers are invested in her happiness.

Two: she is the first Indigenous Australian to be cast as a lead. The sheer whiteness of the show’s previous seasons is unforgivable, and Blurton, a Noongar and Yamatji woman, has been a powerful voice when it comes to fighting for representation in prime time.

Three: she is bisexual – and rather than shy away from that, and lump her with the same old collection of 20 gym-rat dude-bros, the show’s producers decided to break the mould and present the world’s first mixed gender casting.

I am so brimming with joy & love in my heart ahead of tonight’s premier of The Bachelorette🌹
This is a moment fam - we are getting blak JOY on mainstream TV 😭🙌🏽 The focus not on deficit, trauma, or fear but on JOY & love. A pan, blak Bachie means so much 🌈🖤#BacheloretteAU

— Amy Thunig (@AmyThunig) October 20, 2021

Feeling SO connected to my bi+ community right now 💖💜💙 Twitter is on fire right now with #BacheloretteAU love. All the years of rampant biphobia ("Gold Star Lesbian" dating days/people telling me they don't date bi folks 🤮) feels worth it when representation so beautiful 🥲

— Zara 💫 (@zara_vts) October 20, 2021

As I queer woman, I was sceptical about the show’s ability to deal with these complicated themes – and I can only imagine those worries would have been amplified for First Nations fans. Cast members of colour have regularly been sidelined by the franchise and rarely make it to the second half of the season; the show has come under fire for egregious queer baiting; and the way it advertised Blurton’s same-gender fling with Alex Nation, in Paradise, felt distinctly voyeuristic.

The producers don’t seem to know it but the commentary community that props up the Australian Bachelor is extremely diverse and queer (the show is the epitome of camp, after all) – so we were all collectively holding our breath when 7.30pm Wednesday rolled around.

It's a new dawn, it's a new day and Brooke's ready to find her special someone 💕 The #BacheloretteAU coming soon to 10 and 10 Play on Demand. pic.twitter.com/Dnj8FUY2qs

— #BacheloretteAU (@BacheloretteAU) September 29, 2021

The show began with a careful discussion of Blurton’s complex family history, and how trauma has shaped but not defined her. We learned about how central her connection to culture is to her, and she spoke openly about her relationship with her sexuality.

As she stepped out of the limo she was met by three elders from the Bidjigal clan, who gave us the franchise’s first welcome to county. “While you’re here in Dharug country, may the good spirit Baiame watch over you from the high country and take you safely on your journey,” one said, as Blurton’s eyes welled.

Omg the Uncles 😭 #BacheloretteAU

— Madeline Hayman-Reber (@MadelineHayman) October 20, 2021

A welcome to country on a prime time dating show - big yes from me. The diversity in series is going to be special (if someone is disabled I’ll lose it ❤️🏳️‍🌈❤️) #BacheloretteAU

— Dylan Alcott (@DylanAlcott) October 20, 2021

Historic moment having not only the first bisexual bachelorette but the first Indigenous woman too. Proud of you tiddah 🖤💛❤️ #BacheloretteAU

— A M B E R (@fxckzaddy) October 20, 2021

Collectively, we breathed a sigh of relief. Sure, the show was way too self-congratulatory about it, given it took it eight years to get here – 19 years if you include the international iterations but, if the first episode is anything to go by, it seems this season could actually be handled with surprising grace.

The worn-out tropes of every first episode so far were immediately turned on their head by mixed-gender contestants. Normally all the men would be beating their chests, starting ego-fuelled fights to speak to the Bachelorette first, but now they were hanging back, intimidated by the confidence of the queer women. By the end of the episode, the women were even coaching the men on how to flirt with Blurton.

I might actually root for some of these men again, now that they’ve been forced to give up the bravado – and watching the friendships and rivalries form across gender lines is already fascinating.

Best of all, the season’s first same-gender kiss was played totally straight (pardon the pun), without a trace of reality TV’s usual “look how hot it is the two women are kissing” energy.

like i knew this season was going to be incredibly important and iconic but i didn’t fully grasp that until now like…goosebumps #BacheloretteAU

— eilish gilligan (@eilishgilligan) October 20, 2021

My favourite part of this show so far is how inadequate all the men feel, and honestly I’m living for it 👏 #BacheloretteAU

— Elle - AZ x 2 (@elizardqueen92) October 20, 2021

The show isn’t perfect, by any means. The cast is still largely white; masc queer women, non-binary and trans people don’t seem to be represented at all; and there is a weird “team men v team women” thing going on in the mansion. But this more diverse season seems to have been exactly what the franchise needed.

the audacity of having the tradie be a man and not a butch lesbian, a crime #Bacheloretteau pic.twitter.com/NKyXtT73bE

— let's find brooke a wife (@bachiewatch) October 20, 2021

Ratings still aren’t where they were in the show’s heyday, coming in 14th in the overall ratings with 397,000 live viewers – but Blurton’s season had already amassed enough hype that the network renewed The Bachelor and The Bachelorette for 2022 before her first episode even aired.

I know it isn’t cool to care this much about reality TV but I cried scrolling through Twitter, my feed filled with Bachelorette jokes, hot takes and memes. Now that the show actually looks like the people who once adored it, the community has returned in droves. I finally have my church back.

• The Bachelorette Australia continues on Thursday at 7.30pm on Ten. Catch up here

Contributor

Matilda Boseley

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Brooke Blurton on the Bachelorette Australia backlash: ‘I was frustrated with the level of biphobia’
Reeling from the online hate that followed the finale, the show’s first Indigenous bisexual lead opens up about the anguish of losing her sister, finding love with Darvid Garayeli and why she’s ‘bloody proud’

Matilda Boseley

26, Nov, 2021 @10:08 PM

Article image
Brooke Blurton’s Bachelorette Australia changed the conversation – and I’ve never talked more about being bisexual | Matilda Boseley
Having a queer Noongar-Yamatji woman as the star has normalised same-gender relationships – and started discussions around Indigenous history

Matilda Boseley

25, Nov, 2021 @11:18 PM

Article image
How Sophie Monk's toxic Bachelorette men reveal the reality behind TV
Sophie Monk may have won Australia’s heart, but the same can’t be said for some of the men trying to woo her

Stephanie Convery

25, Oct, 2017 @7:02 AM

Article image
Behind the scenes of reality TV: 'You're a little bit daft to apply'
Manipulation is rife on reality TV, with producers often lying to contestants, depriving them of sleep and exploiting weaknesses in the name of manufacturing drama

Elle Hunt

11, Jan, 2017 @10:58 PM

Article image
Osher Günsberg: the TV host on anxiety, dating and if there'll be a gay Bachelor
After years on reality TV helping contestants through vulnerable moments, The Bachelor host tells Brigid Delaney about his own experiences of opening up

Brigid Delaney

18, Feb, 2019 @5:00 PM

Article image
From Upright to Get Krack!n: the eight most memorable moments in Australian TV in 2019
Plus Deborah Mailman takes Total Control, Frayed shows a different side to 1980s Newcastle, and 60 Minutes outdoes itself on hyperbole

Steve Dow, Nathan Dunne, Steph Harmon, Gabriel Wilder, Clarissa Sebag-Montefiore, Stephanie Convery, Luke Buckmaster

28, Dec, 2019 @7:00 PM

Article image
The Bachelor Australia’s diversity problem will be its death knell. Just ask the magazine industry | Grace O'Neill
At a time when we’re desperately in need of frothy distractions, why can’t we get a fantasy we feel good about indulging in?

Grace O'Neill

08, Sep, 2020 @5:30 PM

Article image
From The Block to The Bachelor, reality TV product placement has reached dizzying new lows
Subtlety is out and cringeworthy storyline integration is in for brands across Australian reality shows. But do viewers appreciate it?

Katy Hall

12, Oct, 2021 @3:34 AM

Article image
First Contact: When Indigenous Australia becomes entertainment, everyone loses | Jack Latimore
Stereotypes and falsehoods go uninterrogated on a magical mystery tour of black Australia

Jack Latimore

01, Dec, 2016 @10:30 AM

Article image
Reputation Rehab: can reality TV rescue public figures from a lifetime of cancellation?
From Nick Krygios to Abbie Chatfield, the ABC’s new show aims to give makeovers to those maligned by the public

Brigid Delaney

27, Oct, 2020 @4:30 PM