Max Clifford: The Fall of a Tabloid King review – scandal at the heart of Fleet Street

Though not quite a hagiography, this one-off documentary – heavy on archive clips – comes close to glamorising the way in which the serially abusive publicist operated

There appears to be no reason for the documentary Max Clifford: The Fall of a Tabloid King (Channel 4) – there is no anniversary of his arrest, charge or conviction on eight counts of indecent assault against four victims, or of his death three years into serving his eight-year sentence. However, we do not live in an age when a documentary about the symbiotic relationship between celebrity, handler-slash-story-supplier and media editors, or the ways in which a man in a position of power and influence used it to exploit young women and children, can ever be called untimely.

Rather, we’re at a point where the latter story, especially, has become almost too common to merit comment. The greatest question such retrospective anatomisations used to try to answer was: “How did they get away with it for so long?” Now, the one that looms most unavoidably with every fresh story – about an apparently cuddly TV presenter, popular light entertainer, R&B star, Olympic sports coach and so on – is: do men seek power and influence for any other reason than to abuse it? We’re getting to the point, surely, where it’s better and safer to move forward on the accepted basis that anyone rich and famous has become so because they need the protective trappings that come with it – including a large network of enablers and/or people cowed into silence – in order to satisfy the kind of desires that would otherwise quickly get them arrested.

But whether power always corrupts (or the corrupt always secure power) is a different – deeper and darker – question than documentaries like this one, devoted to a single figure treated as an anomaly, pose. The first half was dedicated to Clifford’s rise as a publicist, supplying exclusives that could net a paper an extra 100,000 sales a day, until he eventually sat like a spider at the heart of the tabloid web, throwing out threads of story here, binding and biting the necks of paralysed victims there. In a lockdown-friendly format, talking heads are interviewed singly, their insights interspersed with clips of the plentiful footage of Clifford and his clients from the decades that he was the nonpareil supplier of celebrity stories and scandals to Fleet Street.

As the film worked its way through the “Freddie Starr ate my hamster” and David Mellor/Antonia de Sancha years, it also covered the barely concealed sex parties Clifford held, involving young women whose enthusiasm he always proclaimed was genuine and unbounded. They – or at least the ones who spoke to Mail on Sunday investigator Nick Fielding for a piece he started putting together in the 1990s to clip Clifford’s wings – recalled it differently. Clifford was a keen voyeur and had compromising photographs of many unwitting individuals who crossed his path taken from hidden vantage points. It all helped. Fielding’s piece never made it to print. He never found out why.

So much footage of Clifford’s greatest hits was played, as former editors lined up to attest – heads shaking in wonderment – to Clifford’s talent for stories, showmanship and shifting units. At these moments, the programme skirted perilously close to, if not hagiography, then at least glamorisation of how far and how fast you can go as a man without conscience.

The programme was saved by interviews with the women who eventually testified against Clifford at trial. Foremost was “Kate”, whom Clifford had groomed since he met her when she was 15, blackmailing her into continuing their sexual relationship when she tried to detach from him. After she came forward, so did many, many other women, from all over the country, independent witnesses corroborating each others’ accounts of Clifford’s tricks, methods and lies.

The Fall of a Tabloid King remained, overall, an essentially superficial look at a profound problem. It hinted occasionally at the greater depths (most notably when it asked Neil Wallis, former deputy editor both of the Sun and the News of the World, if he thought Fleet Street was complicit in Clifford’s success as a serial abuser. He could muster no more after a long, long pause than: “It’s just complicated”), but didn’t plumb them. But because we are so familiar now with the story and the pattern of predators, producers need to dive deeper to avoid effectively fetishising them (as they have always done with serial killers). We, and above all, their victims, deserve better. Better questions, and better answers.

Contributor

Lucy Mangan

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Stalkers review – Stacey Dooley is perfect in this utterly terrifying documentary
Women who live in fear of obsessed former partners open their hearts to a gifted presenter with the common touch

Lucy Mangan

19, Jan, 2022 @11:20 PM

Article image
The Celebrity Circle review – 'catfishing Big Brother' is hard to quit
Watching famous people try to win over others by force of their own personality – or maybe someone else’s – makes for a compelling spinoff of the surprise TV hit

Rebecca Nicholson

09, Mar, 2021 @10:30 PM

Article image
Cooking With Paris review – Hilton in the kitchen? Prepare to have your mind blown
The Netflix show sees the heiress whip up ‘meals’ of glitter and gold with the likes of Kim Kardashian. But can someone really go through life without knowing what a whisk is?

Lucy Mangan

04, Aug, 2021 @12:03 PM

Article image
Taken: Hunting the Sex Traffickers review – stomach-turning tales of abuse and exploitation
Stories of women bought and sold ‘like meat’ and the criminal gangs enjoying lavish lifestyles at their expense are under the spotlight in this disturbing documentary

Lucy Mangan

26, Jul, 2021 @9:00 PM

Article image
Four Lives review – truly damning TV about those who are meant to protect and serve
Stephen Merchant and Sheridan Smith star in the BBC’s mind-boggling story of the murders by serial killer and rapist Stephen Port … and the egregious police failures that followed

Lucy Mangan

03, Jan, 2022 @10:00 PM

Article image
Stephen review – Steve Coogan is the cop who cracks the Lawrence case after 13 years of lies
In this riveting drama, Coogan stars as DCI Clive Driscoll, who finally investigates the racist killing of Stephen Lawrence fully, underlining the extra years of agony his parents had to endure

Lucy Mangan

30, Aug, 2021 @9:00 PM

Article image
Animal review: sorry celebrities – Attenborough’s still the lion king
Netflix’s globe-trotting wildlife show boasts stunning visuals and voiceovers from Rebel Wilson, Bryan Cranston and Rashida Jones – but tells us next to nothing about the natural world

Stuart Jeffries

10, Nov, 2021 @2:56 PM

Article image
A Killing in Tiger Bay review – a rigorous examination of justice unserved
This three-part series takes an unsensationalist approach in recounting how police pursued five innocent men for the murder of Lynette White in Cardiff in 1988

Lucy Mangan

09, Sep, 2021 @9:00 PM

Article image
Mare of Easttown finale review – Kate Winslet drama is a stunning, harrowing success
The actor’s turn as a complex, fallible detective has been a privilege to witness, in a murder mystery that kept us guessing right to the profoundly moving end

Lucy Mangan

31, May, 2021 @9:15 PM

Article image
TV tonight: Max Clifford’s survivors tell their stories
A feature-length film focuses on their long fight for justice. Plus: MasterChef is back. Here’s what to watch this evening

Ammar Kalia, Phil Harrison, Ali Catterall, Jack Seale and Paul Howlett

01, Mar, 2021 @6:20 AM