MasterChef Australia elimination recap: oh, for the love of cod!

Josh Niland returns to put the contestants through their fish-butchering paces and bring the wrath of cod down upon them

It was a chance for redemption in the poultry shed this week on MasterChef Australia as the eliminated contestants returned for one of two chances to rejoin the competition.

Pastry chef Anthony Hart took the baton of tempered chocolate torture from Kirsten Tibballs and commanded the returnees recreate his “chocolate oasis”, which I’m pretty sure I saw in a cubism group show at MoMA. Minoli triumphed and absolutely lost it, which was incredibly endearing.

Finally, the final four of the returnees suffered through a three-course menu challenge final(e]. Maja’s deconstructed Splice, made using the skills she’d attained during her post-elimination work experience, secured her return to white-apron status alongside Minoli.

And so Sunday rolls around, bringing with it another lighthearted fish butchery session. Yes, the human manifestation of one of those “Fish Fear Me” dad caps is back, welcoming the contestants by laying out his weaponry. It’s Josh Niland, everybody!

I draw the jury’s attention to exhibits A through H
I draw the jury’s attention to exhibits A through H. Photograph: Network 10

Brent immediately forgets how much he enjoyed making fancy desserts and declares himself a fish butchery fanboy. Josh stands behind a hapless Murray cod: “I’m going to take this one fish and show you how to make it disappear … ” he teases, as I ready myself to be dazzled by sleight of hand, “... into three courses!” Hang on, this isn’t the junior championships of closeup magic??

“Oh my cod,” says Justin, possessed by the pun-mad spirit of The Goodies.

♬ When it’s spring again, I’ll bring again, tulips from Amsterdam! ♬
♬ When it’s spring again, I’ll bring again, tulips from Amsterdam! ♬ Photograph: Network 10

Josh turns one cod into a “three-piece feed” entree, a roast with crackling, and finally a lamington with crystallised Murray cod scales. It’s a masterclass in inventive, low-waste butchery (ditching only the gills and gallbladder) that leaves the contestants with Car City eyes. “And again, this is something that you can all achieve,” he says, to gales of disbelieving laughter.

It’s such a sustained display of witchcraft that by the time Josh turns fish scales into the lamington’s desiccated coconut I’m ready to sentence him to death by pressing.

It’s to be a three-round, three-course challenge: the contestants have to butcher their own Murray cod and stretch it out across a potential three dishes.

Looks like your cod has forsaken you
Looks like your cod has forsaken you. Photograph: Network 10

Fifteen minutes into round 1 and the contestants have said “hectic” roughly 40 times.

Brent nearly puts his peanuts into Scott’s oven, as the bishop said to the improv troupe, but it’s all good, because Josh reckons Brent’s fish tacos “were worth getting your apron dirty” for.

Fish tacos
‘I had y’all over here for dinner: fish tacos! And this is how you do me?’ Photograph: Network 10

There’s praise, too, for Tommy, Justin, Depinder and Josh’s No 1 fan Sabina, whose barbecued cod belly he describes as “the perfect canapé”.

When senpai finally notices you :3
When senpai finally notices you :3 Photograph: Network 10

Dan’s fish skin has gone rubbery. Amir’s sauce is off. There’s worse news for Minoli, whose cod is raw but whose sauce and sambal is so good that Mel and Josh cry out her name “MENDOZA!!” style.

‘Minoliiiiii!!!’ Photograph: Network 10

It’s on to round 2 for Linda, Pete, Kishwar, Amir, Maja, Dan and Minoli, with 45 minutes to try again with what’s left of their cod.

Minoli is cooking the same dish again but “jazzing it up”; hey, if it ain’t cooked, don’t nix it, or whatever the old phrase is. Amir’s making fancy fish fingers, summoning the spirit of Captain Fishface. (BRB, changing my PhD research topic to cod in British TV comedy.) “It looks sick, smells good,” offers Justin from the gantry, readying himself to win the Pulitzer for food criticism.

It’s time to taste. Pete’s up first, and as soon as Jock cuts into the poached cod, he stares deep into Pete’s soul: “Mate, I’m just gonna call it: this was not your round. Welcome to round 3.” As cod is my witness, he is broken in half!!!

If you look closely you can actually pinpoint the exact moment his heart breaks in two.
If you look closely you can actually pinpoint the exact moment his heart breaks in two. Photograph: Network 10

It’s better news for Linda, whose fried cod tail and loin with tamarind and chilli sauce sends the judges into apoplexies of pleasure.

Josh declares that Maja’s dish, with minor adjustments, would be “on the menu tomorrow”.

Kishwar’s is “wonderful”! Then we begin the slow slide into the abyss. Amir’s fish fingers are “enjoyable” but not amazing. Dan’s eggplant chips are soggy despite his “ripping” sauce.

Minoli gives the judges deja vu with her second take on round 1’s raw fish fantasia, and … “That is easily the best plate of food today,” Josh declares. It’s so good it’s given him goosebumps. Minoli lives!!

Goosebumps by Minoli L Stine
Goosebumps by Minoli L Stine. Photograph: Network 10

It’s left to Pete, Amir (“The salad was irrelevant”) and Dan to duke it out in round 3, with 60 minutes to bring it home. Dan’s doing laksa. Amir is going full Josh and using every bit of the cod he has left, impressing Jock and Andy. It’s a different story at Pete’s bench, where he’s “going to poach cod again”.

“I need you guys to like it,” Pete says, describing a truly revolting-sounding blanched fish skin. Andy makes an expression that will soon replace the Oxford English Dictionary entry for “duh”.

At time’s up, Dan is already crying. He’s given the competition his all but he’s not happy with his laksa. Dan, no!!

“Dear cod, if you’re listening … ”
‘Dear cod, if you’re listening … ’ Photograph: Network 10

Pete’s “elegant, very minimalist” dish is declared “a knockout”. Dan’s dish is “just a laksa”, and Amir’s Turkish dumpling “has potential”, but it’s Dan who the judges reckon left out the best remaining cuts of cod, so he’s going home. And may cod bless us, every one.

What made me cry:

Dan declaring that his MasterChef journey was the “second best” time of his life after his wedding day, and insisting that the true treasure was the friends he made along the way.

The white chocolate velouté award for failure:

Every attempt Pete made to cook bog-standard food. Remember yourself, Pete! You’re the ASMR-voiced master of weird stuff! Next week I wanna see candied pumpkin skin 10 ways floating in a frozen warrigal greens consommé, not “poached cod and tomato bisque”!!

‘How do you do, fellow Tuesday night suburban bistro meals?’
‘How do you do, fellow Tuesday night suburban bistro meals?’ Photograph: Network 10

This article was corrected on 7 June 2021. Sabina cooked cod belly, not pork belly.


Clem Bastow

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
MasterChef Australia elimination recap: psychic agony and fever dreams. But make it TV!
This week was one for the lovers of cliche – and also the lovers of nuanced and beguilingly obscure descriptors of food

Clem Bastow

09, May, 2021 @9:37 PM

Article image
MasterChef Australia elimination recap: beef, bromance and bad ice-cream
Masters Week brought forth the hellish world of tempered chocolate – but the real pressure test came from the pressure cooker

Clem Bastow

16, May, 2021 @5:30 PM

Article image
MasterChef Australia elimination recap: 50 ways to cleave your supper
Nu Nu’s Nick Holloway puts the contestants through their paces with a 50-ingredient taste test

Clem Bastow

20, Jun, 2021 @11:10 AM

Article image
MasterChef Australia elimination recap: black box fright recorder
A two-stage, two-elimination challenge puts the contestants through the emotional wringer

Clem Bastow

27, Jun, 2021 @11:15 AM

Article image
MasterChef Australia elimination recap: final three revealed in semifinal countdown
In a fine dining frenzy, Elise, Justin and Kishwar battle one last service challenge en route to glory

Clem Bastow

11, Jul, 2021 @11:15 AM

Article image
MasterChef Australia elimination recap: it’s time to play the game
With Melissa away, Jock and Andy unleash their worst game-related puns on a mystery meat challenge

Clem Bastow

30, May, 2021 @11:10 AM

Article image
MasterChef Australia elimination recap: a fan favourite
A duel to the finish ends in a reminder: some things are more important than nailing the brief

Clem Bastow

13, Jun, 2021 @11:15 AM

Article image
MasterChef Australia elimination recap: fast food, fine dining and a forlorn farewell ahead of finals week
Seven cooks face the last challenge before finals week, bringing us delicious food before a heartbreaking goodbye

Clem Bastow

04, Jul, 2021 @11:15 AM

Article image
Junior MasterChef weekly recap: 'I'm about to cry!'
In the second week of the series, the tiny cooks are confronted with tough challenges and the spectre of their own mortality

Meg Watson

20, Oct, 2020 @8:58 PM

Article image
MasterChef Australia 2020: the highs, lows and talking points that made this season a hit
The grand finale was a celebration of friendship – but it was conversations about race and diversity in food that defined Back to Win

Helen Sullivan

20, Jul, 2020 @8:11 PM